Mercado Interno Colonial e Grau de Autonomia- Críticas Às Propostas de João Luís Fragoso e...

25
EST. ECON., SÃO PAULO, V. 31, N. 2, P. 369-393, ABRIL-JUNHO 2001 Mercado Interno Colonial e Grau de Autonomia: Críticas às Propostas de João Luís Fragoso e Manolo Florentino Eduardo Barros Mariutti Doutorando em História Econômica do Instituto de Economia da UNICAMP Luiz Paulo Ferreira Nogueról Doutorando em História Econômica do Instituto de Economia da UNICAMP Mário Danieli Neto Mestrando em História Econômica do Instituto de Economia da UNICAMP RESUMO O presente artigo critica algumas das proposições apresentadas recentemente por dois dos mais conhecidos membros do que se tem convencionado chamar Escola do Rio: João Luís Fragoso e Manolo Florentino. Com relação a elas, pomos em dúvida o seguinte: os movi- mentos internacionais dos preços do açúcar e do café indicando a introversão dos ritmos de crescimento econômico, a extensão ao período colonial das análises feitas pelos autores com base em documentos datados entre 1790 e 1840, a crítica ao que eles chamam de modelos tradicionais da historiografia brasileira e o significado das relações de troca existentes entre as economias do que hoje chamamos Regiões Sul e Sudeste do Brasil. PALAVRAS-CHAVE economia colonial, mercado interno ABSTRACT This paper presents some critics for the statemens made recently by two of the most known members from the so called Rio Schoool: João Luís Fragoso and Manolo Florentino. Specifically, we are in doubt about: the international coffee and sugar prices feature, between 1790 and 1840 in Rio, showing the internal growth capability, the extension of their conclusions to all the colonial period, the critics to the traditional models of brazilian historiography and the meaning of trade relationships between the differents economies of the today called South and Southwest Brazilian Regions. KEY WORDS Brazilian colonial economy, national market JEL Classification: N01

description

artigo.

Transcript of Mercado Interno Colonial e Grau de Autonomia- Críticas Às Propostas de João Luís Fragoso e...

  • !"#$%&'

    ()&*+"$",

    +-."&

    /*0&'-

    12341564*'!

    78- -

    0!9#::(

    *

    ;-

  • !"#$%$##$'!&(!)")%#$#*'!

    +% #$,#!)-./!01)$

    !"!#$#!%"!##&'()##%%##$*%'+$

    '%#$$,%#-./'$0'#!$.+#%!$%##($$#'

    !' $% .$(#' 1!2 .3$ %# $ 45 5 $%2 !'

    %#'67$'$'%'!''.#'#%#'

    '#$.2%#'%"!##!.##%8.%##$$#3#%#

    $##$%#''$%#"!#9#'.$#5$#2'.:/

    %7'.!$':/%#!'#$!!$#$%%%#!'

    8*.$8.$2"!#/.%##$$#%!9%#-!3'##;!*:/'

    '#$8.#1 2'$/2?65'2.$2%#

    %#!''.##'#3$#'%#$:/)!1#.$#',

    %!$.%#'#$%@'629:/%3'!%

    +'.$##03#5'#'#'.#-#'.$!$%%##$#

    %3#$7##$#$#:A#%#%!'%#'!$#.#3

    '#$8.#"!#8!'#!%#.#0.%#$$#3#$5

    .$.#$.$#:A#($#.#$0%#'.'#%!

    %'#A#%.$(#'2#'($$(!'.#%#$#%%!'

    %#-$#'5#$3%%#$%#'%#"!#A#2!$*$'!''##

    3#!%($#.###3%##'.#&%.#'#$%#$

    75$#%#!''#$.,%#%*$%#!%%##-.$%$

    "!#2.$ !3#92%#.#%#' #$'##%%#'% #$!2

    .# $B$2 ##'#$% .$## !'%''.$8.$2 "!#

    #$# !' #$ !' # .( $$, %# !'!:A#

    #%8*#7C%*:/+7%.#$.#3$'!%

    .$4$*#4$#2"!.$##%#'%!$##$*5

    34546(

    6

    '##! !7+*# #*#8#1%##$#')!.$/4$*

    #4$#5D#2$$#'"!%#$.$#:/%##

    %!$##'(2%%'.#'#$%%##$###3$##*$+

    " 9#++! !:$%)!2 "! .# 4$* 5< # % !$#

    < DB# $B$#$##% 3$"!#2#'./2$#.$##'(#%

    .#$.#3%##%.$4$*#4$#5D/%!$#'2.$2#!$(&'

    $###5

  • ")!"#!')%%')';!)6#9))"';+8'%#?'%!

    @,#$#%*8#"!+8#")@A+&'9!"!+!#!0!+% '*$%#'$%$#++*#:'*$%#8#+!&';!"#*

    %#"!+!++)!+%!8!+$#+8!@# #$'!&'*8&' !'!!%$@,#"#+)B "$%$#'$%'#"! #$#*'!

    #$'!&K14P2

  • !"#$%$##$'!&(!)")%#$#*'!

    +% #$,#!)-./!01)$

    !$.%#32.$####'! !7+*# #*#8#1%#+#:/%%

    .#%!$#%#-.:/($#.#$',

    %#$3%/$&'

    ( )*5!$# ' %# M?? %# $B2

    #!$.#!.$'##/J.$%!9$'%$#'###$3K15+52/

    #%#%$'.$#'#%$65I $B$$#2

    %##'%2$'#$*!%$2#''$

    !'#$.$.$:/2#$'N.$%!$#%##$3#'$*#

    1#%%#"!#/&'.#$'##$'%%.$.#-

    %'+$#*$#$62"!#.$%!9!%#$#:A##$##

    # #5 4$ 2 (! $#$:% !9:/ %# 3 %#$ %

    .$8.$ ## $2' %# $' %#$#%

    ( & *!"2 "!# .$3!

    $$':A#'.$!%%3#$$':A#$5

    $#2"!#+'$##3#.#$.#3%##%!$#+

    :/ % .#!$%%# %# $!* # ! '.:A# ($#

    .$#%#9:/5#'.$.%$A##!$.#!%+!EF

    #$!!$.$!*!##$0.'.##'.!&'.#

  • ")!"#!')%%')';!)6#9)
  • D !"#$%$##$'!&(!)")%#$#*'!

    +% #$,#!)-./!01)$

    !'!:/#$5#-.$#/J/.K#:/%#$#,;

    J#'%#'#$%K$#'##'%$#'##.$4#$%$!%#.$

    ## !$2 ! &!3# .' J%# (-K % #%%#5

    #-.$#/J.'K$##$##%3#9'$$#'##2#!3#$

    J03#!.#$$#K1*$%##'.$#2$#%#'#$'.#-#562

    !#)2$#%#!'#-.$#/"!##$%3#9'J!.#$3K

    J++#$#+#0'9!#$#3#$!%#!:$#++#+8#$%#+":'+%!+#0)*E+'+%*!F

    >)+'! !8'%!&'+%!"!&%#!0!'B#"!+# '"!"=8 #$%='#8!!2!&!

    +)*'"!*$%)*!"'!&G%' !:':!"# !8'%!&'+*#* #$%!"'@,# #*#>)

    !0!'B#"&$,#G#:"!"'# !8'%!&'+*#5K12=6#

    #$#.'#!'$*#'#$$/+.#%#$%#'

    #7'2 .2 # #2 J$+%&/K )B #$ % #'%5 $

    $!%#2 #'$*#' #$$ + 3#$%%#$ # % 3:A# # %

    $3%%#1"!#.%#2!3#2#$.%.#J.'K6#2#'

    #$#%2!'$'%#$#,;#'%#'#$%2.$##$3%

    $%:/5D/&B%N3%2.$2"!#4$*#4$#'$'

    ####'#%#$!%#5$#2&B'(+'##'#%'$-'

    #' ! #$.$#:A#5 '# . '#$ #!

    $B#$ #$3%$ "!# !. #! .# $#3!B$

    $$':/%#!''%%#.$%!:/$!'.'+!'#'

    "!# %##33% %# $' #'($B$ .$$- # .#$$'##

    .$'$%.$*$%#!$#'!$#((2%#U2#$$U

    %#$#2%#$''#'B2.$(#$$##$5"!#/

    !.!'!*$%#%#"!#%!#%%#(#($#$:/%

    #!%'.'1.,'((V##9U#J%#(#$##$K65

    4$* # 4$# .' '# %# $' %# .

    $$':/ % #%%#2 '2 #2 / %##33#'

    1#$'##6#'5T

    T D$#%%#2##.2#'.$!$2!'$'##8$'$#%$(&

    %##!$#5B!'($#.:/%#'.#!%"!#/+.$(#'9%5

    D/+.03#$!$!'3'.%#'#!!'3'#%*.$'

    .#J)!.:/K##'#"!#.#$##' ./.%#'#$'.#

    '##$#'(%2.%#.!!'*%.$!$%#$3%%)!

    %#"!#9.$#5$!%##$-.!#' .#2.$%#$$,2/

    **53#9#).03#'($%!$#2'#'(

    :/##$$.$(#'#8$'.#-2#%B!*$##$'## .5

  • ")!"#!')%%')';!)6#9)
  • !"#$%$##$'!&(!)")%#$#*'!

    +% #$,#!)-./!01)$

    #23#$'"!#.$#:%:N$2#$#H # M3!'##-.$%$''$#%"!##'

  • ")!"#!')%%')';!)6#9)
  • P !"#$%$##$'!&(!)")%#$#*'!

    +% #$,#!)-./!01)$

    (C6545N

    4634

    0

    500

    1000

    1500

    2000

    2500

    3000

    3500

    4000

    1790 1795 1800 1805 1810 1815 1820 1825 1830 1835ano

    pr

    eos

    em

    ris

    acar 21-31acar 96-11taxa de -3,1% ao anotaxa de -5,7% ao ano

    '#'#%B%.$#:%:N$#''#$%/5'($#)

    3#$%%#"!#.$#:#&'0%$'#%2%#3##%#$$

    "!# .#$0%%#

  • ")!"#!')%%')';!)6#9)
  • P !"#$%$##$'!&(!)")%#$#*'!

    +% #$,#!)-./!01)$

    '(+'%#3%#$##$%#'%.$$##5'2$$#:/#

    )!#%2$B$%"!#.$##%4$*2#-$3#$/%

    $'%#'($#$5

    !%#'.$%!2$$$#:/%$*':N$%

    !' #$ @ % !' % .$'#$ %#.#%## %

    '3'#%#*!%5F.%##$##%%'##%!'#

    %'*$:/.$!*!#.$$##$:/%&B(%#!'

    %($#$2"!#+#/.$##$$'$&%#'%;%#$#

    ' ($#5 D # ;"!#2 "! #'2 % "!# %# '#$

    !2.(%%#%#*!'!'%$'%#!'%#

    !'.$%!!)%#'%#$##'###.$#/#$

    $##- % '.#- #7' 3% .$ #-.$:/5 #3#'

    $'!%%$&%#'%2%#'%.#$&

    '$9 '2.$"!#.#$0%#'"!#/.$.!!'#-.3

    $#'#%#'*$B%%##$#'3$!%#%!*%4'0

    #5D##2!'$##$%%#3##$#-!9%#'.

    .$/%$'.$#/%#"!#!'#.#$0%5

    $$$#:/#$#"!%%#%##$3'.$%#$##

    ':N$.$##%$$9/2.$'2(#$$*#$1?62

    "!% !*#$# "!#P#$ #$ '.$%$2 +! EFE2 %#

    #$3$#$%.#%##$5F.$"!#'#$%$

    .$%!9%.$#%'#'##P$%#%!#$.$#%%#

    %#$3!'##2'/%%'#$2"!#!(!0'.#

    $#%#.$'#$5##'%2$$#:/%#3##$'$'

    #$3 "!# .#$'#' !$!!$ %2 3$B3# ; "! /

    3#'#5

    $#'2*$2;B#%3$:A#%.$#:%:N$#'.#'

    %#$##.$($#$##$*#$2"!#'.#P$BH5

  • ")!"#!')%%')';!)6#9)#?=#!'%#$'

    #$'303#2%%"!#.$#:#!$.#!###3'!('##2

    %%# 3#$'5$+'2 #'($'"!###%

    $'"!#'.$33#'###$##$'%("!#

    #2*#$%##9%#:N$#&!%#(!%@%##

    .$%!D3!%5#7'#2*#%#'$$$'.$8.$2

    % !)#:/%.$#:% :N$ #'# #$*#$5

    $$$'$"!#%#'2.$##'$9H2$##$##

    ;$$#:/%#.$#: %%#'#%*$B5D#&!'

    %0%#.$##%.$##!##'##.$8-'%#9#$.$

    /$#!$&.8##!#%.$4$*#4$#5#$B$2

    3#$'0%#!.#$$#?2T#$#.$($#$#.$#:

    #$5##'2#2"!#.$#:%$'

    "!#'# # .$-'$'%#!' $$#:/.#$#2 "!# .%# #$

    %0%#!'.$##'%'#2'"!#"!##''#.$#

    %$#!.$'#$.%$3#$/%$'5

  • P !"#$%$##$'!&(!)")%#$#*'!

    +% #$,#!)-./!01)$

    Q5L4545N

    4644P

    Rio Bahia Pernambuco Internac. Nac.

    Rio 1 Bahia 0.9507 1 Pernambuco 0.8934 0.9048 1 Internacional 0.6493 0.6577 0.875 1 Nacional 0.9783 0.9823 0.9497 0.7011 1

    4#1?2.5MT?#MT

  • ")!"#!')%%')';!)6#9)
  • PD !"#$%$##$'!&(!)")%#$#*'!

    +% #$,#!)-./!01)$

    $#*/.$3#*%.$#!%.$"!#.$##%$#$0

    %# !' #' #$3 !(&% $##$%'%#

    #-.36*#'%$($32$#.$%!9%.#$B

    @L(6.$##:%#*$%#!%%#.$%!318&!$%!%'#$6#L6

    .$%!:/#$3%.$'#$%#$5'2.$)!$

    .#$,%$#$#$#*##'.$"!##(###24$*.8

    # !%'#'## J!%%#K .$#*% .# '%#

    %'#&$*$5)"+ :*!'+ #*# !! %7+%' !++%)%)!'+"#!+'& #$'!&"#>) #*#

    !+8 %#+")*! #$1)$%)! #$#' !*$%&'*'%!"!#*#+)&%!"#&+)8+%'*!!8"#*'$S$

    '!"$9#8!;#"# !8'%!&* !$%'&"#* !"#'$%$#$!T'+%

  • ")!"#!')%%')';!)6#9)65

    $%.%#/!23#.$#$!'.!'%##:/

    ($#.$.:A#%#4$*5-#'.%2!$#$#3#J15556$!

    :'!"!"#+G )M8!!#MM$,#8:!& '!*,#!)!!9#B8#%!@,#

    + !:'+%! #$#*'! 8!)&'+%! + !++$%!:! 8'$ '8!&*$%$! 8#")@,#"

    +)0+'+%U$ '!$!>)&!:#&%!"!8!!#* !"#'$%$# #$'!&5K14P2

  • P !"#$%$##$'!&(!)")%#$#*'!

    +% #$,#!)-./!01)$

    '/!2.8$#!$:/%.#%#$%+!EFE2

    *!$'#B$#.$%!$%#:N$.$#-.$:/#B$#"!#

    %#3' #!#$:#'%$#:/'#$% #$2 '(#'

    .!#($3 #'$*(# %5!$ %

    #$##"!#J+$9$T#+B8!$"'!*+ #* #$%'$)'"!"8#%#"!!9',#

    "8#'+"P+%'*)&!"#+8&!+ #$"'@A+2!:#=:'+"# #*G '#'$%$! '#$!&

    8&!+*"'"!+9#:$!*$%!'+>)%$"!*!:!';!#8#%#"!$%#+*

    ! " )* >)!%# " +G ) ! 9!$" &!:#)! !@) !'! :'# ! "#*'$!

    #*8&%!*$%! #$#*'!"!=!+%#$#)#*#%#"! #$#*'!8!)&'+%!5K

    1D2

  • ")!"#!')%%')';!)6#9)
  • PP !"#$%$##$'!&(!)")%#$#*'!

    +% #$,#!)-./!01)$

    -'$#'##.'%#3%!%%5D/+%0$"!#

    $0'%#%'#$#.!!.!%%#.$#*%

    .$#'#' #$.$#:A#5%#$''.$#4$*#

    4$#2 '.'##2 $*!'#' "!# + .03#2 ' (#

    (#$3:/%'.$'#%#'$#$##$!*3'##"!%$%#'

    #!.$.'#'2#-!3'#$.2%#-!%#

    #-$53%%4'0#$#.$##!!'#-./%#'%"!#

    /.%##$3%.#.#!'#($!...!:/!'

    ($#9 #-$#''## .#$%!B$ .$! # #$$2 ' .%$A#

    ##3%%# !'"!#/.%' #$ !.$%.#'#$% 5

    D## #%2 (#$!$ % .$ / $! % .$#/

    ($@2'%:/.$*$$(#'#%$#5'#

    '!.:/ % %#'% / + %# #.$ !' !'# % .$%!:/

    3% '#$% #$5 ' % #-#'. ' #-.0 %#

    *##$9:/(!3#%#$'%$%#$.$#:A#$*+

    % $0 ; 4#$%D35 .8 %#B ' J#*!'+ $#%=:&

    "'+ 78)"!'#!"#5K1#'! !7+*#624$*#4$#$'

    %!#$.$#:A##'(5.#$0%%.$D3#B

    '.$##%%#$#2.#$0%'$%.#%*

    #'2"!#.$##!$**'(#$!$%

    .$]H? #' $%2 "!# !$. ## .#$0%2 #*!#

  • ")!"#!')%%')';!)6#9)
  • !"#$%$##$'!&(!)")%#$#*'!

    +% #$,#!)-./!01)$

    '(# "!# )B #-.2 .%#' *$ $#$:$ .$.

    .:A#%##%%*%##$*5'.$'#$!*$2.#$0%#

    $#*/#&%.$4$*#.$4$#//$#.$##3

    .$:'#$!'###$.$..$%'+$%!2

    &2 #2 .$2 *!$3 !' #.: .$3#*% .$

    '+$ # $#9:/ %# 3#'# %# 3!5P##$9$ .$

    $##%#$$8$$#!%(%'#%#B#%#!'.#$0%

    #%#!'$#*/"!#$#N#$#$0+!'*$3##"!035$0

    % &$*$ ($# .#$0% '(+' / + .$#%##5

    $'#$2.$"!#4$*#4$#%#$''.#'#$*

    %!$#"!#.$##%#'$$2''9%'9#.$###

    #$.$#:A# "!# '2 ($#!% ' $#:/ ; #.#%%# %

    +!EFE5'#*!% !*$ # +'*$3# .$"!#(#%#

    !#:/%#!$0/+$*$'%#'$'#:/

    H5

  • ")!"#!')%%')';!)6#9)) + '*!9'$!B'+%'*$#+

    $#++#+"'!+)$' !*$%* &':#+"T'+%

  • !"#$%$##$'!&(!)")%#$#*'!

    +% #$,#!)-./!01)$

    4P2/55#* '!$%+2!;$"'#+2#*!+"! )*)&!@,#

    *)*! #$#*'!+ !:'+%! #$'!&'#"!$'#PPP

  • ")!"#!')%%')';!)6#9)