M ODELING R ESOURCE S HARING D YNAMICS OF V O IP USERS OVER A WLAN U SING A G AME -T HEORETIC A...

23
MODELING RESOURCE SHARING DYNAMICS OF VOIP USERS OVER A WLAN USING A GAME-THEORETIC APPROACH INFOCOM 2008 Edson H. Watanabe, Daniel S. Menasch´e, Edmundo de Souza e Silva, Rosa M. M. Le˜ao Systems Engineering and Computer Science Department COPPE - Federal University of Rio de Janeiro, 21941-590 - Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil Presenter: Po-Jung Wang

Transcript of M ODELING R ESOURCE S HARING D YNAMICS OF V O IP USERS OVER A WLAN U SING A G AME -T HEORETIC A...

Page 1: M ODELING R ESOURCE S HARING D YNAMICS OF V O IP USERS OVER A WLAN U SING A G AME -T HEORETIC A PPROACH INFOCOM 2008 Edson H. Watanabe, Daniel S. Menasch´e,

MODELING RESOURCE SHARING DYNAMICS OF VOIP USERS OVER A WLAN USING A GAME-THEORETIC APPROACHINFOCOM 2008

Edson H. Watanabe, Daniel S. Menasch´e, Edmundo de Souza e Silva, Rosa M. M. Le˜ao

Systems Engineering and Computer Science Department

COPPE - Federal University of Rio de Janeiro, 21941-590 - Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil

Presenter: Po-Jung Wang

Page 2: M ODELING R ESOURCE S HARING D YNAMICS OF V O IP USERS OVER A WLAN U SING A G AME -T HEORETIC A PPROACH INFOCOM 2008 Edson H. Watanabe, Daniel S. Menasch´e,

OUTLINE

Scenario Introduction Game-theoretic model Simulation Experiment Result Conclusion

Page 3: M ODELING R ESOURCE S HARING D YNAMICS OF V O IP USERS OVER A WLAN U SING A G AME -T HEORETIC A PPROACH INFOCOM 2008 Edson H. Watanabe, Daniel S. Menasch´e,

SCENARIO – COFFEE SHOP

Page 4: M ODELING R ESOURCE S HARING D YNAMICS OF V O IP USERS OVER A WLAN U SING A G AME -T HEORETIC A PPROACH INFOCOM 2008 Edson H. Watanabe, Daniel S. Menasch´e,

AIRPORT

Page 5: M ODELING R ESOURCE S HARING D YNAMICS OF V O IP USERS OVER A WLAN U SING A G AME -T HEORETIC A PPROACH INFOCOM 2008 Edson H. Watanabe, Daniel S. Menasch´e,

USING VOIP THROUGH THE WIFI

Page 6: M ODELING R ESOURCE S HARING D YNAMICS OF V O IP USERS OVER A WLAN U SING A G AME -T HEORETIC A PPROACH INFOCOM 2008 Edson H. Watanabe, Daniel S. Menasch´e,

NOW WE HAVE TWO QUESTIONS

What are the performance consequences of letting the users to freely choose their rates?

How to explain the adaptation process of the users?

Page 7: M ODELING R ESOURCE S HARING D YNAMICS OF V O IP USERS OVER A WLAN U SING A G AME -T HEORETIC A PPROACH INFOCOM 2008 Edson H. Watanabe, Daniel S. Menasch´e,

MODELING

Page 8: M ODELING R ESOURCE S HARING D YNAMICS OF V O IP USERS OVER A WLAN U SING A G AME -T HEORETIC A PPROACH INFOCOM 2008 Edson H. Watanabe, Daniel S. Menasch´e,

GAME THEORY EQUATION

Page 9: M ODELING R ESOURCE S HARING D YNAMICS OF V O IP USERS OVER A WLAN U SING A G AME -T HEORETIC A PPROACH INFOCOM 2008 Edson H. Watanabe, Daniel S. Menasch´e,

SYMMETRIC STRATEGIC GAME

N is the number of users that share the access point. S is the discrete set of strategies available, that is, the set of joint codec plus FEC mechanisms that any application user can select from. U is the utility function.

Page 10: M ODELING R ESOURCE S HARING D YNAMICS OF V O IP USERS OVER A WLAN U SING A G AME -T HEORETIC A PPROACH INFOCOM 2008 Edson H. Watanabe, Daniel S. Menasch´e,
Page 11: M ODELING R ESOURCE S HARING D YNAMICS OF V O IP USERS OVER A WLAN U SING A G AME -T HEORETIC A PPROACH INFOCOM 2008 Edson H. Watanabe, Daniel S. Menasch´e,
Page 12: M ODELING R ESOURCE S HARING D YNAMICS OF V O IP USERS OVER A WLAN U SING A G AME -T HEORETIC A PPROACH INFOCOM 2008 Edson H. Watanabe, Daniel S. Menasch´e,

WHAT IS MOS?

Mean opinion score (MOS)

MOS Quality Impairment

5 Excellent Imperceptible

4 Good Perceptible but not annoying

3 Fair Slightly annoying

2 Poor Annoying

1 Bad Very annoying

Page 13: M ODELING R ESOURCE S HARING D YNAMICS OF V O IP USERS OVER A WLAN U SING A G AME -T HEORETIC A PPROACH INFOCOM 2008 Edson H. Watanabe, Daniel S. Menasch´e,

PERSPECTIVE FROM ONE USER

low, 20 kbps (Speex 6 kpbs, FEC 1:2::3:6);

medium, 33.6 kbps (Speex 14.2 kbps, FEC 1:2)

high, 47.5 kbps (Speex 14.2 kps, FEC 1:2::3:6).

Page 14: M ODELING R ESOURCE S HARING D YNAMICS OF V O IP USERS OVER A WLAN U SING A G AME -T HEORETIC A PPROACH INFOCOM 2008 Edson H. Watanabe, Daniel S. Menasch´e,

SYSTEM SATURATION THROUGHPUT TESTING

Page 15: M ODELING R ESOURCE S HARING D YNAMICS OF V O IP USERS OVER A WLAN U SING A G AME -T HEORETIC A PPROACH INFOCOM 2008 Edson H. Watanabe, Daniel S. Menasch´e,
Page 16: M ODELING R ESOURCE S HARING D YNAMICS OF V O IP USERS OVER A WLAN U SING A G AME -T HEORETIC A PPROACH INFOCOM 2008 Edson H. Watanabe, Daniel S. Menasch´e,
Page 17: M ODELING R ESOURCE S HARING D YNAMICS OF V O IP USERS OVER A WLAN U SING A G AME -T HEORETIC A PPROACH INFOCOM 2008 Edson H. Watanabe, Daniel S. Menasch´e,
Page 18: M ODELING R ESOURCE S HARING D YNAMICS OF V O IP USERS OVER A WLAN U SING A G AME -T HEORETIC A PPROACH INFOCOM 2008 Edson H. Watanabe, Daniel S. Menasch´e,
Page 19: M ODELING R ESOURCE S HARING D YNAMICS OF V O IP USERS OVER A WLAN U SING A G AME -T HEORETIC A PPROACH INFOCOM 2008 Edson H. Watanabe, Daniel S. Menasch´e,

EQUILIBRIUM STATES FOR THE MODEL AND THE EXPERIMENT

Page 20: M ODELING R ESOURCE S HARING D YNAMICS OF V O IP USERS OVER A WLAN U SING A G AME -T HEORETIC A PPROACH INFOCOM 2008 Edson H. Watanabe, Daniel S. Menasch´e,

TRANSIENT PROBABILITY

Page 21: M ODELING R ESOURCE S HARING D YNAMICS OF V O IP USERS OVER A WLAN U SING A G AME -T HEORETIC A PPROACH INFOCOM 2008 Edson H. Watanabe, Daniel S. Menasch´e,

PROBABILITY FORM ONE STATE TO ANOTHER

Page 22: M ODELING R ESOURCE S HARING D YNAMICS OF V O IP USERS OVER A WLAN U SING A G AME -T HEORETIC A PPROACH INFOCOM 2008 Edson H. Watanabe, Daniel S. Menasch´e,

LETTING USER EXIT THE SYS IF MOS IS TO LOW

Page 23: M ODELING R ESOURCE S HARING D YNAMICS OF V O IP USERS OVER A WLAN U SING A G AME -T HEORETIC A PPROACH INFOCOM 2008 Edson H. Watanabe, Daniel S. Menasch´e,

SUMMARY AND CONCLUSION

Free users with local information can reach an equilibrium which is close to optimal from the system perspective. However, the equilibrium can be unfair.

Using a game-theoretic model and propose a methodology to parameterize it.

Strength and weekness

Discovery the phenomena of letting user to freely choose

Need more scalable experiments