Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
-
Upload
hugo-santiago -
Category
Documents
-
view
215 -
download
0
Transcript of Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 1/59
ASSOCIAÇÃO VITORIENSE DE EDUCAÇÃO, CIÊNCIA E CULTURAFACULDADE ESCRITOR OSMAN DA COSTA LINS
COORDENAÇÃO DO CURSO DE DIREITO - BACHARELADO
EDVALDO PAULO FERREIRA
O CONSENTIMENTO VÁLIDO COMO DESCARACTERIZADOR DA ANTIJURIDICIDADE NO TRÁFICO DE PESSOAS PARA FINS DE PROSTITUIÇÃO
VITÓRIA DE SANTO ANTÃO – PE,200
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 2/59
EDVALDO PAULO FERREIRA
O CONSENTIMENTO VÁLIDO COMO DESCARACTERIZADOR DA ANTIJURIDICIDADE NO TRÁFICO DE PESSOAS PARA FINS DE PROSTITUIÇÃO
M!"!#$%&'% F'"%( %)$*+*"%% %! C.$+!* D'$*'! % F%/.(%* E+/$'!$ O+%"% C!+% L'"+ – FACOL, /!! $*1.'+'!)%$/'%( )%$% % !*"34! ! 5.(! *B%/6%$*( * D'$*'! Á$*% * C!"/*"$%34!7 D'$*'! P8('/!
D'+/')('"%7 D'$*'! P*"%(O$'*"%!$%7 S.9%"% A#%$
VITÓRIA DE SANTO ANTÃO – PE,200
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 3/59
F383t Ferreira, Edvaldo Paulo.
O consentimento válido como descaracterizadorda antijuridicidade no tráfico de pessoas para fins
prostituição. / Edvaldo Paulo Ferreira. it!ria de "anto
#ntão$ O autor, %&'&.
()f.
*issertação +raduação em *ireito- F#O0
Faculdade Escritor Osman da osta 0ins.
Orientado pela Prof.1 "uzana #2mar.
'. onsentimento álido. %. Prostituição. 3. ráfico de
Pessoas
4 5tulo.
** 36'.(
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 4/59
EDVALDO PAULO FERREIRAO CONSENTIMENTO VÁLIDO COMO DESCARACTERIZADOR DA ANTIJURIDICIDADE NO TRÁFICO DE PESSOAS PARA FINS DE PROSTITUIÇÃO
M!"!#$%&'% F'"%( %)$*+*"%% %! C.$+!* D'$*'! % F%/.(%* E+/$'!$ O+%"% C!+% L'"+ – FACOL, /!! $*1.'+'!)%$/'%( )%$% % !*"34! ! 5.(! *B%/6%$*( * D'$*'! Á$*% * C!"/*"$%34!7 D'$*'! P8('/!D'+/')('"%7 D'$*'! P*"%(O$'*"%!$%7 S.9%"% A#%$
A B%"/% E:%'"%!$% /!)!+% )*(!+ P$!&*++!$*+ %%':!, +! % P$*+';"/'%! )$'*'$!, +.**. ! /%"'%! < %"=('+* % M!"!#$%&'% * "5>*( * ?$%.%34!* % @.(#!. "!+ +*#.'"*+ *$!+7
P$!& F*$"%"! C!$$*'%
J.(#%*"! – N!%7 0,0 A++'"%.$%7
P$!& F$**$'/! ?.'(6*$*
J.(#%*"! – N!%7 0,0 A++'"%.$%7
P$!& S.9%"% A#%$
J.(#%*"! – N!%7 0,0 A++'"%.$%7
N!% F'"%(7 0,0 S'.%34! ! A/%;'/!7 APROVADO D%%7
MENÇÃO ?ERAL7
C!!$*"%!$ ! C.$+! * D'$*'!7P$!& D$ E(/'%+ F*$$*'$% % C!+%
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 5/59
S* )*+%"*@%$, !. $*+%$ 8>'%+, *'/!
/! )$%9*$ *++* *+.! /'*"5&'/! %+ )*++!%+
1.* %'+ %!, * 1.* +* %+ 1.%'+ "4! +%*$'%
/!! %#'$, !. +*@%7 %+ '"6%+ '$4+, E('+%"#*(%
P%.(% E$'/% P%.(% M%$'% C(%$%, *.+ '$4!+,
E+!" P%.(! E5(+!" P%.(! – in memory , *
)$'"/')%(*"* % M%'"6%G, H*(*"% E'('%, )!$
)*#%$ "! *. ), * +*$>'$ * '"+)'$%34! )%$%
1.* *. ).*++* /!"/(.'$ ! /.$+!
F%5('% *++% 1.* +*)$* %/$*'!. * ',
.'%+ >*9*+, % 1.%"! "* *. *+!%/$*'%>%
N4! )!++! '9*$-*, %'"%, M%'"6%, 1.*
/6*#.*' !"* % +*"6!$% +!"6!., * %/$*'!.
1.* *. /6*#%$'%, %+ )!++! &%(%$ 1.* *+!.
%'+ )$:'!
O$'#%! )*(%+ 6!$%+ )*$'%+ * +!"!, +*'
1.* "4! &!' &=/'( "!++! /%'"6%$, %+ /%% '%1.* )%++%, &'/% *"!+ '&5/'( * %'+ )$%9*$!+!
A MINHA AMADA FAMÍLIA
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 6/59
A?RADECIMENTO
A#$%*3! )$*/').%*"*, % D*.+, )!'+, %)*+%$ * +!"6%$, +* %
'"*$>*"34! '>'"%, +* 1.*$ )*"+%$'% * '"'/'%$ *++* /%'"6!, - ! 1.%(, * '"'/'!, &!'
=$.! -, .'! *"!+, * /!"/(.5-(!, /!! %#!$% ! &%3!
S!. **$"%*"* #$%! % '"6% &%5('%, %'"6%G, *.+ '$4!+ * '"6%+
'$4+K, )!'+ +%* %+ '&'/.(%*+, )*(%+ 1.%'+ )%++*', )%$% 1.* ).*++* /6*#%$
% %1.', * 6.'(**"* /!)%$'(6%$%-"%+ /!'#!
.%"! %! %#$%*/'*"! *+)*/'%(, *+* >%' )%$% )*++!% 1.* +*$>'. *
'"+$.*"! '>'"! )%$% /!"/$*'9%34! *+* +!"6!, * 1.*, )!$ !'>!+ %'!$*+, "4!
)!*$*' /'%$, %+ ! ')!$%"* 1.* +%'% 1.*, +!.-(6* #$%! **$"%*"*, %&'"%('>'% * #$%'4! "4! )$*+/$*>*
C!)%$'(6% *++* %#$%*/'*"!, A"% P%.(% B*9*$$% D'$*!$% *
M%$*'"# % FACOLK, 1.* /! %+ )%(%>$%+ /*$%+, * "! !*"! !)!$."!, &!' *
$*%( ')!$"/'% "% $*%('9%34! *+% &%3%"6%
A++', /!! % *1.')* ! ?!(* ?!%( F%/!(, % 1.%( &'9 )$*+*"3%, %'!$
*)!, .$%"* '"6% %%(6%
T%, +*$*' #$%!, )!'+ &%9 )%$* * *. +./*++!, % !% *1.')*FACOL )%++%"! % '$*34!, !+ *"'"!+ % (')*9%, * /! %'!$ )$!*9%, %+
'('!*/=$'%+ 1.* '>*$% .'% )%/';"/'% /!'#!K
N4! )!*$'% *':%$ * %#$%*/*$ %!+ )$!&*++!$*+, 1.* * %/!)%"6%$%
%! (!"#! ! /.$+!, %(#."+, "4! '"!, %/6*'-!+ /6%!+G, !.$!+, )!$ +.% >*9, %++',
%@*'>%$%-* M%+, "4! )!++! "*#%$ 1.* *+* &'"%( )$% *(*+ * ! /!*3! )$% 'K,
+ &!' )!++5>*(, )!$1.* *(*+ '>*$% % 6!$'%* * )%++%$ ! 1.* %)$*"*$% )$%
"+, +*.+ **$"!+ %(."!+D*"$* *++*+ )$!&*++!$*+, %#$%*3! * *+%1.*, %!+ 1.* %/$*'%$%
* '"6% )*++!%, $*+%"! *!"+$%! *++* %! %$%>+ * +')(*+ )%(%>$%+
!'>%!$%+ * *!"+$%3*+ % $*%('%*
E %++', %)$!>*'! ! *"+*@! )%$% %#$%*/*$ % )$!&*++!$% S.9%"% A#%$,
)!'+ *>* .% )%/';"/'% '(''%%, 1.%"! % !$'*"%34! * '+)!"''('%* )$*+%% %
'"6% )*++!%, 1.* +* +.% %@.%, *++% )*+1.'+% )!*$'% "4! +*$ /!"/$*'9%%, )!'+
% *+% )%$'/')!. ;+ % ''%, % % %*$'%('9%34! % !"!#$%&'%
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 7/59
A++' /!!, % %#$%*3! %! P$!&*++!$ A"!"'! * B%$$!+ J."'!$,
1.* *>* .% )%$'/')%34! +'#"'&'/%'>%, )!"!-+* % '+)!+'34!, +*)$* 1.* !
)$!/.$*' )%$% +%"%$ 8>'%+ /"'/%+, !"* %)$!>*'%>% )%$% !.>'$ +.%+ !)'"'*+
A#!$% /6*#%% % >*9 * %#$%*/*$ % !!+ !+ *.+ %'#!+ *
&%/.(%*, !+ 1.%'+ (*>%$*' .% %'9%* **$"%
D*"$* *++*+, A#$%*3! % ?*$#'% M**'$!+, )!$ +.% %'9%* *
)%$'/')%34!, )$'"/')%(*"* 1.%"! "*/*++=$'% )$% $*+!(>*$ !+ )$!(*%+, "*++*
/%+! *$% % )$'*'$% )*++!% * 1.* (*$%>% C!! %, %#$%*3! % D'%"%
?!*+, )!$ +*$ .% )*++!% )$*+%'>%, % 1.%(, "! */!$$*$ ! /.$+!, *>*
6.'(%*, +*)$*, *)$*+%"!-* +*.+ *+/$'!+, )!'+ &!' %++' 1.* /!"+*#.'
)%++%$D*"$* *.+ %'#!+, * +%(% * %.(%, "4! )!*$'% *':%$ * %#$%*/*$,
* *+)*/'%(, % D*(.+* ?!*+, )!'+ /! *(% /!)%$'(6*' !@*'>!+ )$!&'++'!"%'+, *
.'%+ >*9*+, &!' 1.*, /! +.% chaticeG, @!#!.-* baldes de água friaG, )%$% 1.*
*. /!"+*#.'++* $*!$"%$ * *"/%$%$ % $*%('%*
E &', +*$*' #$%!, * &!$% '*"+.$=>*(, % !!+ 1.* * &!$% '$*% !.
'"'$*% )%$'/')%$% * %"*'$% )!+''>% "% '"6% @!$"%%, )%$% 1.* *. ).*++*
(!#$% ! ;:'! * 6!@*OBI!ADO M"# D"#$% FAMILIA " AMI!O$&&
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 8/59
L.%T*. *>*$ (.%$ )*(! D'$*'!
M%+, "! '% * 1.* *"/!"$%$*+ !D'$*'! * /!"&('! /! % @.+'3%,
(.% )*(% @.+'3%G
Eduardo Couture
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 9/59
RESUMO
O *+.! !"!#$=&'/! >'+% *!"+$%$ % ')!$"/'%, "! ."! @.$5'/!-+!/'%(, !/!"+*"'*"! >=('!, *+/%$%/*$'9%"! ! ')! )*"%( $=&'/! * )*++!%+ )%$% &'"+ *
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
)!+'/'!"%*"! /!"+*"+.%( "% !.$'"%, .% >*9 1.*, )%$* /!"+'*$=>*( !+ @.$'+%+ )=$'!+ "4! *"&$*"% % 1.*+4! !$% %!$%%, )$*&*$'"! /!%."%$-+* /! %+/!"+'*$%3*+ $%9'%+ )*(!+ (*#'+(%!$*+, +* 1.* 6%@% .% $*&(*:4! @.$5'/!-)*"%(%'+ /!"."*"* A++' +*"!, % *:)!+'34! +!$* ! *% (*>%$= % .% "!>%$*&(*:4!, +! % '/% % ('*$%* 1.* *+)!"% % '#"'%* +*:.%( * 1.* +*%1.% % $*%('%* * .% +!/'*%* 1.*, *"&$*"% #$%>*+ )$!(*%+ +!/'%'+, %+1.* "4! +* %1.% %! /!"*:! +!/'%( !+ +/.(!+ )%++%!+
Palavras-Chaves: CONSENTIMENTO VÁLIDO 2 PROSTITUIÇÃO TRÁFICO DE PESSOAS
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 10/59
ABSTRACT
T6* !"!#$%)6'/ +. %'+ ! *!"+$%* 6* ')!$%"/*, '" 6* (*#%(, +!/'%(,>%(' /!"+*", *)$'>'"# 6* !&&*"+* $%&&'/'"# '" )*$+!"+ &!$ )$!+'.'!" I '+
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
'++.* "! $%'+*, )$*&*$$'"# ! * /!"+'+*" '6 6* /!"+'*$%'!"+ $!.#6 (*#'+(%!$+, '6!. % 6!.#6 /$''"%( (*#%( !$* /!">'"/'"# T6.+, 6* *:6'''!" !"6* +.@*/ '(( (*% ! "* 6'"'"# &$! 6* )*$+)*/'>* !& &$**! 6% %$'+*+ &$!+*:.%( '#"' %" 6% &'+ 6* $*%(' !& % +!/'* 6% '+ &%/'"# +*$'!.+ +!/'%()$!(*+, . 6% !*+ "! &' 6* +!/'%( /!"*: !& /*".$'*+ )%+
Key-Words: VALID CONSENT 2 PROSTITUTION TRAFFICIN? IN PERSONS
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 11/59
SUMÁRIO
1 ITRO!U"#O0
$ TRÁ%ICO !E PESSOAS PARA %IS !E PROSTITUI"#O: !A TORPE&A AOCOSETIMETO 'Á(I!O
2 DA CONJECTURA EWISTENTE NA CONDUTA ILXCITA DO TRÁFICO DEPESSOAS PARA FINS DE ATIVIDADE SEWUAL
22 TRÁFICO DE PESSOAS7 DO CÓDI?O PENAL AO PROTOCOLO DEPALERMOY
2 DO CONSENTIMENTO NO TRÁFICO DE PESSOAS2
) !AS !I'ER*+CIAS ,UR!ICO-!OUTRIARIAS .UATO ACOCEITUA"#O !E CRIME2Y
DO FATO TXPICO E SEUS ELEMENTOS2
2 DA CULPABILIDADE E SUA COMPOSIÇÃO2
DA ANTIJURIDICIDADE E SUAS CAUSAS DE EWCLUSÃO2
/ !O COSETIMETO 'Á(I!O COMO %ATOR !ESCARACTERI&ATE !AATI,URI!ICI!A!EY
[ DO CONSENTIMENTO NO TRÁFICO DE PESSOAS PARA FINS DEPROSTITUIÇÃOY
[2 DA RELAÇÃO ENTRE O CONSENTIMENTO E A EWCLUSÃO DATIPICIDADEQ
[DAS TEORIAS DO CONSENTIMENTO
[[ DOS REUISITOS UE COMP\EM O CONSENTIMENTO VÁLIDO[
0 !AS COSE.U+CIAS SOCIAIS EM COSI!ERAR A RE(A"#O ETRE APROSTITUI"#O E O TRÁ%ICO !E PESSOAS[
Y DA RELAÇÃO7 PROSTITUIÇÃO E OS BONS COSTUMES[
Y2 DA RELAÇÃO7 PROSTITUIÇÃO E O TRÁFICO DE PESSOASY0
] CONSIDERAÇ\ES FINAISYY
REFERÊNCIASY
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 12/59
1 ITRO!U"#O
A )$*+*"* )*+1.'+% %!$%$= % %"*'$% %$%>+ % 1.%( %(#."+ !+
*+.'!+!+ * %)('/%!$*+ ! '$*'! ; +* /!)!$%! )*$%"* ! *('! $=&'/! *
)*++!%+, "% >*$*"* % )$!+'.'34!
O+*$>%-+* 1.* "4! )!*$= +*$ ')!+% (''%3*+ %! '$*'! < ('*$%*
* /!"+*"'$, *+* 1.* *+*@% '%"* * . /!"+*"'*"! 1.* $%#% !!+ !+
$*1.'+'!+ % *(* '"*$*"*+, +! )*"% * >'!(%3*+ ')(5/'%+ %! )$'"/')'! % '#"'%*
6.%"%, *+)*/'%(*"* "! 1.* +* $*&*$* %! *:*$/5/'! % +*:.%('%*, %(#! '"*$*"*
%! '"'>5.! * = +.% +%'+&%34! )*++!%(
A*%'+, ! *:*$/5/'! % )$!+'.'34! .% %'>'%* ('/'% * ! ('>$*
/!"+*"'*"!, !$"% % /!".% /!"'9*"* /! ! !$*"%*"! @.$5'/! )=$'!,
*+* 1.* *+% +*@% !+*$>%% '+!(%%*"*
P%$% *++* &', *:/(.'$-+*-= ! /!"+*"'*"! %>'"! * )*++!%+
'"/%)%9*+ * )$*+=-(!, .% >*9 1.* +*)$* &%(%$4! $*1.'+'!+ )%$% % >%('%34! !
/!"+*"'*"! /!! /$'$'! *+/%$%/*$'9%!$ % %"'@.$''/'%*
I+! )!+!, .% >*9 1.*, ! *('! $=&'/! * )*++!%+, "% !%('%*
)$!+'.'34!, >* +*"! '"*$)$*%! * &!$% ('*$%(, (''%"!-+* % . 8"'/!
)!+'/'!"%*"!, ! 1.%( &!' !%! /%%+ %$=+, * '&*$*"* /!"*:! 6'+$'/!-
+!/'%( * +! % )*$+)*/'>% * .% +!/'*%* 1.* $%9'% /!! 8"'/! * @.$5'/!
.*(%! )*(! '$*'! )*"%( +*:.%(, !+ /!+.*+
N*+* '%)%+4!, +.$#* .% )$!(*='/% +!$* % 8>'% % *:'+;"/'% !.
"4! ! !@*! @.$5'/! * %( *('!, * **$'"%%+ +'.%3*+, * *+)*/'%(, 1.%"!
*:'+* . /!"+*"'*"! 8.! *"$* %+ )%$*+ *">!(>'%+ * .% $*(%34!, % 1.%(
)!*$= +*$ *$%*"* /!*$/'%( *, %++', )!++% *$ &'"+ (%!$%'+, (%3!+ *
/!"&'%"3% *!. %&*! A @.+'&'/%34!, )%$% *+.%$ *+% 6')*+*, +* = )!$ !/!$$*$, * &!$%
/(%$%, /*$/*%*"! %! '$*'! < ('*$%* * /!"+*"'$ "% )$='/% % %'>'%*
+*:.%(, (%!$%(, >'>'! )!$ .% )%$/*(% 5"'% % +!/'*%*, )!$, "4! *"!+
+'#"'&'/%"* 1.* %+ *%'+, *, %, )*(! &%! *+* /*$/*%*"! *+%$ +*"!
'"*$)$*%! *++*"/'%(*"* ".% )*$+)*/'>% *('.!+%, /.@% !%('%*, "*
+*)$* *"/!"$% $*+)%(! &'*'#"! %! $=&'/! * )*++!%+, )!'+ )*$/**-+* .%
/(%$% %.+;"/'% * !@*!, .% >*9 1.* % )$!+'.'34!, * +' *+%, "4! .%'"&$%34! )*"%(
10
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 13/59
P!$ '++!, % )*+1.'+% %!% /!! !@*'>! )$*/5).! % "*/*++'%* *
*!"+$%$ 1.* *:'+* .% /%$;"/'% "% *>!(.34! % "!$%, * %/!$! /! !+
%"+*'!+, /!+.*+ * "*/*++'%*+ % +!/'*%*
B.+/%-+*, *+% &!$%, .% "!>% '"*$)$*%34!, "! ."! @.$5'/!,
'>*$#*"* % 1.* >* +*"! !%% )*(!+ @.59*+ * $'."%'+ C!! %,
*+/%$%/*$'9%$ !, '(.+$'!, '(5/'! )*"%( ! $=&'/! * )*++!%+, "% !%('%*
)$!+'.'34!, 1.%"! "4! &!$3%!, "4! (.'$'%!, "4! !'++! "! +*. $*%( '"*$*++*,
%+ +', * &!$% ('>$*, /!"+/'*"*, %$** * >!(."=$'%, !+$%"! 1.* "*
+*)$* *:'+* %(#!9*+ * >5'%+ )!*"! *:'+'$, %)*"%+, )*++!%+ /! '"*$*++*+
$*/5)$!/!+ * /!">*$#*"*+
P%$% %'"#'$ !+ *+/!)!+, %/'% *"/'!"%!+, .+%$-+*-=, /!! $*&*$*"/'%(*$'/!, %+ ''%+ %>*$+%+ * !.$'"%!$*+ /!! ?.'(6*$* * S!.9% N.//',
F*$"%"! C%)*9, %$'"% N!#.*'$%, *"$* !.$!+
O+ !.$'"%!$*+ %!% . /!"/*'! )$)$'! ! 1.* +*@% /!"+*"'*"!,
$%9*"! % "*/*++'%* * %!$%$ %+ '>*$#;"/'%+ *"/!"$%%+, .% >*9 1.* !
'$*'! +* /!"+$' % )%$'$ * /!"/*)3*+ 1.* +* /!"$%)* * 1.*$%
)%$%'#%+, "! +*"'! * +* /!%."%$ /! !+ $*%'+ '"*$*++*+ * .% +!/'*%*
)%.%% )!$ >%(!$*+ /!"+'./'!"%(*"* *+%*(*/'!+7 >'%, '#.%(%*, ('*$%*,*/ A++', )%$% %(#."+, ! /!"+*"'*"! )!* %*1.%$ % /!".% < (*', * *+')'&'/%$
! *('! $=&'/! * )*++!%+, "% !%('%* )$!+'.'34! *"1.%"! 1.*, )%$% !.$!+,
*++% )!++''('%* *+%$'% *+/%$%%, )!'+, % )$*>'+4! (*#%( )$!)* %( )."'34!
.%"! < *!!(!#'% *)$*#%%, +*$= ! !! *.'>!, '"*$)$*%"!
* /!'"%"! ''%+ !+ !.!+, +*@% *++%+ /!">*$#*"*+ !. '>*$#*"*+,
%$%"#*"! !!+ !+ !@*'>!+ % )*+1.'+%, *:)(!$%"! ! '$*'! < ('*$%* !
/!"+*"'*"!, "! $=&'/! * )*++!%+, )%$% 1.*, % )%$'$ *(%+, +.$@% .% "!>%)*$+)*/'>% '"*$)$*%'>%
P%$% '++!, +*$= .+%! ! !! '('!#$=&'/!, >'+%"! <+ !$%+ *++*+
!.$'"%!$*+, %'+ /!!7 ('>$!+ !.$'"=$'!+ %$'#!+ * '"*$"* @.$'+)$.;"/'%, "%
+.% '"*$)$*%34! %'+ *:*"+'>% /!! 1.%(1.*$ . !.$! %*$'%( 1.* *$*3% .%
*&*$;"/'% *:)$*++'>%, * %/!$! /! ! "5>*( % )*+1.'+%
E, %++' * '"'/'!, +*$= $*%('9%! . (*>%"%*"! 6'+$'/! "! $=&'/! *
)*++!%+, *+.%"! % $*(%34! *:'+*"* *"$* ! P$!!/!(! * P%(*$! * ! C'#!
P*"%( B$%+'(*'$! T$%%(6%"! %+ !%('%*+ ! $=&'/! * )*++!%+, $*+$'"#'"! *
11
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 14/59
*(''%"! ! /%)! % )*+1.'+%, )%$% 1.* )!++% +*$ *+.%! * &!$% *+)*/'&'/%
! /!"+*"'*"! >=('! "% !%('%* * $=&'/! )%$% &'"+ * )$!+'.'34!
L!#! * +*#.'%, +*$= &*'! . *+.!, +'"'/! * *$%*"* '"&!$%'>!
+!$* % *!$'% ! *('! * +*.+ /!)!"*"*+, )%$% 1.* +'$>% /!! +.)$*++4! *
1.%'+1.*$ 8>'%+ 1.* )!++% >' % +.$#'$ N4! +*"!, &'/%"! /(%$! *+* %#!$%,
! *+/!)! )$*/5).! % )$*+*"* )*+1.'+%
N! /%)5.(! +*#.'"*, &%$-+*-=, . *+.! "% *!$'% ! /!"+*"'*"!
>=('!, %!$%"! +.%+ )$'"/')%'+ *!$'%+ * %*1.%"! +*.+ $*1.'+'!+ %! $=&'/! *
)*++!%+ )%$% &'"+ * )$!+'.'34! A! $*%('9%$ *+* /!"&$!"!, !@*'>%-+* *!"+$%$
1.* ! /!"+*"'*"! >=('!, +*$>* /!! *:/(.*"* % %"'@.$''/'%* ! *('! *
>!#%P!$ &', % )*+1.'+% *':%$= /(%$% % "*/*++'%* * /!"+'*$%$ *++% "!>%
>'+4!, * +.%+ $*+)*/'>%+ /!"+*1^;"/'%+ )!+''>%+ "! *'! +!/'%(, 1.%"! %
(*#'+(%34! )*"%( $%+'(*'$% $*+!(>*$ /!"+'*$%$ ! /!"+*"'*"! >=('! /!! &%!$
*+/%$%/*$'9%"* % %"'@.$''/'%* ! $=&'/! * )*++!%+, $*+)!"*"!, *
%/!)%"6%"!, %++', % %"+'*%* * % *>!(.34! % +!/'*%* P!'+, %)*+%$ %
)$!+'.'34! +!&$*$ . %(! #$%. * )$*/!"/*'! >%(!$%'>!, % *+% *:*$/'% *
.+.&$.5% * &!$% ('>$* * >!(."=$'% "! +*'! +!/'%( * >=$'!+ )%5+*+ /!!, )!$*:*)(!, I=('%, P!$.#%(, I"#(%*$$% *"$* !.$!+, ! 1.* "4! '&*$*"* "%
+!/'*%* $%+'(*'$%
12
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 15/59
$ TRÁ%ICO !E PESSOAS PARA %IS !E PROSTITUI"#O: !A TORPE&A AOCOSETIMETO 'Á(I!O
F%9-+* ')*$%'>!, %"*+ * $%%$ ! *+/!)! )$*/5).!, % )$*+*"*
)*+1.'+%, $*%('9%$ .% $*$!+)*/'>% "% *>!(.34! ! *('! $=&'/! * )*++!%+, *"!
* >'+% %+ !'&'/%3*+ $*%('9%%+ "! */!$$*$ ! *)!, %!$%"! !+ *(**"!+
1.* (*>%$% % +.% ')'&'/%34!, "! C'#! P*"%( B$%+'(*'$!, /!!, %, ! !@*!
@.$5'/! $*+#.%$%! )!$ *(*
N! *"%"!, *$*/* .% %*"34! *+)*/'%( ! '$*'! < ('*$%* !
/!"+*"/'*"*, .% >*9 1.* *+* >* +!&$*"! >'!(%3*+, "! !*"! * 1.* !+
@.59*+ * $'."%'+ '"*$)$*% ! 1.* +*@% $=&'/! * )*++!%+, "4! (*>%"! *
/!"+'*$%34! ! 8.! /!"+*"'*"! *"$* %+ )%$*+ *">!(>'%+
2 DA CONJECTURA EWISTENTE NA CONDUTA ILXCITA DO TRÁFICO DEPESSOAS PARA FINS DE ATIVIDADE SEWUAL
O $=&'/! * )*++!%+, +* 8>'%+ .% %+ &!$%+ %'+ /$.'+ *
*:)(!$%34! ! 6!* )*(! 6!*, ! 1.* %/%$$*% *+$*+)*'! < '#"'%* ! +*$
6.%"!, !"* >'!(% % '"*#$'%* &5+'/% * )+51.'/% ! '"'>5.!, *+%"! )$*+*"*
*+* .'! *)!, - %+%"! < !)!$."'%* )%$% %(#. %.&*$'$ (./$! - * ! 1.*
)'!$, +* )$*>'+4! * *:'"#.'$, )!'+7
O $=&'/! "%% %'+ 1.* % >'!(%34! %! '#"!, % *:%/*$%34! % /$.*(%*,)$='/% *+.%"% .('&%/*%% 1.* +!$*>'>* %! *)!, %'"#'"! +.%+>5'%+ %$%>+ % !$)*9% * % %(5/'% N%% %'+ @.+'&'/% % *:'+;"/'% S"4! +%*!+ 1.%"! +.$#'$= . 1.*$*$G 1.* &%3% '9'%$ *++% =/.(% 1.*'"#* '"*(>*( "!++% >'% )%++%% * ! 1.* )!*!+ /6%%$ * "!++%6'+$'% /!"*)!$"*%
P%$% A"=('% B*('+% R'*'$!2
! $=&'/! * )*++!%+ .% %+ &!$%+ %'+*:)(5/'%+ * *+/$%>'4! !*$"% E!$% *"6% +'! %!('% !&'/'%(*"*, %
*+/$%>'4! "."/% &!' $*%(*"* *$$%'/%%G
J= "% >'+4! * ?(9'% P*$*'$% ! $=&'/! * )*++!%+ .% &!$% *
*+/$%>'4!, /%$%/*$'9%% )*(! *+(!/%*"! %+ *+%+ %$%>+ *7 $%)! *"#%"!,
&$%.*, %*%3%, %.+! * %.!$'%*, '(.+4! * .% >'% *(6!$G
1 VASCONCELOS, %$'"% N!#.*'$% C!!K Tr2345o de 6essoas P*$"%./!7 A++*)(%", 200 )Y[2 RIBEIRO, A"% B*('+% MARZA?ÃO J_NIOR, L%*$* I /!!K * %( Tr2345o de 6essoas S4! P%.(!7.%$'*$ L%'", 200 ) ]Q3 PEREIRA, ?(9'% N!#.*'$% C!!K Tr2345o de 6essoas 6ara 347s de e86lora9o se8ualP*$"%./!7 A++*)(%", 200Q )
13
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 16/59
O $=&'/! * )*++!%+, @= *&'"'! %/'%, "% "!$% $%+'(*'$%, '>'*-+* *
!'+ ')!+, +*"! ! $=&'/! '"*$"%/'!"%( * )*++!%+ * $=&'/! '"*$"! * )*++!%+ )%$%
&'"+ * *:)(!$%34! +*:.%(, *"*"*"! ! )$'*'$! /!! +*"! % %'>'%* *
)$!!>*$ !. &%/'('%$ % *"$%%, "! *$$'$'! "%/'!"%(, * %(#. 1.* "*(* >*"6% %
*:*$/*$ % )$!+'.'34! !. !.$% &!$% * *:)(!$%34! +*:.%(, !. % +%5% * %(#.
1.* >= *:*$/;-(% "! *+$%"#*'$!G E+* ! /!"/*'! * $=&'/! '"*$"%/'!"%( 1.* !
C'#! P*"%( B$%+'(*'$! %!!. * +*. %$ 2, /%).
P!$ /! +*#.'"*, 1.%"! % +*#."% /(%++'&'/%34!, ! %$ 2-A C%)., !
$*&*$'! C'#! '9 1.* /!"+'*$%! $=&'/! '"*$"! * )*++!%+ % %34! *
P$!!>*$ !. &%/'('%$ ! *+(!/%*"! * %(#. *"$! ! *$$'$'! "%/'!"%( )%$% !
*:*$/5/'! % )$!+'.'34! !. !.$% &!$% * *:)(!$%34! +*:.%(GP!$ +.% >*9, ! $=&'/! * )*++!%+, +*@% *(* $*%('9%! * &!$% '"*$"% !.
*:*$"%, +.'>'*-+* * $;+ !%('%*+7 $=&'/! * )*++!%+ )%$% &'"+ * 4!-*-
!$% *+/$%>% $=&'/! * )*++!%+ )%$% &'"+ * $*!34! * $#4!+ * $=&'/! *
)*++!%+ )%$% &'"+ * *:)(!$%34! +*:.%(
A 1.*+4! $*&*$*"* %! $=&'/! * )*++!%+, )%$% &'"+ * *:)(!$%34! * 4!
* !$% *+/$%>%, "4! +* *"/!"$% .*(%! "!+ %$'#!+ 2 * 2 A, ! /'#! )*"%(,
! 1.* "4! '"'/% 1.* "4! +*@% .% /!".% *$*/*!$% * $*).'!, * 1.* "4! +*@%"!$%'9%! "! '$*'! )*"%( $%+'(*'$!
O 1.* %/!"*/* 1.* +* *"/!"$% )$*>'+!+ * %$'#!+ '+)*$+!+ "!
C'#! P*"%(, %+ %3*+ 1.* '".9 %! $=&'/! * )*++!%+ )%$% &'"+ * $%%(6!
*+/$%>!, /!! )!$ *:*)(!, ! %$'#! [[ ! C'#! P*"%( 1.* $%% %
)!++''('%* * $*.34! < /!"'34! %"=(!#% < * *+/$%>!
.%"! % 1.*+4! ! $=&'/! * )*++!%+, )%$% &'"+ * $*!34! * $#4!+,
1.* * ! /!"/*'.% %$'"% V%+/!"/*(!+, "*+*+ *$!+7
A $*!34! * $#4!+ )%$% &'"+ /!*$/'%'+, !%('%* ! $=&'/! * )*++!%+/!"6*/'! /!! $=&'/! * $#4!+, . /$'* $%"+"%/'!"%( 1.* >'!(% !+'$*'!+ &."%*"%'+ ! 6!*, %'+ /!! ! '$*'! < >'%, < '"*#$'%*&5+'/% * < '#"'%* % )*++!% 6.%"%Y
C!"'".%"!, %$'"% V%+/!"/*(!+, %, %!$% ! /!"/*'! * $%&'/!
* )*++!%+ )%$% &'"+ * *:)(!$%34! +*:.%( % +*#.'"* &!$%7
4 R*.9'$ %(#. % /!"'34! %"=(!#% < * *+/$%>!, 1.*$ +.**"!-! % $%%(6!+ &!$3%!+ !. %
@!$"%% *:%.+'>%, 1.*$ +.@*'%"!-! % /!"'3*+ *#$%%"*+ * $%%(6!, 1.*$ $*+$'"#'"!, )!$1.%(1.*$ *'!, +.% (!/!!34! * $%94! * 5>'% /!"$%5% /! ! *)$*#%!$ !. )$*)!+!75 VASCONCELOS, %$'"% N!#.*'$% C!!K Tr2345o de 6essoas P*$"%./!7 A++*)(%", 200 )YY
14
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 17/59
O $=&'/! * +*$*+ 6.%"!+ – TSE, )%$% &'"+ * *:)(!$%34! +*:.%(, .%)$='/% /$''"%( 1.* +* /!"&'#.$% )!$ .% $** * *$!+, /! ! '".'! **+(!/%$ )*++!%+ * .% $*#'4! )%$% !.$% *"$! ! +*. )$)$'! )%5+$=&'/! '"*$"!K !. )%$% !.$! )%5+ $=&'/! '"*$"%/'!"%(K, % &' * 1.* +*@%
+.*'%+ < *:)(!$%34! +*:.%(, "*#%"!-(6*+ ! '$*'! < ('*$%* **+/!(6%, ! * '$ * >'$, < '#"'%* % )*++!% 6.%"%, *"$* %"!+ !.$!'$*'!+ &."%*"%'+]
E+% .('% !%('%*, *$*/* .% %*"34! %'!$, % 1.%( +*$= %% *
/%)5.(!+ %)$!)$'%!+, .% >*9 1.* ! !@*! % )*+1.'+% * /.$+!
D*+% &!$%, +*$= /!"+'*$%! ! /!"+*"'*"! %>'"! %+ $*(%3*+
*$%*"* /!*$/'%'+, !"* %+ )%$*+ ; '"*$*++*+ $*/5)$!/!+ * %"%#`"'/!+,
*">!(>*"! % %'>'%* +*:.%(, % 1.%( >* +* /!"&."'"! /! ! *('! $=&'/! *
)*++!%+ )%$% &'"+ * *:)(!$%34! +*:.%( F'"%"!, /! % *!"+$%34! * 1.*1.%"! ! /!"+*"'*"! *"$* %+ )%$*+ %>'"!, * &!$% ('>$* * >!(."=$'%,
)$*+%! )!$ %#*"* /%)%9, "4! * /!! /!"&."' % $%"+%34! /!*$/'%( /! %
')'&'/%34! $=&'/! * )*++!%+ )%$% &'"+ * *:)(!$%34! +*:.%(
D*+% &!$%, *:)(!$%$-+*-= % )$!*34! %!+ '$*'!+ * #%$%"'%+ '"'>'.%'+,
)!'+, * &!$% #*$%(, ! * .*(%!, ! !@*! @.$5'/! $*+)%(*/'! "% ')'&'/%34!
$=&'/! * )*++!%+
22 TRÁFICO DE PESSOAS7 DO CÓDI?O PENAL AO PROTOCOLO DE
PALERMO
N4! *+*$*/*"! !+ '"+'.!+ "!$%'>!+ %"*$'!$*+, )!'+ /*'3! 1.*
! B$%+'(, * +.% *>!(.34! 6'+$'/%, *(%!$!. "!$%+ /! '".'! * $*+#.%$%$ %
)$!*34! %!+ '$*'!+ * #%$%"'%+ '"'>'.%'+, * *+)*/'%(, "! 1.* '9 $*+)*'! %!
'$*'! < ('*$%*, ! 1.%( * *:)(!$%!, * &!$% /(%$% * +./'"%, )!$ M%$/.+
V'"'/'.+, 1.%"! '++*$% % $*+)*'!, '9*"! 1.* A ('*$%* . &."%*"! %
*!/$%/'% A $*#$% % ('*$%* % $*+$'34! < ('*$%* *:/*34! O '"'>'.!
('>$* *+* 1.* "4! %'"@% % ('*$%* %(6*'%, >'+! 1.* !!+ '$*'!+ ; (''*+G
E, %++', ! B$%+'( &!' $*+)*'%"! * /!"/$*'9%"!, * &!$% )$!#$*++'>%, !
/!"*:! 6'+$'/!-+!/'%( * /%% )!/% >'>*"/'%% )!$ +*. )!>!, .+/%"! .%
*(6!$'% "%+ $*(%3*+ *:'+*"*+ "! +*'! % +!/'*%*, ! 1.* >*'! % %/!"*/*$ )!$
6 VASCONCELOS, %$'"% N!#.*'$% C!!K Tr2345o de 6essoas P*$"%./!7 A++*)(%", 200 )7 RIBEIRO,M%$/.+ V'"'/'.+ !4re4tos hu;a7os e 3u7da;e7ta4s S4! P%.(!7 R.++*((, 200 ) [
15
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 18/59
*'!+ * $*#$%*"!+ /!!, )!$ *:*)(!7 % L*' ! V*"$* L'>$*, % L*' Á.$*%, % L*'
M%$'% % P*"6%, ! E+%.! ! I!+!, *"$* !.$%+
C!! %, +%'! 1.* ! B$%+'( *"6% (*#'+(%! )!$ '"+'.! )$)$'!
"! 1.* '9 $*+)*'! %! !@*! % )$*+*"* )*+1.'+%, !. +*@%, +!$* ! $=&'/! *
)*++!%+, * "*+* )!"! )!*!+ /'%$ !+ */$*!+ * "8*$!+ Y[Q0] * ][0Q,
1.* >'+% . *"&$*"%*"! %! $=&'/! * )*++!%+ )!$ "!$%+ %'+ $5#'%+
N! *"%"!, % )$*+*"* )*+1.'+% )%++%$= % %!$%$ ! $=&'/! * )*++!%+ %
)%$'$ ! P$!!/!(! A'/'!"%( < C!">*"34! %+ N%3*+ U"'%+ C!"$% ! C$'*
O$#%"'9%! T$%"+"%/'!"%( R*(%'>! < P$*>*"34!, R*)$*++4! * P."'34! ! T$=&'/! *
P*++!%+, * E+)*/'%( * M.(6*$*+ * C$'%"3%+, %'+ /!"6*/'! /!! P$!!/!(! *
P%(*$!P!'+, &!' !"* +* *. % *"%'>% '"'/'%( * ."'&!$'9%$ ! $=&'/! * )*++!%+
"% *+&*$% '"*$"%/'!"%(, /!! *, !"*, )!$ +.% >*9 $*+'* % 1.*+4! !
/!"+*"'*"! /!! *(**"%$ !@*'>! ! ')!
E++% *"%'>% +* *. "% /'%* * P%(*$! - I=('%, %5 % !$'#* O"*
>=$'!+ )%5+*+ $%'&'/%$% ! $*&*$'! P$!!/!(!, *"$* *(*+ *+%>% ! M:'/!, % I=('%,
! *1.%!$, *"$* !.$!+ O B$%+'( + >*'! % !$"%-+* +'#"%=$'! ! )$!!/!(! *
P%(*$! "! %"! * 200, %$%>+ ! */ Y0, * 0 * %$3! * 200[D*+% &!$%, !+ )%5+*+ 1.* %!%$% ! P$!!/!(! * P%(*$!, $*#*-+*
)!$ . /!"/*'! 8"'/! ! 1.* +*@% $=&'/! * )*++!%+, )%$% % +!(.34! * )!++5>*'+
/!"&('!+ "% *+&*$% '"*$"%/'!"%( O )$!!/!(! * P%(*$!, )!$ +.% >*9, * +*. %$'#!
a, %(5"*% %G *&'"* ! $=&'/! * )*++!%+ "!+ +*#.'"*+ *$!+7
%K A *:)$*++4! b$=&'/! * )*++!%+b +'#"'&'/% ! $*/$.%*"!, ! $%"+)!$*, %$%"+&*$;"/'%, ! %(!@%*"! !. ! %/!(6'*"! * )*++!%+, $*/!$$*"! <%*%3% !. .+! % &!$3% !. % !.$%+ &!$%+ * /!%34!, %! $%)!, < &$%.*, %!
*"#%"!, %! %.+! * %.!$'%* !. < +'.%34! * >.("*$%'('%* !. <*"$*#% !. %/*'%34! * )%#%*"!+ !. *"*&5/'!+ )%$% !*$ !/!"+*"'*"! * .% )*++!% 1.* *"6% %.!$'%* +!$* !.$% )%$% &'"+ **:)(!$%34!
A'"% )%$% "4! *':%$ 8>'%+, ! P$!!/!(!, >*'! *:)('/%$, * &!$% /(%$%,
"% *+% %(5"*%, ! 1.* >* % +*$ % *:)(!$%34!, $%9*"! % +*#.'"* $*%34!7
A *:)(!$%34! '"/(.'$=, "! 5"'!, % *:)(!$%34! % )$!+'.'34! * !.$* !.!.$%+ &!$%+ * *:)(!$%34! +*:.%(, ! $%%(6! !. +*$>'3!+ &!$3%!+,*+/$%>%.$% !. )$='/%+ +''(%$*+ < *+/$%>%.$%, % +*$>'4! !. % $*!34! *
$#4!+
16
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 19/59
A"%('+%"! %+ *(**"%$*+ ! ')! 1.* +4! ! $*/$.%*"!, ! $%"+)!$*, %
$%"+&*$;"/'%, ! %(!@%*"!, ! %/!(6'*"! * )*++!%+, < &$%.*, %! *"#%"!, !
%.+! * %.!$'%*, < *"$*#% !. %/*'%34! * )%#%*"!+ N4! $*+% 8>'%
1.%"! < /(%$*9% * +'#"'&'/%! * /%% 1.%( N! *"%"!, +*$= )$*/'+! . *+.!
%'+ *%(6%! "! 1.* >*"6% % +*$ *"*"'! )!$ +'.%34! * >.("*$%'('%*, .%
>*9 1.* /!" '"*$)$*%34! +.@*'>% P!$%"!, "% '"*"34! * '$''$ 1.%'+1.*$
8>'%+ 1.* )!++% >' % +.$#'$, %!%$-+*-= ! )!+'/'!"%*"! * A(*++%"$%
?$*/!Q, % 1.%( $%9 ! /!"/*'! * >.("*$=>*( /!! +*"! %1.*(*+ 1.* *$*/*
)$!*34! *+)*/'%( * >'$.* * +.% /!"'34! )*++!%( * &$%1.*9% '"'>'.%( !.
+!/'%(G D*+% &!$%, *"*"*$-+*-= 1.* )%++% )!$ +'.%34! * >.("*$%'('%* %
)*++!%, 1.* )!$ .% +'.%34! * &$%1.*9% )*++!%( !. +!/'%(, "4! /%)%9 **"*"*$ % $*%('%* * +.% >!(% /!! *(% $*%(*"* , *"*"*"! * &!$%
/%.&(%%, %*1.%"!-% % +.%+ "*/*++'%*+ )+51.'/%+ * +!/'%'+
O 1.* (*>% % /$*'%$ 1.* *++%+ )*++!%+ +4! I)!++''('%%+, * $*%('9%$
%+ '"*$)$*%3*+ "*/*++=$'%+, /!"'9*"* /! % $*%('%* S*"! %++', +4!
*$*/*!$%+ * .% )$!*34! %'!$ )!$ )%$* ! E+%!, '">%('%"! 1.%(1.*$
/!"+*"'*"! 1.* >*"6% *:*$"%$, "% *+&*$% % /!*$/'%('9%34! % %'>'%*
+*:.%(D'$''%+ %+ '"1.'*%3*+, "4! $*+% 8>'% 1.%"! .% )*++!% *+%
+*"!, !. *':%"! * +*$ *:)(!$%%, )!'+ % )$='/% %+ *(**"%$*+ ! ')!
')$*+/'"5>*( < /!"&'#.$%34! *+* *('!
D% (*'.$% ! *:/*$! $%"+/$'!, "!%-+* 1.* !/!$$* .% )$!*34! #*$%( %!
1.* )!* +*$ /!"+'*$%! /!! $=&'/! * )*++!%+, )!'+ *"#(!% %"! ! $=&'/! )%$%
&'"+ * 4!-*-!$% *+/$%>%, )%$% &'"+ * $%"+)(%"* * $#4!+, /!! % !
$=&'/! )%$% &'"+ * *:)(!$%34! +*:.%(C!"'".%"!, % *:)(!$%34! ! %$'#! a, "! P$!!/!(! * P%(*$!, % %(5"*%
G, &%9 . /!*"! '"*$*++%"*, )!'+ $%% ! /!"+*"'*"! %+ >5'%+, !$%"!
% +*#.'"* &!$%7
K O /!"+*"'*"! %! )*(% >5'% * $=&'/! * )*++!%+ *"! * >'+%1.%(1.*$ ')! * *:)(!$%34! *+/$'! "% %(5"*% %K ! )$*+*"* A$'#! +*$=/!"+'*$%! '$$*(*>%"* +* '>*$ +'! .'('9%! 1.%(1.*$ . !+ *'!+$*&*$'!+ "% %(5"*% %K #$'&!.-+*K
8 ?RECO, A(*++%"$% O$/*+' P*$! J_NIORMARZA?ÃO, L%*$* I /!!K * %( Tr2345o de 6essoasS4! P%.(!7 .%$'*$ L%'", 200 ) 2Q
17
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 20/59
O 1.* &%9 "!%$, 1.* ! /$'* * $=&'/! * )*++!%+, "% !%('%*
)$!+'.'34!, * +.% *++;"/'%, + %/!"*/* 1.%"! "4! )$*+*"* ! /!"+*"'*"!
%+ )%$*+, !., "! 5"'!, 1.%"! "4! &!$ *+* %(/%"3%! * &!$% ('>$*, !. 1.%"!
*+'>*$ )$*+*"* < =-&
P!$, +* )$*+*"* ! /!"+*"'*"!, !. *++* &!' *:$%5! * !% & +*
1.* %+ )*++!%+ +* +'"%, !. +*@% *"#%"%%+, "4! 6= ! 1.* &%(%$ * /$'* %(#.
A++', *>* %"%('+%$, * &!$% $=)'%, %+ !%('%* * $=&'/! *
)*++!%+, * %>*$'#.%$ +* "*(%+ /%*$'% !. "4! /!"+'*$%$ ! /!"+*"'*"! 8.! %+
)%$*+, /!! &!$% *+/%$%/*$'9%!$% ! /$'* E++% % )$!*34! 1.* .+/%
#%$%"'$ ! P$!!/!(! * P%(*$!, !. +*@%, $*+#.%$%$ % ('*$%* ! '"'>'.!,
)$!*#*"!-! 1.%"! +*. /!"+*"'*"! &!$ *:$%5! * &!$% *"#%"!+%, "! *"%"!)!++''('%"! % $%"+%34! /!*$/'%(, 1.%"! ! /!"+*"'*"! +.$#'$ * &!$% ('>$* *
>!(."=$'%
N! 1.* %"#* % C!"+'.'34! F**$%( ! B$%+'( * QQ /!"+'.'34!, )!*-
+* '9*$ 1.* &!' %$/%"* % %*"34! %% %! *('! $=&'/! * )*++!%+, .% >*9 1.*
$*+#.%$!. ! '$*'! < ('*$%* * ! '$*'! < '#"'%* % )*++!% 6.%"%, /!!
%"*+ "."/% &!$% $*#'+$%! "!+ %$/!+ % 6'+$'% %+ C!"+'.'3*+ $%+'(*'$%+
A"*+, ! B$%+'( *:)(!$%>% /!! 4!-*-!$% *+/$%>% !+ "*#$!+ $%9'!+,* +.% %'!$'%, ! /!"'"*"* %&$'/%"! C! % %!('34! % *+/$%>%.$%, * %
$*+'+;"/'% * %/*'%$ *+* &%!, ! $%+'(*'$! )%++!. % *:)(!$%$ ! $%"/!, +*"! 1.*
* '"'/'! *++% *:)(!$%34!, *>* /!! %(>! %+ .(6*$*+, %+ 1.%'+ *$% $%&'/%%+
/! &'"+ +*:.%'+
P!+*$'!$*"* /6*#!., * )*$.$% %* ! )$*+*"*, % *:)(!$%34! * &!$%
(*#%('9%%, +*"! %$'.5% < *+'#.%(%* +!/'%( * "4! % /!"'34! * +*$ 6.%"!,
/!! !.$!$%, .% >*9 1.* "4! ')!$% %'+ % /!$ % )*(*, ! +*:!, % *"'%, %'++', ! #$%. "% 6'*$%$1.'% +!/'%( 1.* /%% . !/.)%, * 1.%"! *"!$ &!$, %'!$ +*$=
% )!++''('%* * +*$ %(>! % *:)(!$%34!, !. +*@%, /6*#!. % >*9 % *:)(!$%34!
/%.&(%% )*(! /%)'%('+!
N!+ *)!+ !*$"!+, ! /%"'%('+! * % *+/$%>'4! /!">*$#'$% )%$% %+*$>'4! * +.% &!$% %'+ $*(*+ O +*$>'( ! )!$* E(* ! "!>! !.$! c,"%+ +!/'*%*+ /!"*)!$"*%+, ! #$.)! +* %(% E, /! % #(!%('9%34!,!+ )!$*+ &!$% . #$.)! +* &$!"*'$%+7 !!+ !+ )!$*+ ! ."! +4!.% /!'+%G + – . %"/!G * $%%(6! * * $#4!+ S*1^*+$%$, %%$,
18
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 21/59
6.'(6%$, $*'$%$ $#4!+ !. /!)$%-(!+ T.! @.+'&'/=>*( * )*$''! A&'"%(1.%( +*$'% % .'('%* !+ )!$*+d
T%'+ /!"+'*$%3*+ *!"+$%, * &!$% *:)(5/'%, % *:'+;"/'% *
>'!(%34! %! '$*'! < '#.%(%*, /!"+%#$%! "! !@! ! A$ Ya, /%)., % C!"+'.'34!F**$%(, 1.* '+)*7
T!!+ +4! '#.%'+ )*$%"* % (*', +* '+'"34! * 1.%(1.*$ "%.$*9%,#%$%"'"!-+* %!+ $%+'(*'$!+ * %!+ *+$%"#*'$!+ $*+'*"*+ "! P%5+ %'">'!(%'('%* ! '$*'! < >'%, < ('*$%*, < '#.%(%*, < +*#.$%"3% * <)$!)$'*%*, "!+ *$!+ +*#.'"*+7
V*$'&'/%-+*, "*++* /!"*:! 1.* % *+'#.%(%* !/!$$*$ * &!$%
*$/%"'( N! *"%"!, % 1.* )!"! *+% >'!(%34!, %! '$*'! * '#.%(%*, -
*:)(!$%34! ! 6!* )*(! 6!* - )!* +*$ /!"+'*$%% (5/'%, 1.%"! ! *('!,$=&'/! * )*++!%+, +* /!"&."' /! ! '$*'! < ('*$%*d
P!$ /!"+*1^;"/'%, * '%+ %.%'+, +.$#* .% "!>% &!$% * *:)(!$%34!
1.* )%$* ! 6!* )%$% ! 6!* T!%>'%, '&*$*"/'%-+*, /!"&!$* ! !@*!, .%
>*9 1.* %#!$%, *:)(!$%-+* % %'>'%* +*:.%(, )$'"/')%(*"* %+ .(6*$*+, )!'+
* %'+ $*"=>*(, %'+ (./$%'>%, * "4! )*$*/5>*( * '*'%!
.%"! %! C'#! P*"%( B$%+'(*'$!, % ')'&'/%34! ! $=&'/! * )*++!%+
*"/!"$%-+* "! %$ 2 /! % +*#.'"* $*%34!7
P$!!>*$ !. &%/'('%$ % *"$%%, "! *$$'$'! "%/'!"%(, * %(#. 1.* "*(*>*"6% % *:*$/*$ % )$!+'.'34! !. !.$% &!$% * *:)(!$%34! +*:.%(, !. %+%5% * %(#. 1.* >= *:*$/;-(% "! *+$%"#*'$!P*"% - $*/(.+4!, * $;+K % Q !'!K %"!+e ! I"/!$$* "% *+% )*"% %1.*(* 1.* %#*"/'%$, %('/'%$ !. /!)$%$ %)*++!% $%&'/%%, %++' /!!, *"! /!"6*/'*"! *++% /!"'34!,$%"+)!$=-(%, $%"+&*$'-(% !. %(!@=-(%
A L*' 0], * 2Q * %$3! * 200Y, >*'! $%9*$ "!>% $*%34! %! *('!
$=&'/! '"*$"%/'!"%( * )*++!%+, ! 1.%( %"*+ % *+% *$% /!"6*/'! /!! $=&'/!* .(6*$*+G ! 1.* (''%>% % %$%"#;"/'% ! +.@*'! )%++'>!, !"* + %+ .(6*$*+,
*:/(.+'>%*"* *++%+, )!*$'% +*$ >5'%+ *++* *('!
I++! +* %>% )!$ /%.+% !+ /!+.*+ +!/'%'+, .% >*9 1.* "% )!/% %
$*%34! !$'#'"%( ! C'#! P*"%(, "4! *$% >'+(.$%! % )!++''('%* * ! 6!*
+*$ %(>! ! $=&'/! )%$% &'"+ * )$!+'.'34!
C!! % *$% (''%! ! !@*! @.$5'/!, +* %$%"#*$ % &'"%('%* !$=&'/! )%$% &'"+ * *:)(!$%34! +*:.%( * )%$% $*!34! * $#4!+
9 VASCONCELOS, C!!K %). BERLIN?UER Tr2345o de 6essoas P*$"%./!7 A++*)(%", 200) 0
19
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 22/59
S* 8>'%, < )!/% * 1.* ! /'#! )*"%( &!' *'%!, *$% '"'%#'"=>*( !$=&'/! * 6!*"+ )%$% *:*$/*$ % )$!+'.'34! L%*"%>*(*"*, *++% )$='/%+* !$"!. /!. f >'+% '++!, &!' "*/*++=$'! )$!*#*$ %+ >5'%+ ! +*:!%+/.('"!, +! )*"% * #$%>* !&*"+% %!+ )$'"/5)'!+ % '#"'%* % )*++!%+6.%"% * % '#.%(%*0
c '"*$*++%"*, % !+*$>%$ %(#.%+ %(*$%3*+ $%9'%+ )*(% L*' "a
20Y, * 0 * %#!+! * 200, /!*3%"! )*(% "!>% "!*"/(%.$% 1.* +* *.
%! 5.(! 1.* %"*+ *$% /!"6*/'! /!! !+ /$'*+ /!"$% !+ /!+.*+G * % )%$'$
% $*&*$'% (*', )%++!.-+* % +*$ /6%%! !+ /$'*+ /!"$% % '#"'%* +*:.%(G,
"!%-+* * &!$% )$*)!"*$%"* 1.* 6!.>* .% *>!(.34! "% "!$%, %/!)%"6%"!
% *>!(.34! +!/'%( U% >*9 1.* ! *('! $=&'/! * )*++!%+ &!$% '"+*$'! "! 5.(! !+
/$'*+ /!"$% !+ /!+.*+, )!$ /%.+% !+ >%(!$*+ !$%'+ !'"%"* "% )!/% 1.*
+.$#'. ! C'#! P*"%( E++% %(*$%34! *&*"'%, /! )$!*9% )!$ F*$"%"! C%)*9
N4! +* * * >'+%, %#!$%, * )$'*'$! )(%"!, % !$%( '% % +!/'*%*,! $*+#.%$! !+ !"+ /!+.*+, '+! , ! '"*$*++* * *$/*'$!+ /!! *%'+ $*(*>%"* % +*$ )$!*#'! %+ % )$!*34! % '#"'%* ! '"'>5.! +!! )!"! * >'+% +*:.%(
P%$% %/$*+/*"%$, % (*' * /!*"! %)('!. ! !@*! @.$5'/! $*+#.%$%!
"! *('! )*"%(, >'+! 1.* %/$*+/*"!. %! )$*/*'! )$'=$'! ! %$'#! 2 ! *$!
*:)(!$%34! +*:.%(G, %.*"%"! %+ )!++''('%*+, T!$"%"! % )$!+'.'34! .%
*+)/'* ! #;"*$! *:)(!$%34! +*:.%(
P!$ +.% >*9, *+* *$! *:)(!$%34! +*:.%(, * *&'"'! )!$ R!#$'!S%"/6*+ %). E>%+ F%(*'$!+ 200, ) 2YK, % +*#.'"* &!$%7
U% !'"%34! * %.+! ! /!$)! * /$'%"3%+, %!(*+/*"*+ * %.(!+!&*$%K, )!$ *:)(!$%!$*+ +*:.%'+ *$/%!$*+K, !. )!$ )%'+ !. $*+)!"+=>*'+,* )!$ /!"+.'!$*+ * +*$>'3!+ +*:.%'+ )%#!+ *%"%K, %''"! 1.%$!!%('%*+2K
A $*+)*'! ! $=&'/! '"*$"! * )*++!%+, ! B$%+'( + %!!. *++%
)!++''('%* 1.%"! +* !$"!. +'#"%=$'! ! P$!!/!(! * P%(*$!, %$%>+ % L*'
10 CAPEZ, F*$"%"! MARZA?ÃO J_NIOR, L%*$* I /!!K * %( Tr2345o de 6essoas S4! P%.(!7.%$'*$ L%'", 200 ) 2]11 I* ) 12 SANCHES, R!#$'! ?OMES, L.'9 F(=>'! /`!K %). FALEIROS, E !4re4to 6e7al: 6arte es6e54al > * S4! P%.(!7 RT, 200 ) 2Y A &' * )$!)'/'%$ .% *(6!$ *:)(%"%34!, * '$''$ 1.%'+1.*$ 8>'%+, +*#.* %+ !%('%*+/(%++'&'/%%+ )*(% %.!$%7 %K )$!+'.'34! – %'>'%* "% 1.%( %!+ +*:.%'+ +4! "*#!/'%! * $!/% *)%#%*"!, "4! %)*"%+ !"*=$'! K .$'+! +*:.%( – ! /!$/'! +*:.%(, * %$'/.(%!, */'%*+ .$5+'/%+, *">!(>*"! .$'+%+ "%/'!"%'+ * *+$%"#*'$!+ * )$'"/')%(*"* .(6*$*+ @!>*"+, *+*!$*+ *:/(.5!+ * )%5+*+ * *$/*'$! ."! /K )!$"!#$%&'% - )$!.34! *:''34!, '+$'.'34!,
>*"%, /!)$% )!++* * .'('9%34! * %*$'%( )!$"!#$=&'/!, )$*+*"* % "% ('*$%.$%, /'"*%,)$!)%#%"% */ * K $=&'/! )%$% &'"+ +*:.%'+ – !>'*"! /(%"*+'"! * '(5/'! * )*++!%+ %$%>+ *&$!"*'$%+ "%/'!"%'+, /! ! !@*'>! * &!$3%$ .(6*$*+ * %!(*+/*"*+ % *"$%$ * +'.%3*++*:.%(*"* !)$*++!$%+ * *:)(!$%!$%+, )%$% (./$!+ * %('/'%!$*+
20
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 23/59
0], * 2Q * %$3! * 200Y, 1.* )%++!. % +*$ /!"'! "! %$ 2 – A !
C'#! P*"%(, /! % +*#.'"* $*%34!7
P$!!>*$, '"*$*'%$ !. &%/'('%$, "! *$$'$'! "%/'!"%(, ! $*/$.%*"!, !$%"+)!$*, % $%"+&*$;"/'%, ! %(!@%*"! !. ! %/!(6'*"! % )*++!% 1.*>*"6% *:*$/*$ % )$!+'.'34!7 P*"% - R*/(.+4!, * $;+K % Q %"!+, * .(%
C! ! %>*"! % L*' 20Y200, ! %$ 2 – A, ! C'#! P*"%(,
)%++!. % *$ % "!*"/(%.$% * $=&'/! '"*$"! * )*++!%+ )%$% &' * *:)(!$%34!
+*:.%(G $%9*"! * +*. !@! % +*#.'"* $*%34!7
P$!!>*$ !. &%/'('%$ ! *+(!/%*"! * %(#. *"$! ! *$$'$'! "%/'!"%()%$% ! *:*$/5/'! % )$!+'.'34! !. !.$% &!$% * *:)(!$%34! +*:.%(7P*"% - $*/(.+4!, * 2 !'+K % ] +*'+K %"!+e ! I"/!$$* "% *+% )*"% %1.*(* 1.* %#*"/'%$, %('/'%$, >*"*$ !. /!)$%$% )*++!% $%&'/%%, %++' /!!, *"! /!"6*/'*"! *++% /!"'34!,$%"+)!$=-(%, $%"+&*$'-(% !. %(!@=-(%
c "!=>*( % +**(6%"3% *"$* . '+)!+''>! * ! !.$!, +*"! '&*$*"*+,
"!+ ('5$!&*+ &$!"*'$%'+ .% >*9 1.* ! A$ 2 >'+% ! $=&'/! * )*++!%+ %( %+
*$$%+ $%+'(*'$%+, !. 1.%"! $*%('9%!+ "! B$%+'(, *"6% . *+$%"#*'$! /!! >5'%
E"1.%"! ! T$%&'/! '"*$"! * )*++!%+, * .% %$%"#;"/'% %'+
$*+$'%, !. +*@%, ! 1.* '&*$* . ')! ! !.$! ! *(**"! *+)%/'%(
2 DO CONSENTIMENTO NO TRÁFICO DE PESSOAS
A"*+ * $%%$ ! !@*! )$*/5).! % )*+1.'+%, +*$= "*/*++=$'! %!$%$ !
/!"+*"'*"! "%+ *%'+ !%('%*+ * $=&'/! 6.%"! C!*3%"! "% 1.*+4!
! /!"+*"'*"! "! $=&'/! * )*++!%+ )%$% &'"+ * *:)(!$%34! * 4!-*-!$%
*+/$%>%, .% >*9 1.* *+* "4! ! !@*'>! % )*+1.'+%, )!'+ "4! 6= /!! &%(%$ *
/!"+*"'*"! %+ )%$*+, )!$1.* % &'"%('%* *++% %34! *('.!+% +.**$ !
+*$ 6.%"! <+ /!"'3*+ %"=(!#%+ < * *+/$%>!+ $%%(6%"! +* $*/**$
13 M'"'+$'! ! T$%%(6! * E)$*#! Tra<alho es5ravo 6er=u7tas e res6ostas D'+)!"5>*( *7g6)7*#!>$')$*"+%*&%.(%+)h A/*++! *7 0Y * J." 200 O M'"'+$'! ! T$%%(6!* E)$*#! MTEK >* *"*"*"! % /!"'34! %"=(!#% % * *+/$%>! % +*#.'"* &!$%7 O C'#!P*"%( B$%+'(*'$! *+/$*>* 1.%$! /!".%+ 1.* * /!"@."! !. '+!(%%*"* /!"&'#.$% ! /$'* *$*.34! < /!"'34! %"=(!#% % * *+/$%>! S4! *(%+7 i S.**$ ! $%%(6%!$ % $%%(6!+ &!$3%!+ iS.**$ ! $%%(6%!$ < @!$"%% *:%.+'>% i S.@*'%$ ! $%%(6%!$ % /!"'3*+ *#$%%"*+ *
$%%(6! i R*+$'"#'$ % (!/!!34! ! $%%(6%!$ * $%94! * 5>'% )%$% /! *)$*#%!$ !.)$*)!+! N*++% !%('%*, /!"6*/'% /!! +*$>'4! )!$ 5>'%G, !+ $%%(6%!$*+ +4! /!%#'!+,&5+'/% * !$%(*"*, % )*$%"*/*$ "%+ )$!)$'*%*+ $.$%'+ % +%(%$* !+ '!+ % 1.* &!$%+.*'!+ )!$ *'!+ &$%..(*"!+ !. )*(%+ /!"'3*+ /!"$%.%'+ * $%%(6!
21
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 24/59
1.%(1.*$ /!"$%)$*+%34!, !. 1.%"! $*/**, '"&*$'!$ %! 1.* $*%(*"* *>*$'%
$*/**$, (%!$%"! * /!"'3*+ )$*/=$'%+, '+*$=>*'+
D*+% &!$%, "4! 6= /!! &%(%$ * /!"+*"'*"!, )!'+ "'"#. * +*.
*+%! *!/'!"%(, *"$! % "!$%('%* /!"/!$%$'% * +* +.**$ % %'+
/!"'3*+
P!$ +.% >*9, "! 1.* '9 $*+)*'! %! $=&'/! * )*++!%+ )%$% &'"+ *
$%"+)(%"* * $#4!+ %&%+%! ! /!"+*"'*"!, >'+! 1.* &*$* % '"*#$'%* &5+'/%
! '"'>'.!, /%.+%"!-(6* . %( '$$*)%$=>*(, "4! +*"! '+)!"5>*( * %/%$$*%"!
''".'34! "% '"*#$'%* &5+'/% ! 6!*, /!! * >'!(%34! %! '$*'! < >'% * <
'#"'%* % )*++!% 6.%"%
A $*!34! * $#4!+ )%$% &'"+ /!*$/'%'+, !%('%* ! $=&'/! * )*++!%+,% /!"6*/'! /!! $=&'/! * $#4!+, . /$'* $%"+"%/'!"%( 1.*>'!(% !+ '$*'!+ &."%*"%'+ ! 6!*, %'+ /!! ! '$*'! < >'%, <'"*#$'%* &5+'/%, * < '#"'%* % )*++!% 6.%"% [
E++* '"+$.*"! $%%! "! %$ ! C'#! C'>'( P=$'!, '" >*$'+7
A$ S%(>! )!$ *:'#;"/'% '/%, *&*+! ! %! * '+)!+'34! ! )$)$'!/!$)!, 1.%"! ')!$%$ ''".'34! )*$%"*"* % '"*#$'%* &5+'/%, !./!"$%$'%$ !+ !"+ /!+.*+P%$=#$%&! 8"'/! O %! )$*>'+! "*+* %$'#! +*$= %''! )%$% &'"+ *$%"+)(%"*, "% &!$% *+%*(*/'% * (*' *+)*/'%(
O. +*@%, "4! )!* 6%>*$ ! /!"+*"'*"! 1.%"! !/!$$*$ .% $%"+%34!,
*"! /!! !@*! % '+)!+'34! ! /!$)!, * !! !. * )%$*, /! &'"+ (./$%'>!+,
$*+%"! < )!++''('%* )%$% &'"+ /'*"5&'/!+, %($.5+%+, %'+ + )%$% *)!'+ %
!$* * *+! %++', "4! )!* *:'+'$ % &'"%('%* /!*$/'%(, /!"&!$* $*9% ! %$
[ ! C'#! C'>'(
A$ [ c >=('%, /! !@*'>! /'*"5&'/!, !. %($.5+'/!, % '+)!+'34! #$%.'%! )$)$'! /!$)!, "! !! !. * )%$*, )%$% *)!'+ % !$*P%$=#$%&! 8"'/! O %! * '+)!+'34! )!* +*$ ('>$**"* $*>!#%! %1.%(1.*$ *)!
A++."! $%%! * &!$% %'+ *%(6%% )!$ S'(>'! V*"!+%, "% %"%('+*
$*%('9%% "! D'$*'! % P*$+!"%('%* )%$% '+)!$ ! )$)$'! /!$)!
T$%%-+* * +'.%34! '"/*"'>%% )*(! E+%!, % &' * )$!)'/'%$ % >'% /!!+ $#4!+ !+ 1.* @= +* &!$% A !%34! * $#4! )!+ !$* "4! *>* *$1.%(1.*$ /."6! )*/."'=$'! )!$1.* '!$%( * /!"$=$'! %!+ !"+ /!+.*+N.(%, )!$ %.+;"/'% * !@*! (5/'!, +*$= 1.%(1.*$ '+)!+'34! "*++* +*"'! O/."6! % '+)!+'34! *>*$= +*$ *:/(.+'>%*"* /'*"5&'/! * %($.5+'/! C%*
%! (*#'+(%!$ /!''$, '"/(.+'>* )*"%(*"*, ! *+>'! * &'"%('%* "*++*
14 VASCONCELOS, %$'"% N!#.*'$% C!!K Tr2345o de 6essoas P*$"%./!7 A++*)(%", 200 )
22
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 25/59
/%)! A &%/.(%* * !%$ $#4!+ %)+ % !$* '$*'! )!*+%'>! %)*++!%, )!*"! % */'+4! "*++* +*"'!, )!$ *++% $%94!, +*$ $*>!#%% %1.%(1.*$ *)! %$ [ )%$=#$%&! 8"'/!KY
O '"+'.! @.$5'/! 1.* $%% % !%34! * $#4!+, */'!+ * )%$*+ !
/!$)! 6.%"! )%$% &'"+ * $%"+)(%"* * $%%*"! % (*' [[ * 0[ * &*>*$*'$!
* 200, "*(% *+% )$*>'+% %+ 6')*+*+ (*#%'+ * '+)!+'34! ! /!$)! %"*+ !.
)!+*$'!$ < !$*, "! *"%"! "*(% "4! +4! *+/%$%!+ !+ /%$%/*$*+ % #$%.'%*
* ! %($.5+!
U% 1.*+4! '"*$*++%"*, 1.* *>* +*$ '$''% '9 $*+)*'! < !%34! *
+%"#.* *"*"*"!, *+% /!! +*"! ! )$!/*++! )*(! 1.%( . !%!$ >!(."=$'!
* +*. +%"#.* /!(*%! )%$% %$%9*"%*"! * . %"/! * +%"#.* !. )%$% .
.+! +.+*1.*"* * .% $%"+&.+4! * +%"#.*G] N! *"%"!, % '"1.'*%34! >*
/! % )!++''('%* * +*$ $*%('9%%, %( $%"+&.+4! * &!$% '">!"('"=$'%, +* 1.*
*"6% ! /!"+*"'*"! ! '"'>'.!
D*+% &!$%, *&*"*-+*, 1.* ! /%+! * >!#%, "4! +* *"1.%$%$'% "!
*('! $=&'/! * )*++!%+, )%$% &'"+ * $*!34! * !$#4!, - "4! 1.*$*"! %.&*$'$ .
/%$=*$ '>*$+! ! 1.* $*%(*"* +* %$ %! +%"#.*, .% >*9 1.* ! *+! +*
8>'%+ . */'!, * /!! %( *$*/* +*$ )$!*#'!, /!! * %/!"*/* /! !+
!$#4!+ ! /!$%34!, ! ).(4!K, * %++' >* %/!"*/*"! - %'+ +', *+%$'% '%"*
* .% (*+4! /!$)!$%( * "%.$*9% (*>*, .% >*9 1.* ! +%"#.*, * $*#$%,
$*"!>=>*(, * "4! /%.+% *'('%*, )*$%"*"* "! '"'>'.! C!! * )$*(*/'!"%
S'(>'! V*"!+% 200, ) Q0K
A (*' "a [[, * [-2-, '+)* +!$* % $*!34! * !$#4!+, */'!+ *)%$*+ ! /!$)! 6.%"! )%$% &'"+ * $%"+)(%"* * $%%*"! E++* ')(!%*+)*/'&'/% 1.* "4! *+4! /!)$'*"'!+ * +*. '!, *"$* !+ */'!+, !+%"#.* ! *+)*$% * >.(!, )!'+ +4!$*"!>=>*'+ "! /!$)! 6.%"!
E, /!"+'*$%"! % 6')!*+* /!! .% (*+4! /!$)!$%( * "%.$*9% (*>*, %
*+% *)*"*$= * $*)$*+*"%34! )!$ )%$* ! !&*"'! !. % >''%, *, /!! +*
)$**"* *!"+$%$, %'+ % '%"*, ! /!"+*"'*"! %'>'"!, "*+*+ /%+!+, %
*+! )!+*$'!$ !. /!"/!'%"* % %34! *('.!+% +*$>* /!! /%.+% * *:/(.*"*
% %"'@.$''/'%*
.%"! %! /!"+*"'*"! "! $=&'/! * )*++!%+ )%$% &'"+ ! *:*$/5/'! %
)$!+'.'34! - !@*'>! )$'"/')%( % )$*+*"* )*+1.'+% - *+* *>* +*$ /!"+'*$%!,
15 VENOSA, S'(>'! * S%(>! !4re4to 54v4l: 6arte =eral 0 * S4! P%.(!7 A(%+, 200 ) Q016 jIIPcDIA, % *"/'/(!)'% ('>$* !oa9o de sa7=ue D'+)!"5>*( *7g6)7)'')*'%!$#''D!%kCkAkCkA!*+%"#.*h A/*++! *7 0Y @." 200
23
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 26/59
)!'+ )*$/**++* 1.*, $*'$%"!-+* !+ %+)*/!+ 1.* !$"% *+% )$='/% . /$'*
!+ %'+ /$.'+, % +%*$7 % &$%.*, % /!%34!, ! $%)!, ! *"#%"!, >*$'&'/%-+* 1.* !
('>$* /!">*"/'*"! )!*$= &%9*$ /! 1.* % !%('%* )$!+'.'34! +*@% *:/(.5%
*+% +*%$% )*(!+ %$#.*"!+ 1.* +*$4! *:)(!$%!+ "! */!$$*$ *+% )*+1.'+%,
.% >*9 1.* ! *:*$/5/'! % )$!+'.'34! ('>$*, * (5/'! "! )%5+, /%$*/*!$ %)*"%+ *
'"+'.!+ "!$%'>!+ )%$% +.% $*#.(%*"%34!
D*+% &!$%, ! /!"+*"'*"! *"$* %+ )%$*+ )!*$= *:/(.'$ ! 1.*
/(%++'&'/%! /!! $=&'/! * )*++!%+ "% !%('%* )$!+'.'34!, /!!, %!$%$-+*-
= * )=#'"%+ >'"!.$%+
24
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 27/59
) !I'ER*+CIAS ,UR!ICO-!OUTRIARIAS .UATO A COCEITUA"#O!E CRIME
C!! /*'3!, "4! * !! .""'* ! /!"/*'! * /$'*, "4! + "!
!$*"%*"! @.$5'/! )=$'! /!! "!+ !$*"%*"!+ %('*"5#*"%+, +.$#'"! %++', %+
'>*$#;"/'%+ !.$'"%$'%+ I++! !/!$$* )!$1.* ! /'#! )*"%( "4! $!.:*, * +*.
!@!, ! /!"/*'! *:)$*++! ! 1.* >* % +*$ ! /$'*, *':%"! % /$'$'! !+ !.!+,
*++* '+*$
D*+% &!$%, % !.$'"% >* %!%"! $;+ *!$'%+ 1.* $%%(6% !
/!"/*'! ! /$'*, /%$%/*$'9%"!-(6* /!! &!$%(, %*$'%( * %"%(5'/!
.* * $*+.* *++* )%)*( B*'!(, 1.%"! %). R!#$'! ?$*/!,%!
'9*$7
.%+ /!"/*)3*+ !)!+%+ +* *%* *"$* +' /! % &'"%('%* */!"/*'.%$ ! /$'*7 .% * /%$=*$ &!$%(, !.$% * /%$=*$ +.+%"/'%( A)$'*'$% %-+* %! /$'* sub es'(cie iuris, "! +*"'! * /!"+'*$%$ !/$'* l!! ! &%! 6.%"!, )$!''! )*(% (*' )*"%(m A +*#."%, )!$ +.%>*9, +.)*$% *++* &!$%('+! /!"+'*$%"! ! /$'* l!! ! &%! 6.%"!(*+'>! * . '"*$*++* /%)%9 * /!)$!**$ %+ /!"'3*+ * *:'+;"/'%,* /!"+*$>%34! * * *+*">!(>'*"! % +!/'*%*m
S*"! %++', $%%(6%$-+*-= !+ /!"/*'!+ %!%!+ )*(% !.$'"%,
!%"! /!! '"5/'! ! /!"/*'! F!$%(, !"* ! /$'* +* /!"&."* /! +*. /!"/*'!
*+%*(*/'! * (*', +*"! *"*"'!, %)*"%+ /!! *$% /!".% *+)*$%% *
)$*+.'% "%+ (*'+ )*"%'+ *'%%+ )*(! (*#'+(%!$ L!#!, S! ! %+)*/! &!$%(,
/$'* +*$'% !% /!".% 1.* %*"%++*, 1.* /!(''++* &$!"%(*"* /!"$% % (*' )*"%(
*'%% )*(! E+%!GQ
C!".!, )%$% M'$%**, $*%('9%"! . *+.! +!$* ! /!"/*'! * /$'*
&!$%(, (*/'!"% 1.*
E++%+ *&'"'3*+, *"$*%"!, %(/%"3% %)*"%+ . !+ %+)*/!+ !&*"`*"! /$''"%(, ! %'+ %)%$*"*, 1.* % /!"$%'34! ! &%! % .%"!$% * '$*'!, !. +*@%, +.% '(*#%('%* /!! &%! /!"$=$'! < "!$%)*"%( N4! )*"*$%, /!".!, * +.% *++;"/'% * +*. /!"*8!, * +.%%$'%G
17 BETTIOL %). ?RECO, R!#$'! Curso de d4re4to 6e7al: 6arte =eral 2 * R'! * J%"*'$!7I)*.+, 200 ) ]18 ?RECO, R!#$'! Curso de d4re4to 6e7al: 6arte =eral 2 * R'! * J%"*'$!7 I)*.+, 200 )]19 MIRABETE, J.('! F%$'"' FABBRINI, R*"%! N Ma7ual de d4re4to 6e7al: 6arte =eral 2] * S4!P.(!7 A(%+, 200 ) Q
25
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 28/59
.%"! %! /!"/*'! %*$'%( * /$'*, %!%$-+*-= % )!+'34! !.$'"%$'% *
?.'(6*$* * N.//'20 YK, .% >*9 1.* )%$% *(* ! /$'* %*$'%( c % /!"/*)34!
% +!/'*%* +!$* ! 1.* )!* * *>* +*$ )$!''!, *'%"* % %)('/%34! * +%"34!
)*"%( c, )!'+, % /!".% 1.* !&*"* . * @.$''/%*"* .*(%!, *$*/*!$% *
)*"%G O. +*@%, ! /!"/*'! %*$'%( * /$'*, "%% %+ 1.* .% /!".% (*+'>% %!
* @.$5'/! .*(%! )*(! E+%!, ! 1.%(, $*+)!"+=>*( )*(% +*(*34! * )$!*34! %!+
*"+ @.$5'/!+, %%$/%!+ )*(%+ (*'+ )*"%'+, !"*, *"%-+* *>'%$ %+ >'!(%3*+,
')!"! %+ +%"3*+ )*"%'+, !/%+'!"%"! .% )$!)!$34! *"$* % )$!*34! * %
>'!(%34! %! * @.$5'/! .*(%!
A'"%, "% /!"/*)34! * M'$%**2 T* ! E+%! < &'"%('%* * !*$ !
* /!(*'>!, %"*"! % !$*, % 6%$!"'% * ! *1.'(5$'! +!/'%(, 1.%(1.*$ 1.* +*@%% &'"%('%* ! E+%! * /!., * ! )$!(*%$'%!, */K !. ! +*. $*#'*
)!(5'/! *!/$%/'%, %.!$'%$'+!, +!/'%('+!, */KG O 1.* $*+.(% * .%
!$'#%34! ! E+%! "% )$!*34! !+ *"+ @.$5'/!+ 1.* ! *+! $*+!(>* .*(%$,
)*$%"* % >'!(%34! !+ '$*'!+ '"'>'.%'+ * +*.+ /'%4!+
N! 1.* %"#* %! /!"/*'! %"%(5'/! * /$'* )!*-+* '9*$, +*#."!
N.//'22 1.* % /!"/*)34! % /';"/'% ! '$*'!, 1.* "4! '&*$*, "% *++;"/'%, !
/!"/*'! &!$%( N% $*%('%*, ! /!"/*'! &!$%( &$%#*"%! * *(**"!+ 1.*)$!)'/'% ! *(6!$ *"*"'*"! % +.% %$%"#;"/'%G
C!"/*'.%$ /$'* * +*. %+)*/! %"%(5'/! %$*&% =$.% U% >*9 1.*,
/!! >'+!, ! *+! .% *+)/'* * &$%#*"%34! ! /!"/*'! &!$%(, )!$,
/!"+'.5! )!$ *(**"!+ )$)$'!+ O 1.* %/%$$*% %(#.%+ '"*$)$*%3*+ *
'>*$#;"/'%+ +!$* !+ *(**"!+ /!)!"*"*+ *++% &$%#*"%$'*%*
C!"'".%"! ! $%/'!/5"'! * N.//'2, *++* *&*"* 1.*
T$%%-+* * .% /!".% 5)'/%, %"'@.$5'/% * /.()=>*(, >%(* '9*$, .%%34! !. !'++4! %@.+%% % . !*(! (*#%( * /!".% )$!''%')'/'%*K, /!"$=$'% %! '$*'! %"'@.$5'/%K * +.@*'% % . @.59! *$*)$!>%34! +!/'%( '"/'*"* +!$* ! &%! * +*. %.!$, *+* 1.* *:'+%').%'('%*, /!"+/';"/'% )!*"/'%( * * *:'#''('%* * )!++''('%* *%#'$ /!"&!$* ! '$*'!
20 NUCCI ?.'(6*$* * S!.9% Ma7ual de d4re4to 6e7al: 6arte =eral e es6e54al * S4! P%.(!7$*>'+%+ !+ $'."%'+, 200 ) Y21 MIRABETE, J.('! F%$'"' FABBRINI, R*"%! N Ma7ual de d4re4to 6e7al: 6arte =eral 2] * S4!
P.(!7 A(%+, 200 ) Q222 NUCCI ?.'(6*$* * S!.9% Ma7ual de d4re4to 6e7al: 6arte =eral e 6arte es6e54al * S4!P%.(!7 $*>'+%+ !+ $'."%'+, 200 ) ]023 I*
26
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 29/59
A"%('+%"!, *++* /!"/*'! $')%$'*, >*$-+* 1.* ! /!"/*'! * /$'*
%$%"#*7 % ')'/'%*, % %"'@.$''/'%* * % /.()%'('%* E++* ! )!+'/'!"%*"!
%@!$'=$'! "% !.$'"% )=$'% * *+$%"#*'$%
N! *"%"!, % /!"$=$'! +*"+., *!+ ! )!+'/'!"%*"! 1.* *+)!+%!
)!$ )%$* * .% /!$$*"* !.$'"% '"!$'=$'%, *"$* *(*+, '$*!+ /'%$ % !)'"'4! *
M'$%**2[ 1.* )*$&'(6% % +*#.'"* &!$%
O /$'* *:'+* * +' *+!, )!$ +*$ . &%! 5)'/! * %"'@.$5'/!, * %/.()%'('%* "4! /!"* ! !(! !. % /.()% * +*"'! *+$'!, %++'#"'&'/% %)*"%+ $*)$!>%'('%* !. /*"+.$%'('%* * /!".% O %#*"*+ +*$= $*+)!"+%'('9%! )!$ *(* +* &!$ /.()%!, !. +*@%, +* 6!.>*$/.()%'('%* P!* *:'+'$ )!$%"!, /$'* +* 1.* %@% /.()%'('%*, !.+*@%, /*"+.$%'('%* !. $*)$!>%'('%* % /!".%, "4! *:'+'"! %/!"'34! '"'+)*"+=>*( % ')!+'34! * )*"%
E +5"*+*, )%$% ! /'%! M'$%**, ! /$'* + * !'+ *(**"!+7
')'/'%* * %"'@.$''/'%*, *+%"! < /.()%'('%* /(%++'&'/%% /!! )$*++.)!+!
)%$% % %)('/%34! % )*"%, "4! +*"! %++', . !+ *(**"!+ /!"+'.'>! ! /$'*
E:'+*, %'"%, !.$!+ )!+'/'!"%*"!+ !.$'"=$'!+ % $*+)*'! %
/!)!+'34! ! /$'* * +*. /!"/*'! %"%(5'/!, "! *"%"!, )!$ "4! +*$ * /."6!
&."%*"%(, )%$% %'"#'$ ! !@*! % )*+1.'+%, ! %++."! "4! +*$= *:)(!$%!, *
&!$% %'+ *+)*/'&'/%
P!$, +*$= "*/*++=$'! )%$% *+/(%$*/*$ * '$''$ &..$%+ 8>'%+, %!$%$
* *:)('/%$ ! /!"/*'! %"%(5'/!, *">!(>*"! !+ *(**"!+ % ')'/'%*, %
%"'@.$''/'%* * % /.()%'('%*, *+.%"! +.% /!)!+'34! )$)$'% * ! $*&(*:! *
/%% . !+ *(**"!+, "! ."! @.$5'/!
DO FATO TXPICO E SEUS ELEMENTOS
A ')'/'%* . !+ /!)!"*"*+ /!"+'.'>! ! /$'* 1.* /!$$*(%/'!"%
. &%! % .% %34! )$*>'+% "! !$*"%*"! )*"%( .%"! %! *% D%=+'! *
J*+.+ '9 1.*, T')'/'%*, ". /!"/*'! )$*(''"%$, % /!$$*+)!";"/'% *"$* ! &%!
)$%'/%! )*(! %#*"* * % *+/$'34! * /%% *+)/'* * '"&$%34! /!"'% "% (*' )*"%(
'"/$''"%!$%G2Y
24 MIRABETE, J.('! F%$'"' FABBRINI, R*"%! N Ma7ual de d4re4to 6e7al: 6arte =eral 2] * S4!P.(!7 A(%+, 200 ) Q25 JESUS, D%=+'! E * !4re4to 6e7al: 6arte =eral * S4! P%.(!7 S%$%'>%, 200 ) 00
27
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 30/59
O. +*@%, % ')'/'%* +*$>* /!! . *"1.%$%*"! * . &%! /!"/$*!
* .% 6')*+* %+$%%
P%$% % %'!$'% % !.$'"%, % ')'/'%* /!)!+% )!$ 1.%$! *(**"!+7
/!".%, $*+.(%!, ')! )*"%( * "*:! * /%.+%('%*, !+ 1.%'+ +*$4! %"%('+%!+ *
&!$% +'"*'/% (!#! * +*#.'%
C!".% +'"`"'! * %34! * * /!)!$%*"! C!".% 1.*$ '9*$,
%'"%, %34! !. /!)!$%*"! 6.%"!G2] O. +*@%, ! 1.* '"*$*++% )%$% ! '$*'!
)*"%( % /!".% 6.%"%, .% >*9 1.* %1.*(% ('>$* * /!"+/'*"* >!(%% )%$% .
**$'"%! &'
.%"! %! $*+.(%!, *++* )!*$= +*$ "%.$%(5+'/!, ! 1.%( )!* +*$
*"*"'! /!! +*"! ! *&*'! "%.$%( % %34! 1.* /!"&'#.$% % /!".% 5)'/%, !.+*@%, ! &%! ')'/%*"* $*(*>%"* )$!.9'! "! ."! *:*$'!$ )*(! !>'*"!
/!$)$*! ! %#*"* * % *(* ('#%! )!$ $*(%34! * /%.+%('%*G2
E !.$%+ )%(%>$%+ ! $*+.(%! "%.$%(5+'/!, %1.*(* 1.* .% %
$*%('%* /'$/."%"*, *':%"! >*+5#'!
O., %'"%, ! $*+.(%! )!*$= +*$ /(%++'&'/%! /!! @.$5'/!, *"*"*"!
*+* /!! +*"! %(#! 1.* !/!$$* +* .%$ % $*%('%* /'$/."%"*, "4! *':%"!
>*+5#'!, +*#."! %+ ('3*+ * ?.'(6*$* N.//' ! $*+.(%! @.$5'/!
% !'&'/%34! #*$%% "! ."! @.$5'/!, +*@% "% &!$% * %"! *&*'>! !."% * %"! )!*"/'%(, &*$'"! '"*$*++* )$!*#'! )*(% "!$% )*"%( S! *++*)!"! * >'+%, !% /!".% 1.* &*$* . '"*$*++* @.$''/%*"* )$!*#'!/%.+% . $*+.(%!2Q
A $*+)*'! ! N*:! * C%.+%('%*, )!*-+* '9*$ 1.* ! *(! *"$* %
%34! * +.% $*+)*/'>% /!"+*1^;"/'% C!"'".%"! % /!$$!!$%$ /! ! )*"+%*"!
! %.!$ %/'%, )!*-+* '9*$ 1.* ! "*:! * /%.+%('%* 1.* +*#."! ! >'"/.(!
*+%*(*/'! *"$* % /!".% ! %#*"* * ! $*+.(%! )!$ *(* #*$%!, /! $*(*>"/'%+.&'/'*"* )%$% &!$%$ ! &%! 5)'/!G2
E:'+* .%+ *!$'%+ 1.* $%% % $*+)*'! ! "*:! /%.+%( 1.* +4! %
*!$'% % /%.+%('%* %*1.%%, 1.* * %/!$! /! *+% *!$'%, . *>*"!
26 ?RECO, R!#$'! Curso de d4re4to 6e7al: 6arte =eral 2 * R'! * J%"*'$!7 I)*.+, 200 )[27 MIRABETE, J.('! F%$'"' FABBRINI, R*"%! N Ma7ual de d4re4to 6e7al: 6arte =eral 2] * S4!P.(!7 A(%+, 200 ) ]28 NUCCI ?.'(6*$* * S!.9% Ma7ual de d4re4to 6e7al > 6arte =eral * S4! P%.(!7 $*>'+%+ !+$'."%'+, 200 ) ]29 NUCCI ?.'(6*$* * S!.9% Ma7ual de d4re4to 6e7al > 6arte =eral * S4! P%.(!7 $*>'+%+ !+$'."%'+, 200)
28
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 31/59
/!"+'*$%! /%.+% 1.%"!, )*(%+ $*#$%+ * *:)*$';"/'%, *(* &!$ %)!, '`"*! %
)$!>!/%$ ! $*+.(%! N4! %!%% )*(! !$*"%*"! )*"%( $%+'(*'$! E % *!$'%
% *1.'>%(;"/'% !+ %"*/**"*+ /%.+%'+, * %/!$! /! *+% *!$'% %+ /%.+%+ "4!
*:/(.* .%+ %+ !.$%+, %+ /%.+%+ *1.'>%(* E+% *!$'% %+*%% "! @.59!
6')!'/! * *(''"%34! c % !%% "! !$*"%*"! )*"%( $%+'(*'$!
J= * $*(%34! < T')'/'%*, *+* . /!"/*'! 1.* /%.+% '&'/.(%*+
U% >*9, 1.* ! *+! )!* +*$ /!"&."'! /! ! /!"/*'! * &%! 5)'/!, "!
*"%"!, "4! >%' %/!"*/*$ "!+ *+/$'!+ )$*+*"*+, )!'+, %!%$-+*-= %+ ('3*+ *
?.'(6*$* N.//* 1.* $*+.* ! ')%++* +!$* ! %++."! % +*#.'"* &!$%7
E +.%7 ')'/'%* '"+$.*"! * %*1.%34!, *"1.%"! ! &%! 5)'/! %/!"/(.+4! *++* )$!/*++! E:*)('&'/%"!7 T5/'! *(''"% % >'% * C%'!,*+&*$'"!-(6* '$!+ * %$% * &!#! &%! % >'% $*%(K C!"+%%-+* 6%>*$ !!*(! (*#%( )$*>'+! "! %$ 2 ! C'#! P*"%( %%$ %(#.GKS.+.*-+* ! &%! %! ')! * *"/!"$%!+ % ')'/'%* L!#'/%*"*, )%$%1.* ! &%!+ % >'% $*%( )!++% +*$ )*"%(*"* >%(!$%!+, '"'+)*"+=>*(1.* ! $'"`'! *+*@% )$*+*"* /!".% n "*:! n $*+.(%!K0
E !.$%+ )%(%>$%+ % ')'/'%* "%% %+ 1.* % %*1.%34! ! &%! $*%(,
! &%! /!"/$*!, %! ')! )*"%( '"/$''"%!$ )$*>'+! "%+ "!$%+ )*"%'+ %+$%%+
2 DA CULPABILIDADE E SUA COMPOSIÇÃO
A /.()%'('%* * '>*$+!+ +'#"'&'/%!+, )!*"! $*/%'$ +!$* % )*++!%,
+!$* % '('/'.* * @.59! * >%(!$ 1.* /!"/*'% % . &%!, )!* +*$>'$ )%$% %
*'34! % )*"% /!"&!$* ! %$ Y ! C'#! P*"%( B$%+'(*'$!, * % )!*
+*$ *"*"'% /!! . @.59! * >%(!$, * /*"+.$% 1.* $*/%5 +!$* ! +.@*'!
)$%'/%"* * . &%!
N!+ '9*$*+ * R!#$'! ?$*/! C.()%'('%* ! @.59! * $*)$!>%34!)*++!%( 1.* +* $*%('9% +!$* % /!".% )$%'/%% )*(! %#*"*G2
A /.()%'('%*, ')!$%"* *(**"! /!"+'.'>! ! /$'*, */'&$%%, "!
)$*+*"*, "! *$3! @.$5'/! )=$'! )*(% *!$'% "!$%'>% ).$%, !. +*@%, %
30 NUCCI ?.'(6*$* * S!.9% Ma7ual de d4re4to 6e7al > 6arte =eral e 6arte es6e54al * S4!P%.(!7 $*>'+%+ !+ $'."%'+, 200 ) Q31 A$ Y - O @.'9, %*"*"! < cul'abilidade, %!+ %"*/**"*+, < /!".% +!/'%(, < )*$+!"%('%* !%#*"*, %!+ !'>!+, <+ /'$/."+"/'%+ * /!"+*1^;"/'%+ ! /$'*, * /!! %! /!)!$%*"! %>5'%, *+%*(*/*$=, /!"&!$* +*@% "*/*++=$'! * +.&'/'*"* )%$% $*)$!>%34! * )$*>*"34! ! /$'*732 ?RECO, R!#$'! Curso de d4re4to 6e7al: 6arte =eral 2 * R'! * J%"*'$!7 I)*.+, 200 )]33 .* %!$% * &!$% #$%"'!+% *++% *!$'% * M'$%** 200, Q2K, %! $%%$ % /.()%'('%* *+.%+ *!$'%+, % +*#.'"* &!$%7 N*++*+ *$!+, "4! +* )!* %/*'%$ % *!$'% )+'/!(#'/!-"!$%'>%,
29
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 32/59
/.()%'('%* "4! * %'+ *(**"!+ )+'/!(#'/!+, .% >*9 1.* *+*+ +*
*"/!"$% "% ')'/'%*
S*"! %++', /!"+'*$%$-+*-= 1.* % /.()%'('%* +*@% /!)!+% )!$ $;+
*(**"!+7 % ').%'('%*, % *:'#;"/'% * /!)!$%*"! /!"&!$* ! '$*'! *
)!*"/'%( /!"+/';"/'% % '('/'.*, !+ 1.%'+ +*$4! *+.%!+ %'%"*
P$'*'$%*"*, * $*(%34! < ').%'('%* !. /%)%/'%* *
/.()%'('%* % /%)%/'%* 1.* ! %#*"* * * %.! *"*"'*"!, *
%.!**$'"%34!, % /%)%/'%* 1.* )*$'* 1.* ! %#*"* +*@% ').=>*(
S*#."! D%=+'! * J*+.+, I).%$ %$'.'$ % %(#. % $*+)!"+%'('%* *
%(#.% /!'+% I).%'('%* )*"%( ! /!"@."! * /!"'3*+ )*++!%'+ 1.* 4! %!
%#*"* /%)%/'%* )%$% (6* +*$ @.$''/%*"* ').%% % )$='/% * . &%!)."5>*(G[
A ').%'('%* $*#'% )*(! /$'$'! '!)+'/!(#'/!, !. +*@%, * 1.* +*$
%.&*$'! % '%*, ! *+*">!(>'*"! *"%( ! +.@*'!, +* *(* /%)%9 * *"*"*$
+*.+ %!+ * %+ $*+)*/'>%+ /!"+*1^;"/'%+, * $*+.!
A ').%'('%* /!"+'.5% )!$ !'+ *(**"!+7 . '"*(*/.%( /%)%/'%** *"*"*$ ! /%$=*$ '(5/'! ! &%!K, ! !.$! >!(''>! /%)%/'%* ***$'"%$-+* * %/!$! /! *++* *"*"'*"!K O )$'*'$! %/%)%/'%* #*"$'/%K * /!)$**"*$ %+ )$!''3*+ !. **$'"%3*+ @.'/'%'+ Bettiol '9 1.* ! %#*"* *>* )!*$m)$*>*$ %+ $*)*$/.++*+ 1.* %)$)$'% %34! )!*$= %/%$$*%$ "! ."! +!/'%(m, *>* *$, )!'+ l% )*$/*)34!! +'#"'&'/%! '/!-+!/'%( ! )$)$'! %#'$m O +*#."!, % l/%)%/'%* *'$'#'$ % /!".% * %/!$! /! ! *"*"'*"! '/!-@.$5'/! C!"&!$*Berttioli , )$*/'+! 1.* ! %#*"* *"6% /!"'3*+ * %>%('%$ ! >%(!$ ! !'>!1.* ! ')*(* < %34! *, ! !.$! (%!, ! >%(!$ % %*%3% )*"%(Y
c @.+%*"* *++% % /!"/(.+4! 1.* +* /6*#% %! %"%('+%$ %! %$ 2] !
/'#! )*"%(, 1.* $*9% %++'7
A$ 2] – c '+*"! * )*"% ! %#*"* 1.*, )!$ !*"3% *"%( !.
*+*">!(>'*"! *"%( '"/!)(*! !. $*%$%!, *$%, %! *)! % %34! !.% !'++4!, '"*'$%*"* '"/%)%9 * *"*"*$ ! /%$=*$ '(5/'! ! &%! !. ***$'"%$-+* * %/!$! /! *++* *"*"'*"!R*.34! * )*"%P%$=#$%&! 8"'/! - A )*"% )!* +*$ $*.9'% * . % !'+ *$3!+, +* ! %#*"*,* >'$.* * )*$.$%34! * +%8* *"%( !. )!$ *+*">!(>'*"! *"%(
)!'+ ! !(! "4! )!* +*$ *(**"! ! &%! * *(**"! % /.()%'('%* 'elo fato C6*#!.-+*, %++', <*!$'% % cul'abilidade, !. *!$'% normati)a 'ura7 ! !(! )*$*"/* < /!".% !+ *(**"!+"!$%'>!+ &!$% !!+ % /.()%'('%*, !. +*@%, % $*)$!>%'('%* % /!".% A++', /!! '9F$%"/'+/! * A++'+ T!(*!, % /.()%'('%* #%"6% . *(**"! – l% /!"+/';"/'% % '('/'.*m/!"+/';"/'% ! '"@.+!K – %+ )*$* !+ %"*$'!$*+ *(**"!+ l%"5'/!+-+.@*'>!+m - ! !(! * % /.()%
stricto sensu - $*.9'"!-+*, *++*"/'%(*"*, % . @.59! * /*"+.$%G34 JESUS, D%=+'! E * !4re4to 6e7al: 6arte =eral * > S4! P%.(!7 S%$%'>%, 200 ) Y35 SANZO BRODT,L.'+ A.#.+!, %). ?RECO, R!#$'! C.$+! * '$*'! )*"%(7 )%$* #*$%( 2 *R'! * J%"*'$!7 I)*.+, 200 )
30
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 33/59
'"/!)(*! !. $*%$%! "4! *$% '"*'$%*"* /%)%9 * *"*"*$ ! /%$=*$'(5/'! ! &%! !. * **$'"%$-+* * %/!$! /! *++* *"*"'*"!
P!'+ *+* (*>% * /!"+'*$%34! ! /$'$'! '!)+'/!(!#'/! )%$% /!"&*$'$ %
').%'('%* %! %#*"*.%"! %!+ '"').=>*'+ ! /'#! )*"%( 1.'+ 1.* &!++* $%%!+ * (*'+
*+)*/'%'+, *++% % **$'"%34! ! %$ 2 ! C'#! P*"%(, 1.* $%9 1.* O+
*"!$*+ * Q *9!'!K %"!+ +4! )*"%(*"* '"').=>*'+, &'/%"! +.@*'!+ <+
"!$%+ *+%*(*/'%+ "% (*#'+(%34! *+)*/'%(G
T%, )$*>'+!, * (*', 1.* %!+ +*'"').=>*'+ +*$= %)('/%% % )*"%
/! $*.34! !. /! *'% * +*#.$%"3%
N! 1.* %"#* %! )!*"/'%( /!"+/';"/'% +!$* % '('/'.* ! &%!, /*'3! 1.* ! %++."! /!)(*:!, .% >*9 1.* $%%(6%$ ! *$$! * )$!''34! * ! *$$! *
')! $*1.*$ .% *&*$;"/'% +'#"'&'/%'>% * *:*"+'>%, )!$ )*(! &%! * +*$ .
)!"!, /!! '! %/'%, *$%*"* '"&!$%'>! - !"* >'+%! %)*"%+ '$''$
&..$%+ 8>'%+ 1.* )!++% +.$#'$ "% (*'.$% ! *+/$'! -, + +*$= $*'! ! *)!
"*/*++=$'!, )%$% %"!
S*"! %++', !%$-+*-= %+ ('3*+ * R!#$'! ?$*/!, %! '&*$*"/'%$ ! *$$!
* ')! * ! *$$! * )$!''34!, (*/'!"%"! 1.*
O *$$! * ')!, )!$%"!, '"/''$= +!$* !+ *(**"!+, /'$/."+%"/'%'+ !.1.%(1.*$ !.$! %! 1.* +* %#$*#.* < &'#.$% 5)'/% E +.%, *$$! * ')! %"%('+%! "! ')! O *$$! * )$!''34!, %! /!"$=$'!, "4! *+.%! "! ')!)*"%(, %+ +', 1.%"! % %&*$'34! % /.()%'('%* ! %#*"* C! ! *$$!* )$!''34! )$!/.$%-+* >*$'&'/%$ +* "%+ /!"'3*+ * 1.* +* *"/!"$%>% !%#*"* '"6% *(* /!"'3*+ * /!)$**"*$ 1.* ! &%! 1.* )$%'/%>% *$%'(5/'!]
.%"! < '"*:'#''('%* * /!".% '>*$+%, *++% % )!++''('%* 1.*
'"6% ! %#*"* *, "! !*"! % %34! !. % !'++4!, %#'$ * %/!$! /! ! '$*'!,/!"+'*$%"!-+* % +.% )%$'/.(%$ /!"'34! * )*++!%+ 6.%"%G O. +*@%, %
'"*:'#''('%* * /!".% '>*$+%, % $*+$'34! * *+/!(6% 1.* ! '$*'! = %!
+.@*'! )%$% 1.* *++* )!++% %#'$ /!"&!$* +*.+ '%*+, * %++' &%3% ! 1.*
/!"+'*$%! /*$!
E++% '"*:'#''('%* * /!".% '>*$+% )!* *+%$ )$*>'+% "% (*', /!!
! /%+! ! %$ 22 ! C'#! P*"%(, 1.* $%9 % +*#.'"* "%$$%'>%7 S* ! &%!
36 ?RECO, R!#$'! Curso de d4re4to 6e7al: 6arte =eral 2 * R'! * J%"*'$!7 I)*.+, 200 )Q37 ?RECO, R!#$'! Curso de d4re4to 6e7al: 6arte =eral 2 * R'! * J%"*'$!7 I)*.+, 200 )Y
31
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 34/59
/!*'! +! /!%34! '$$*+'+5>*( !. * *+$'% !*';"/'% % !$*, "4!
%"'&*+%*"* '(*#%(, * +.)*$'!$ 6'*$=$1.'/!, + )."5>*( ! %.!$ % /!%34! !. %
!$*G O., )!*$= +*$, +.)$% (*#%( /!! ! /%+! ! *+%! * "*/*++'%*
*:/.()%"*, !"* ! * )$!*#'! *"!$ 1.* ! * +%/$'&'/%! )$!>!/%34! *
(*#''% *&*+% *"$* !.$%+
DA ANTIJURICIDADE E SUAS CAUSAS DE EWCLUSÃO
A! /!"$=$'! !+ !.$!+ !'+ *(**"!+ ! ')! )*"%(, "% %"'@.$''/'%*,
"4! +*$= $*%('9%! . *+.! * +.% /!)!+'34! P!$, +*$= $*%('9%! . *+.!
"%+ %3*+ 1.* /!"+*#.* *:/(.5$* % %"'@.$''/'%*P%$% %"! +*$= %!%! ! /!"/*'! * %"'@.$''/'%* )*$&'(6%! )!$
M'$%**, ! 1.%( (*/'!"% 1.* % %"'@.$''/'%* % /!"$%'34! *"$* .% /!".% *
! !$*"%*"! @.$5'/!GQ
E +.% % %"'@.$''/'%* "%% %+ 1.* .% %34! /!"$=$'% %! 1.*
*+%*(*/' %+ (*'+ )*"%'+ N! *"%"!, )!*$4! +*$ *"/!"$%%+, "! !$*"%*"!
)=$'! $%+'(*'$!, %3*+ 1.* *+/%$%/*$'9* % %"'@.$''/'%*, %+ 1.%'+ *+4!
)$*>'+%+ "% )%$* #*$%( ! C'#! P*"%(, %+ *+)*/'&'/%*"* "! %$ 2
, **+*">!(>'%+ "!+ %$'#!+ +*#.'"*+, 1.* )%++%$= % +*$ %(>! * *+.!
O E+%! * "*/*++'%* !/!$$* 1.%"! ! %#*"* +* *)%$% * .%
+'.%34! * *+/!(6%, !"* *$= 1.* !)%$ )*(! +%/$'&5/'! * . * * *"!$ >%(!$,
@.$''/%*"* )$!*#'!, * )$!( * . !.$! * * >%(!$ +!/'%(*"* %'!$, *+*
1.* "4! *"6% !.$% &!$% * %'"#'$ ! $*+.(%! O 1.* @.+'&'/% % %34! %
"*/*++'%* 1.* ')* ! +%/$'&5/'! * . * * +'.%34! * /!"&('! !. /!('+4!,
'%"* % 1.%( ! !$*"%*"! @.$5'/! )*$'* ! +%/$'&5/'! ! * * *"!$ >%(!$G[0
S*"! %++', 1.%"! ! %#*"* )$%'/%$ % /!".% /$''"!+%, *+/$'% "!
')! )*"%(, * +%/$'&'/%$ . * * )$!( ! !.$!, % /!".% "4! +*$= *"1.%$%%
/!! +*"! . /$'* )*"%(, )!'+ (6* &%(%$% ! *(**"! % %"'@.$''/'%*
38 MIRABETE, J.('! F%$'"' FABBRINI, R*"%! N Ma7ual de d4re4to 6e7al 2] * S4! P.(!7 A(%+,200 ) Y3) A$ 2 - N4! 6= /$'* 1.%"! ! %#*"* )$%'/% ! &%!7
I - * *+%! * "*/*++'%*
II - * (*#5'% *&*+% III - * *+$'! /.)$'*"! * *>*$ (*#%( !. "! *:*$/5/'! $*#.(%$ * '$*'!40 FRA?OSO, H*(*"!, %). BITENCOURT, C*9%$ R!*$! Tratado de d4re4to 6e7al: 6arte =eralY * S4! P%.(!7 S%$%'>%, 200 ) ]
32
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 35/59
P%$% $*+%$ /!"&'#.$%! ! *+%! * "*/*++'%* "*/*++=$'! %(#."+
$*1.'+'!+ *(*"/%!+ )*(%+ !.$'"%+, 1.* "4! +4! )*$'"*"*+ )%$% ! &' %
)*+1.'+%+, "! *"%"! +*$4! /'%!+ * &!$% #*"$'/%, 1.%'+ +*@%7
%K % %*%3% % '$*'! )$)$'!+ !. %(6*'!+ K % *:'+;"/'% * . )*$'#! %.%(* '"*>'=>*( /K % '"*:'#''('%* ! +%/$'&5/'! ! * %*%3%! K .%+'.%34! "4! )$!>!/%% >!(."%$'%*"* )*(! %#*"* *K % '"*:'+;"/'% **>*$ (*#%( * *"&$*"%$ ! )*$'#! &K * ! /!"6*/'*"! % +'.%34! ! &%! @.+'&'/%"*G[
N! 1.* '9 $*+)*'! % (*#''% *&*+%, /!! ! %$'#! 2Y ! C'#! P*"%(
*+/$*>*, *"*"*-+* )!$ (*#''% *&*+% 1.*, .+%"! !*$%%*"* !+ *'!+
"*/*++=$'!+, $*)*(* '"@.+% %#$*++4!, %.%( !. ''"*"*, % '$*'! +*. !. * !.$*G
D% *+% &!$% 1.* !/!$$*. "! )'/! %/'%, 1.* $%!. ! *+%! *
"*/*++'%*, !/!$$*$% "! )'/! )$*+*"*, !. +*@%, + +*$ $%%% % (*#''% *&*+%
* &!$% $*+.'% A++', +4! $*1.'+'!+ )%$% /!"&'#.$%$ % (*#''% *&*+%, "%+
('3*+ * M'$%**7 %K % $*%34! % .% %#$*++4! %.%( !. ''"*"* * '"@.+% K %
*&*+% * . '$*'! )$)$'! !. %(6*'! /K % !*$%34! "! *)$*#! !+ *'!+
"*/*++=$'!+ < $*).(+% K * ! *(**"! +.@*'>!G[2
E $*(%34! %! *+$'! /.)$'*"! * *>*$ (*#%( * ! *:*$/5/'! $*#.(%$
* '$*'!, * $*(%34! %! )$'*'$!, *"*"'! 1.* "4! )!* 6%>*$ ! /$'* 1.%"!
! +.@*'! %#* )$%'/%"! % %34! *('.!+% "! *+$'! /.)$'*"! * . *>*$ (*#%(,
*+% % )$*>'+4! 1.* $=+ % )$'*'$% )%$* ! '"/'+! III, ! %$ 2 ! C'#! P*"%(
J= % +*#."% )%$*, ! $*&*$'! '"/'+!, /!"/(.'-+* 1.* "4! 6%>*$= /$'*, 1.%"! !
%#*"* )$%'/%$ +.% %34! )$!*#'! )*(! *:*$/5/'! $*#.(%$ * . '$*'!
A)+ +*$ $*%('9%!+ !+ /!*"=$'!+ "*/*++=$'!+ )%$% 1.* +* )!++%
'$''$ 1.%'+1.*$ 8>'%+ +.+*1^*"*+, )%++%$-+*-= %! *+.! % /%.+% %
*:/(.*"* * %"'@.$''/'%* '"&$%(*#%(, !. +*@%, ! C!"+*"'*"! E+.%"! +*.+
$*1.'+'!+ * +.%+ 6')*+*+, )%$% 1.* +* )!+% *!"+$%$ 1.*, ! *+! +*$>* /!!
&%!$ *+/%$*$'9%"* ! *('! $=&'/! * )*++!%+ "% !%('%* )$!+'.'34!
N! *"%"!, "*/*++=$'! $*&!$3%$, %'+ .% >*9, 1.* ! /%)'.(! %/'%, &!'
$*'#'! /! ! &' * +%"%$ 1.%'+1.*$ 8>'%+ 1.* ).*++* >' % +.$#'$ /!
*:)$*++*+, +'#"'&'/%!+, !. /!)!+'3*+ * /!"/*'!+ +.@*'>!+, "! !*"! %
41 BITENCOURT, C*9%$ R!*$! Tratado de d4re4to 6e7al: 6arte =eral Y * S4! P%.(!7 S%$%'>%,200 ) ]42 MIRABETE, J.('! F%$'"' FABBRINI, R*"%! N Ma7ual de d4re4to 6e7al 2] * S4! P.(!7 A(%+,200 ) ]Q
33
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 36/59
(*'.$%, !. "% /!"&*/34! *+% !$%, "4! +*"!, %++', *+/!)! % *+% * "4!
*$*/*"! % *&*$;"/'% 1.* !+ *%'+ /%)5.(!+ *$*/*
34
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 37/59
/ !O COSETIMETO 'Á(I!O !O COSECIETE COMO %ATOR!ESCARACTERI&ATE !A ATI,URI!ICI!A!E
A)+ *$ +'! $*%('9%! . *+.! +'"'/! +!$* % *!$'% ! /$'* * +*.+
*(**"!+ *+/%$%/*$'9%"*+, /6*#%-+* % >*9 * *+.%$, .% %+ &!$%+ *
*:/(.*"* % %"'@.$''/'%* 1.* ! /!"+*"'*"! >=('!, 1.* *!$%, "4! +*@%
*"/!"$%! $*+)%(! "%+ (*'+ )*"%'+ * &!$% *:)$*++%, %/*'! 1.%+* 1.*
.""'*, )*(% !.$'"% * @.$'+)$.;"/'%
.*, * ! !'>!, )*(! 1.%( *>* +*$ /!"+'*$%%+ %+ /%.+%+ *
*:/(.*"*+ % %"'@.$''/'%* +.)$%(*#%( Z%&&%$!"', 1.%"! %). )!$ C*9%$
B'*"/!.$, (*/'!"%"! 1.*
C!! ! (*#'+(%!$ "4! )!* )$*>*$ !%+ %+ 6')*+*+ * 1.* %+$%"+&!$%3*+ )$!.9'%+ )*(% *>!(.34! '/!-+!/'%( * . )!>! )%++% %%.!$'9%$ !. )*$''$ % $*%('9%34! * *$'"%%+ /!".%+, '"'/'%(*"*)$!''%+, *>*-+*, * )$'"/5)'!, %''$ % *:'+;"/'% * /%.+%+ +.)$%(*#%'+* *:/(.+4! % %"'@.$''/'%*, * 1.* )*+* %(#.% $*+'+;"/'% !&*$*/'%)!$ )%$* % !.$'"% * % @.$'+)$.;"/'%[
E %++', *+.%$-+*-= % )!++''('%* * +*$ *:/(.5! ! $=&'/! * )*++!%+
"% !%('%* )$!+'.'34! 1.%"! &!$ $*%('9%! ! /!"+*"'*"! >=('! % )%$*,
1.*, * %(#."+ /%+!+ *+)*/5&'/!+, $%%! /!! +*"! .% )*++!% '"/%)%9 **:*$/*$ +*. '$*'! < ('*$%* * &!$% ('>$* * /!"+/'*"*
[ DO CONSENTIMENTO NO TRÁFICO DE PESSOAS PARA FINS DE
PROSTITUIÇÃO
O $=&'/! '"*$"%/'!"%( * )*++!%+ .% %+ %'>'%*+ '(5/'%+ %'+
$*"=>*'+ !+ 8('!+ *)!+, % )$!>% '++! 1.* &'/% %$=+ %)*"%+ ! $=&'/! *
%$%+ * ! $=&'/! * $!#%+
T% *+% !/!$$*"!, * &!$% "!=>*(, . /$*+/'*"! "! $=&'/! *
)*++!%+ "% *+&*$% '"*$"% ! *$$'$'! $%+'(*'$!
P$*/*'! %)*"%+ )*(! /!$/'! '(*#%( * $!#%+ * %$%+, ! $=&'/! * +*$*+6.%"!+ )%$% &'"+ +*:.%'+ % *$/*'$% %'>'%* %'+ $*"=>*( ! /$'*!$#%"'9%! E+'%-+* 1.* *+% )$='/% !>'*"* /*$/% * % 2 '(6*+* (%$*+ %".%(*"* * !! ! ."! N! B$%+'(, "4! 6= .% *+'%'>%$*%( % 1.%"'%* * $*/.$+!+ !>'*"%!+ )!$ *+% %'>'%*, "!*"%"!, % '"/';"/'% * /%+!+ %(%$%"*[[
43 ZAFFARONI, %). BITENCOURT, C*9%$ R!*$! Tratado de d4re4to 6e7al: 6arte =eral Y *S4! P%.(!7 S%$%'>%, 200 ) ]0
35
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 38/59
S*"! 1.* "% #$%"* %'!$'% %+ >*9*+ ! $=&'/! * )*++!%+, +*@% '"*$"!
!. '"*$"%/'!"%(, >* +*"! $*%('9%! /!"&' * *:)(!$%34! +*:.%(, *"! /!!
>5'%+ )$'"/')%(*"* %+ .(6*$*+
P!'+ ! !@*! @.$5'/!, *+* *('! % )*++!% 1.* +* )$!+'.' !. 1.* >%'
+*$ &!$3%% % +* )$!+'.'$, 1.* )!* +*$ .+%% '"/!"=>*'+ >*9*+, *"! +.%
'#"'%* 6.%"% >'!(%% /%% >*9 1.* +.*'% % %( %!
U $%&'/%"* /%"%*"+* %&'$!. 1.* $%&'/%$ .(6*$*+ *$% .'! %'+'"*$*++%"* /!*$/'%(*"* ! 1.* % >*"% * %$%+ * $!#%+, )!'+ *++%+.%+ %'>'%*+ ; . /!*3! * . &', *"1.%"! ! /!$)! % .(6*$ )!*+*$ >*"'! '"8*$%+ >*9*+ % 1.* *(% )%*3% * A'+, +5&'('+ !.*"(!.1.*3%[Y
P%$% %*"*$ %!+ &'"+ % )*+1.'+% +*$= "*/*++=$'! *"*"*$ ! /!"/*'! *)$!+'.'34! )*$&'(6%! )!$ N.//', /!! +*"! ! /%'"6! 6%'.%( * %'>'%*
+*:.%( N4! +* )!* /!"+'*$%$ .% )*++!% )$!+'.% )!$1.* .% 8"'/% >*9 !*>*
>%"%#* */!"`'/% * $!/% * . $*(%/'!"%*"! +*:.%( KG[]
J= )%$% E>% F%(*'$!+, 1.%"! %). )!$ R!#$'! ?$*/!, *"*"* 1.*
% )$!+'.'34! *&'"'% /!! % %'>'%* "% 1.%( %!+ +*:.%'+ +4!"*#!/'%!+ * $!/% * )%#%*"!, "4! %)*"%+ !"*=$'!, %+ )!*"!'"/(.'$ % +%'+&%34! * "*/*++'%*+ =+'/%+ %('*"%34!, >*+.=$'!, %$'#!K
!. ! %/*++! %! /!"+.! * *"+ * * +*$>'3!+ $*+%.$%"*+, %$*+, 6!'+,+6!))'"#+, .'1.*+, '>*$+4!K[
A++', )%$% 1.* .% )*++!% +*@% /!"+'*$%% )$!+'.5% *$= 1.* +*$
$*%('9%! ! %! %'+ * .% >*9 A++' ! &%! % )*++!% +*$ !$'#%%+ % )$%'/%$ !
+*:! '"8*$%+ >*9*+ "4! &%9 +.$#'$, .% $*'*$%34! /$''"!+%, .% >*9 1.* !/!$$* !
*:%.$'*"! ! *('! $=&'/! * )*++!%+ 1.%"! % )*++!% !$'#%% % *:*$/*$,
)*(% )$'*'$% >*9, *&*'>%*"* % )$!+'.'34!
A )$*>'+4! *+% /!".% /$''"!+% *"/!"$%-+*, /!! @= &!$% >'+!,
)$*+*"* "! !$*"%*"! )*"%( $%+'(*'$! "!+ %$'#! 2, 2-A * +*. )%$=#$%&!+
1.* $*9% % +*#.'"* &!$%, $*+)*/'>%*"*7
44 C!"+.(%! ?*$%( !+ E+%!+ U"'!+ – S4! P%.(! B$%+'( Se5retar4a da ,ust49a 5r4a o 6r4;e4roes5r4t?r4o de 6reve79o e 5o;<ate ao tr2345o de 6essoas do 6a@s D'+)!"5>*( *6)72*%':%%%*$'/%"%!$#$'"*:)6)d%/'!"o+%!)%.(!%*$'%)6)p'o2[]2p+.*".op'**".o]] A/*++! *7 0 *9 20045 SIUEIRA, F(=>'! A.#.+! M%$*' D! /!"+*"'*"! ! !&*"'! J!$"%( J.$', S4! P%.(!, 0 @%"200 D'+)!"5>*( * g 6)7@!$"%(@.$'/!$%*$'%+"!'/'%+/!"+*"'*"!-!&*"'!h A/*++!*7 0 *9 20046 NUCCI ?.'(6*$* * S!.9% C?d4=o 6e7al 5o;e7tado * S4! P%.(!7 $*>'+%+ !+ $'."%'+,200 ) 47 FALEIROS, E>%, %). ?RECO, R!#$'! Curso de d4re4to 6e7al: 6arte es6e54al > *N'*$'7 I)*.+, 200 ) Y[[
36
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 39/59
T$=&'/! '"*$"%/'!"%( * )*++!% )%$% &' * *:)(!$%34! +*:.%( A$ 2 P$!!>*$ !. &%/'('%$ % *"$%%, "! *$$'$'! "%/'!"%(, * %(#.1.* "*(* >*"6% % *:*$/*$ % )$!+'.'34! !. !.$% &!$% * *:)(!$%34! +*:.%(,!. % +%5% * %(#. 1.* >= *:*$/;-(% "! *+$%"#*'$!
T$=&'/! '"*$"! * )*++!% )%$% &' * *:)(!$%34! +*:.%( A$ 2-A P$!!>*$ !. &%/'('%$ ! *+(!/%*"! * %(#. *"$! !*$$'$'! "%/'!"%( )%$% ! *:*$/5/'! % )$!+'.'34! !. !.$% &!$% **:)(!$%34! +*:.%(7
D*+% &!$%, +*#."! !+ %$'#!+ *"/'!"%!+ '"/!$$* "% /!".%
*('.!+% * $=&'/! * )*++!%+ )%$% &'"+ * *:)(!$%34! +*:.%(, 1.* )$%'/%$ !
>*$! ! ')! *+/$'! "! /%). A++' /!! '"/!$$*$=, 1.* )$%'/%$ %+ *(**"%$*+
$%9'%+ "! )%$=#$%&! )$'*'$! 1.%'+ +*@%7 %#*"/'%$, %('/'%$, >*"*$ !. /!)$%$,
$%"+)!$=-(%, $%"+&*$'-(% !. %(!@=-(%
C!! +* )*$/**, * @= &!$% '!, %+ )!$ '='/% )$*/'+! $*'*$%$, !
/'#! )*"%( $%+'(*'$! "4! &%9 *"34!, * &!$% %(#.% %! /!"+*"'*"! >=('!,
/!! +*"! .% *:/(.*"* % %"'@.$''/'%* ! $=&'/! * )*++!%+ L''%"!,
%++' % ('*$%* ! '"'>'.! P!'+ *+/!"+'*$% % )!++''('%* * 1.* ! /'%4!,
* ('>$* * *+)!""*% >!"%*, 1.*'$% *:*$/*$ % )$!+'.'34! )$!!>'%, %#*"/'%%
!. % %"! * . *$/*'$! T% )$!5* 1.* ! '"'>'.! *"6% ! *:*$/5/'! %
)$!+'.'34! &%/'('%!, )!*"! *+= &%/'('%34! !/!$$*$ )!$ *'! * %(!@%*"! *
$%"+)!$* !. 1.%(1.*$ . !.$% /'$/."+"/'% 1.* &%/'('* !. )$!!>% % )$!+'.'34!
N! *"%"!, /!! %(6.$*+ (*>%"%!, *:'+* .% )$*>'+4! (*#%( 1.* (*>%
* /!"+'*$%34! ! /!"+*"'*"! /!! *:/(.*"* % %"'@.$''/'%*, 1.* *>* +*$
$*+)*'%% )*(! ! !$*"%*"! )*"%( $%+'(*'$!, * +* *"/!"$% "! P$!!/!(! *
P%(*$!, ! 1.%( &%9 *"34! %! /!"+*"'*"! * +*. %$'#! ! a %(5"*% G $%9*"!
% +*#.'"* "%$$%34!
K O /!"+*"'*"! %! )*(% >5'% * $=&'/! * )*++!%+ *"! * >'+%
1.%(1.*$ ')! * *:)(!$%34! *+/$'! "% %(5"*% %K ! )$*+*"* A$'#! +*$=/!"+'*$%! '$$*(*>%"* +* '>*$ +'! .'('9%! 1.%(1.*$ . !+ *'!+$*&*$'!+ "% %(5"*% %K #$'&!.-+*K
*"*"*"! ! /!"+*"'*"! +*#.'"! % ''% * F(=>'! S'1.*'$%, 1.* )%$% *(*
*++% @.+'&'/%"* +.)$%(*#%( )!* +*$ *"*"'% /!! +*"! % %1.'*+/;"/'%! '.(%$ * . * !"* '"/'% % .*(% )*"%(, % (*+4! )$!>!/%% )!$!.$* %! !@*! @.$5'/! ! ')! )*"%(, %&*%"! ! '"*$*++* /.@% )$*>'+4!"!$%'>% >*% %( &%! * $*+#.%$% % '"*#$'%* ! * * * +*. '.(%$ [Q
48 SIUEIRA, F(=>'! A.#.+! M%$*' !o 5o7se7t4;e7to do o3e7d4do J!$"%( J.$', S4! P%.(!, 0 @%" 200 D'+)!"5>*( * g 6)7@!$"%(@.$'/!$%*$'%+"!'/'%+/!"+*"'*"!-!&*"'!h A/*++! *7 0 *9 200
37
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 40/59
A++', *)%$%-+* 1.* ! /!"+*"'*"! *"/!"$% )$*>'+4! "! P$!!/!(! *
P%(*$!, /!! %/'% $*+% *!"+$%! * 1.* ! *+! *>* +*$ !+*$>%!
P!'+ ! $*&*$'! . $%%! '"*$"%/'!"%( 1.* >*$+% +!$* '$*'!
6.%"!+, * 1.* * >=$'!+ )%5+*+, /!! +'#"%=$'!+, * *"$* *++*+ )%5+*+,
*"/!"$%-+* ! B$%+'(
O P$!!/!(! * P%(*$! $*/** +%.+ * (*' !$'"=$'%, "! !$*"%*"!
$%+'(*'$!, &'/%"! * +.% &!$%('%*, * '#.%( )%%%$ /! ! /'#! )*"%(
$%+'(*'$!, % )*+%$ * *++* *$ /%$=*$ * (*' /!)(**"%$
S*"! %++', /!! $*+)*'%! ! /!"+*"'*"! "! P$!!/!(! *
P%(*$!, 1.%"! +* $%% * *"1.%$%*"! ! $=&'/! * )*++!%+ )%$% &'"+ *
)$!+'.'34!, !$"%-+* >'=>*( 1.* % %++' ! +*@% "! /'#! )*"%( $%+'(*'$!P!'+ "! P$!!/!(! * P%(*$!, + /!"+'*$%! $=&'/! * )*++!%+ 1.%"!
)$%'/%! % %34! ! ')! )*"%( '"/$''"%!$ * &!$% % %&$!"%$ ! /!"+*"'*"!
>=('! ! !&*"'!, )!$ '++!, >*$-+* "*/*++=$'! $*%('9%$ .% %!$%#* "*++%
!%('%* * $=&'/! * )*++!%+
[2 DA RELAÇÃO ENTRE O CONSENTIMENTO E A EWCLUSÃO DE TIPICIDADE
P!$ *"*"*$ 1.* ! /!"+*"'*"! >=('! )!* *:/(.'$ %"! % ')'/'%*
1.%"! % %"'@.$''/'%*, >*$-+* "*/*++=$'!, *$/* %(#."+ +'"#*(!+ /!*"=$'!+ %
$*+)*'! ! /!"+*"'*"! >=('! /!! &%!$ *+/%$%/*$'9%"* % ')'/'%*
L!#!, *)*"*"! %+ /'$/."+"/'%+ ! /$'* * ! ')!, ! /!"+*"'*"! !'.(%$ ! * @.$5'/! %++.* .% &*'34!, +*"! * &."%*"%( ')!$"/'%+.% %"=('+*, .% >*9 1.* * **$'"%%+ !/%+'*+ +* *+'>*$ *+* )$*+*"*"4! 6= ')'/'%* !. "4! 6= %"'@.$''/'%* *, +* "4! 6= ')'/'%* !. "4! 6=%"'@.$''/'%*, "4! 6= /$'*, @= 1.* % ')'/'%* * % %"'@.$''/'%* +4!
*(**"!+ *++*"/'%'+ ! *('![
O /!"+*"'*"! )!*$= %)%$*/*$ /!! &!$% * *:/(.+4! % ')'/'%*
* &!$% *:)$*++%, )!$ *'! % (*', !. * &!$% =/'% "*+%+ 6')*+*,
*>'*"**"*, % ')'/'%* ! &%! $*+% *:/(.5%GY0
N! *"%"!, )!*$= %)%$*/* %$%>+ * /!"+*"+! "*#%'>!, !. +*@%,
1.%"! ! +.@*'! )%++'>! * 1.* "*#%$ +*. /!"+*"'*"! )%$% 1.* ! *('! "4! +*
49 SANTOS, M%.$'/'! M%/*! !+ SÊ?A, V'>'%"* A%$%( O 5o7se7t4;e7to do o3e7d4do 7a teor4a
do del4to J.+ "%>'#%"' ) 2 !. 2000 D'+)!"5>*( * g 6)7@.+.!(/!$$*>'+%*:!QQ!-/!"+*"'*"!-!-!&*"'!-"%-*!$'%-!-*('!h A/*++! * 0 *9 20050 PIERAN?ELI, J!+ H*"$'1.* O 5o7se7t4;e7to do o3e7d4do: 7a teor4a do del4to * S4!P%.(! R*>'+% !+ T$'."%'+, 200 )
38
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 41/59
)!++% /!"/$*'9%$, %#!$% + )!*$= %)%$*/*$ * &!$% =/'%, %++' /%++! % >5'%
/!"+'"%, *+/%$%/*$'9%$-+*-= ! /$'*, )!'+ % /!".% +*$= %5)'/%
.%"! % &'#.$% 5)'/% /!" % &%(% * /!"+*"'*"! % >5'% /!!*(**"! % *&'"'34! (*#%( ! /$'*, ! /!"+*"+! &."/'!"% /!! /%.+% **:/(.+4! % ')'/'%* A++', "! *('! * >'!(%34! * !'/5('! CP, %$Y0K, ! '++*"+! ! +.@*'! )%++'>! &."/'!"% /!! *(**"%$ ! ')! D*!! 1.* % )$*+*"3% * +*. /!"+*"'*"! !$"% %5)'/! ! &%!Y
T%, )!*$= %)%$*/*$ ! /!"+*"'*"! /!! . !+ *(**"%$*+ !
')! )*"%( '"/$''"%!$, /!! %/!"*/'% "! *('! * $%)! /!"+*"+.%(, !$% $*>!#%!,
! *+! !/!$$* /! ! *('! * %!$! /! ! /!"+*"'*"! % #*+%"* %$ 2]
CPK O '++*"+!, *"4! )%++% % +* /!"+'.'$ * *(**"! *++*"/'%( ! ')!GY2 S*"!
"*/*++=$'! ! /!"+*"'*"! % >5'%, )%$% 1.* )!++% +*$ /%$%/*$'9%! ! ')! )*"%(
'"/$''"%!$
A/$*'%"! 1.*, %)*+%$ * *$ +'! )*$&'(6%! * &!$% $*+.'% - )!$
"4! +*$ ')$*+/'"5>*( %! &' % )*+1.'+%-, &'/!. /(%$% * /!)$!>%% % 6')*+* !
/!"+*"'*"! >=('! +*$>'$ /!! *:/(.*"* % ')'/'%*
E %++' >!(%$-+*-=, )%$% ! *+.! *++* '"+'.!, /!$$*(%/'!"%"!-! /!!
.% *:/(.*"* * %"'@.$''/'%* +.)$%(*#%(
[ DAS TEORIAS DO CONSENTIMENTO
P!$ "4! +*$ $%%! *&*'>%*"* ! /!"+*"'*"! /!! . )$'"/5)'! #*$%(
"!$*%!$ ! '$*'! $%+'(*'$!, &'/% '&5/'( *"/!"$%$ *!$'%+ % +*. $*+)*'! O 1.* "4!
!$"% ! /!"+*"'*"! .% %$'% *+'"*$*++%"* "! '$*'! )*"%( )=$'!,
)$'"/')%(*"* "! 1.* %"#* % *!$'% ! /!"+*"'*"! ! !&*"'!, * %++', %
)*+1.'+% )$**"* *+*"*$, %( '"*$*++* "! $=&'/! * )*++!%+, 1.%"! /!*'!/! &'"+ +*:.%'+
S*"! %++', +*$4! *+.%%+, * &!$% $*+.'%, %(#.%+ %+ *!$'%+
! /!"+*"'*"! %'+ '+/.'%+ )*(!+ )*"%('+%+, 1.%'+ +*@%7 % *!$'% *
F*.$%/6, % *!$'% * "*#/'! @.$5'/! * % *!$'% % %34! @.$5'/%
51 JESUS, D%=+'! *, %). SANTOS, M%.$'/'! M%/*! !+ SÊ?A, V'>'%"* A%$%( O5o7se7t4;e7to do o3e7d4do 7a teor4a do del4to J.+ "%>'#%"' ) !. 2000 D'+)!"5>*( * g
6)7@.+.!(/!$$*>'+%*:!QQ!-/!"+*"'*"!-!-!&*"'!-"%-*!$'%-!-*('!h A/*++! * 0*9 20052 TOLEDO, F$%"/'+/! * A++'+, %). PIERAN?ELI, J!+ H*"$'1.* O 5o7se7t4;e7to do o3e7d4do:7a teor4a do del4to * S4! P%.(! R*>'+% !+ T$'."%'+, 200 )) -Q
39
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 42/59
E '"'/'! )!*-+* /'%$ % *!$'% * F*.$%/6, *++% *!$'% * %"'#%, %+
#.%$% $*%( ')!$"/'% "!+ '%+ %.%'+ P%$% F*.$%/6
*"1.%"! .% )*++!% )!* $*"."/'%$ * +*.+ '$*'!+ %$%>+ * . %!*/(%$%$'! * +.% >!"%*, ! /!"+*"'*"! )%$% ! &%! % )%$* !)$*@.'/%! *(''"% ! /!"/*'! * *('! V!(*"' "!" &' '"@.$'% T4!-+!*"**>* +*$ +.*'! <+ '+)!+'3*+ )$!>=>*'+ /!"&!$* ! '$*'!K !!&*"'!, ! '$*'! /!"$% ! 1.%( % %34!, % 1.* +* $*&*$* ! /!"+*"'*"!,*+= '$'#'% S* ! '$*'! *+= +.$%5! < ('>$* %"'&*+%34! % >!"%* !%.!$'9%! !. +* *+* '"/%)%9 % +.% ('>$* '+)!+'34!, ! /!"+*"'*"! "4!* *&*'! @.$5'/! %(#.Y
C!"/(.'-+* ! *+/$'! %/'%, 1.* )%$% ! !.$'"%!$, ! /!"+*"'*"!
)!*$'% +*$>'$ /!! *+/%$%/*$'9%"* % %"'@.$''/'%*, )!'+ )%$% *(* ! 1.*
')!$%, )%$% /!"+'*$%$ ! /!"+*"'*"! >=('! % )!++''('%* * '+)!+'34! !
'$*'!, * % /%)%/'%* * +*. '.(%$ R*1.'+'!+ *:'#'!+, * *&*"'!+ )!$ %(#."+
!.$'"%!$*+, % !+ '%+ %.%'+, /!! * !*"! !)!$."!, *!"+$%$-+*-=
.%"! < *!$'% ! "*#/'! @.$5'/!, *++%, *"1.%$% !. /!)%$% !
/!"+*"'*"! /!! +*"! . "*#!/'! @.$5'/!, * %++' *&*"* 1.* )!++% +*$>'$
/!! *:/(.*"* * %"'@.$''/'%*, .% >*9 1.* !+ )$'"/5)'!+ 1.* %%$/% !
"*#/'! @.$5'/!, +4! !+ *+!+ 1.* "!$*'% %+ $*(%3*+ * '$*'! )$'>%! *
%++', &'/% %! %(>*$'! %+ )%$*+ $*(%/'!"%$* *"$* +', ! !@*! * '+)!+'34! * %("*#/'! @.$5'/! P!$ !.$%+ )%(%>$%+, !%+ %+ %3*+ /!"+*"'%+ 1.* *+'>*++*
* /!"&!$'%* /! ! '$*'! )$'>%!, %'"% 1.* *'>%%+ % %"'@.$''/'%* )*"%(,
*+% *+%$'% *:/(.5% * &%/* %+ '+)!+'3*+ % #*+4! * "*#/'!+GY[
E $*(%34! %!+ *"+ "% *!$'% % %34! @.$5'/%, P'*$%"#*(' (*/'!"% %
+*#.'"* &!$%
!+ *"+ +4! @.$''/%*"* .*(%!+ *"1.%"! ! +*. '.(%$ !+ /!"+'*$% * !+$%% /!! *"+ * >%(!$ S* '.(%$ * '! * /!"+*"* "% +.% )*$%, "%
+.% ''".'34! !. *:)!+'34! % )*$'#! * )*$% !. * $*.34!, * +*$/!"+'*$%% (5/'% % /!".%YY
P%$% *+% *!$'%, * !.$%+ )%(%>$%+, % ('>$* %"'&*+%34! ! '.(%$ !
* )$!*#'! )*(! '$*'!, * /!"+*"'$ "% $*"."/'% % %( )$!*34! ! +.&'/'*"*
)%$% 1.* ! /!"+*"'*"! >=('!, +'$>% /!! &%!$ *+/%$%/*$'9%"* ! ')!
'"/$''"%!$
53 FEUERBACH, a'ud PIERAN?ELI, J!+ H*"$'1.* O 5o7se7t4;e7to do o3e7d4do: 7a teor4a dodel4to * S4! P%.(! R*>'+% !+ T$'."%'+, 200 ) 54 PIERAN?ELI, J!+ H*"$'1.* O 5o7se7t4;e7to do o3e7d4do: 7a teor4a do del4to * S4!P%.(! R*>'+% !+ T$'."%'+, 200 ) Y55 PIERAN?ELI, J!+ H*"$'1.* O 5o7se7t4;e7to do o3e7d4do: 7a teor4a do del4to * S4!P%.(! R*>'+% !+ T$'."%'+, 200 ) Q
40
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 43/59
[[ DOS REUISITOS UE COMP\EM O CONSENTIMENTO VÁLIDO
N4! 6= %"%+ '>*$#;"/'%+ !.$'"%$'%+ "! 1.* %"#* % /!)!+'34! !+
$*1.'+'!+ )%$% 1.* ! /!"+*"'*"! >=('! +'$>% /!! /%.+% +.)$% (*#%( *
*:/(.*"* % %"'@.$''/'%*, )!$ '++! +*$= $*%('9%! . *+.! "!+ $*1.'+'!+
*(*"/%!+ )!$ F$%"/'+/! * A++'+ T!(*!Y], )!$ +*$* *(*+ /'%!+ )!$ !.$!+
!.$'"%!$*+ /!! ! /%+! * R!#$'! ?$*/! 200Q, ) K, %)*+%$ *+*,
&!$.(%$ +*.+ $*1.'+'!+ )$)$'!+, 1.%'+ +*@%
P%$% "+, ! /!"+*"'*"! ! !&*"'! +!*"* +.$'$= ! *&*'! *+*@%! +*
*+'>*$* )$*+*"*+ $;+ $*1.'+'!+ &."%*"%'+7 1.* ! !&*"'! *"6% /%)%/'%* )%$% /!"+*"'$ 1.* ! * +!$* ! 1.%( $*/%'% % /!".% ! % #*"* +*@% '+)!"5>*( 1.* ! /!"+*"'*"! *"6% +'! %! %"*$'!$*"* !. )*(! *"!+ ".%
$*(%34! * +'.(%"*'%* < /!".% ! %#*"*Y
D*+% &*'%, )%++%$-+*-= %! *+.! !+ $*1.'+'!+ ! /!"+*"'*"!
*(*"/%!+ )!$ A++'+ T!(*!, )%$% 1.* %++', )!++% /!"+'*$=-(! /!! +*"! >=('!
O )$'*'$! *(*+, 1.* ! !&*"'! *"6% %"'&*+%! +.% %1.'*+/;"/'%
('>$**"*, +* /!%34!, &$%.* !. !.$! >5/'! * >!"%*
D*+%/%-+*, 1.* @= &'/!. *:)!+!, "!+ !@!+ *++* *+/$'!, 1.* +*$'%
%"%('+%!, ! /!"+*"'*"!, %>'"! * &!$% ('>$*, %$**, /!"+/'*"* * >!(."=$'%,
* "4! (.'$'%!, "! +*. $*%( +*"'!, "4! +*"! !%! %+ *+/.$%
O $*1.'+'! * *+.!, *+%$ )$*+*"* 1.%"! .% )*++!%, )!$ @= )$%'/%$
% )$!+'.'34!, !. *+*@* "*(% '"#$*++%$ %/*'% '$ )%$% . !.$! E+%!, *:*$/*-(%,
/!! +*"! .% )$!&'++4! 1.%(1.*$
O. %'"%, 1.%"! . %(#., /'*"* * 1.* /*$% )*++!% '$% *:*$/*$ %
)$!+'.'34!, !&*$*/* %$'#!, %@.% "!+ /.+!+ % >'%@*, )$!!>*"! !. &%/'('%"!
56 TOLEDO, F$%"/'+/! * A++'+ Pr475@64os <2s45os de d4re4to 6e7al Y * S4! P%.(!7 S%$%'>%,200 ) 2YP%$% ! %.!$ S4! $*1.'+'!+ ! /!"+*"'*"! @.+'&'/%"*7%K 1.* ! !&*"'! *"6% %"'&*+%! +.% %1.'*+/;"/'% ('>$**"*, +* /!%34!, &$%.* !. !.$!
>5/'! * >!"%*K 1.* ! !&*"'!, "! !*"! % %1.'*+/;"/'%, *+*@% * /!"'3*+ * /!)$**"*$ ! +'#"'&'/%!
* %+ /!"+*1^;"/'%+ * +.% */'+4!, )!++.'"!, )!'+, /%)%/'%* )%$% %"!/K 1.* ! * @.$5'/! (*+%! !. *:)!+! % )*$'#! * (*+4! +* +'.* "% *+&*$% * '+)!"''('%* !
%1.'*+/*"*
d) &'"%(*"*, 1.* ! &%! 5)'/! )*"%( +* '*"'&'1.* /! ! 1.* &!' )$*>'+! * +* /!"+'.% * !@*!* /!"+*"'*"! )*(! !&*"'!G A++'+ T!(*! 200, 2YK
57 ?RECO, R!#$'! Curso de d4re4to 6e7al: 6arte =eral 2 * N'*$'7 I)*.+, 200 ) ]0
41
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 44/59
% *"$%% !+ )$!&'++'!"%'+ ! +*:! "! *$$'$'! "%/'!"%(, /!"&'#.$%"! %++', !
$=&'/! '"*$"%/'!"%(, !. "%/'!"%(, *++* 1.%"! ! $%"+(%! !/!$$*$ * *+%!+ %
@.$'+'34! *$$'!$'%( "%/'!"%(, ! 1.* /!"&'#.$% ! $=&'/! '"*$"!
P!$, "! /%+! %/'%, "4! 6= 1.* +* &%(%$ * $=&'/! * )*++!%+, )%$%
&'"+ * )$!+'.'34! U% >*9 1.* ! /!"+*"'*"! "4! !/!$$*. %$%>+ * /!%34!,
&$%.* !. !.$!+ >5/'!+ * >!"%*
N! *"%"!, "4! +*"! $*+)*'%! *++* $*1.'+'!, * +*, ! /!"+*"'*"!
&!$ %1.'$'! * &!$% (.'$'!+%, *"#%"%"! .% %+ )%$*+, !. )!$ *'! *
>'!(;"/'%, 1.%(1.*$ . !.$! *'! %$'(, !$'#%"! %(#. % +* )$!+'.'$ * &!$%
'">!(."=$'%, *+%$'% * &!$% /(%$% /!"&'#.$%! ! $=&'/! * )*++!%+
N4! 6= 8>'% * 1.* % )%$'/')%34! '">!(."=$'% "% )$!+'.'34! /!"+'.'$=&'/!, * 1.* % )$!('&*$%34! %+ !$#%"'9%3*+ /$''"!+%+ >!(%%+ )%$% %'+%'>'%*+ *:'#* .% *"$#'/% * '"*"+% %34! ! E+%!, >%(*"!-+*,'"/(.+'>*, !+ '"+$.*"!+ '+)!"''('9%!+ )*(! '$*'! )*"%(YQ
.%"! %.+*"* *++* $*1.'+'! ! /!"+*"'*"! >%('!, *+%$= '%"* %
)$!+'.'34! '">!(."=$'%, 1.* *"/!"$% $*+)%(! "! %$'#! a, %(5"*% %KG /!! @= &!$%
>'+! %"*+ * 1.* $*9%7
a- A *:)$*++4! b$=&'/! * )*++!%+b +'#"'&'/% ! $*/$.%*"!, ! $%"+)!$*, %
$%"+&*$;"/'%, ! %(!@%*"! !. ! %/!(6'*"! * )*++!%+, re5orre7do a;ea9a ou uso da 3or9a ou a outras 3or;as de 5oa9o ao ra6to 3raude ao e7=a7o ao a<uso de autor4dade ou s4tua9o devul7era<4l4dade ou e7tre=a ou a5e4ta9o de 6a=a;e7tos ou <e7e3@54os)%$% !*$ ! /!"+*"'*"! * .% )*++!% 1.* *"6% %.!$'%* +!$* !.$%)%$% &'"+ * *:)(!$%34! #$'&!.-+*K
S*"! %++', 1.%"! ! /!"+*"/'*"*, "4! +!.*$ % %'>'%* 1.* '$=
*+*)*"6%$, !. 1.%"! +*@% /!%#'!, %(>! * &$%.*, *"1.%$%"!-+* * .%
%+ *(**"%$*+ ! ')!, +*. /!"+*"'*"! "4! +*$= >%('!, )!'+ !+ $*1.'+'!+, )%$%
1.* )!++% /!"+'*$%$ ! /!"+*"'*"! >=('!, %! )!"! * *:/(.'$ % %"'@.$''/'%*,*$4! 1.* +*$ !!+ !%!+ * . 8"'/! /!"@."!
O +*#."! $*1.'+'! *+%*(*/'!, )!$ A++'+ T!(*!, *+)*$% 1.* !
!&*"'!, "! !*"! % %1.'*+/;"/'%, *+*@% * /!"'3*+ * /!)$**"*$ !
+'#"'&'/%! * %+ /!"+*1^;"/'%+ * +.% */'+4!, )!++.'"!, )!'+, /%)%/'%* )%$%
%"!
58 BIANCHINI, A('/* Tr2345o de 6essoas e le4 1$10D F deG $ D'+)!"5>*( * g6)7%$'"%*$(!/!2002$%&'/!-*-)*++!%+-*-(*'-20Y06( h A/*++! * 0 *9200
42
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 45/59
T%, @= &!' *:)('/%! 1.* )!$ !'>! * /!*$;"/'%, '/%, * $*+)*'! <
'#"'%* % )*++!% 6.%"%, +*$'% *:/(.5! ! /!"+*"'*"! $*%('9%! )!$ .%
)*++!% '"/%)%9 * )$*+=-(!, '"*)*"*"**"* * 1.* *++% /%)%/'%* +*@%
$*(%'>% !. %+!(.%
I++!, )!$ *"*"*$ 1.* %+ )*++!%+ '"/%)%9*+, "4! *"6% ! "*/*++=$'!
'+/*$"'*"!, )%$%, 1.* "*+* /%+! * *(% - ! ('>$* *:*$/5/'! % )$!+'.'34! –
)!++% *('*$%$ % $*+)*'! * +*:! * +.%+ /!"+*1^;"/'%+
! /!"+*"/'*"* *>* +*$ /%)%9 * /!"+*"'$, '+! , /%)%9, +*#."! +.%%.$'%* )+51.'/% * !$%(, * $*/!"6*/*$ ! +'#"'&'/%! * ! %(/%"/* %$*"8"/'% %! * @.$5'/! * * @.(#=-(! @.+%*"* K N4! +* *:'#* )%$% '+!.% **$'"%% '%* K D*/'+'>! +!*"* 1.* *"6% %%$/%!
'"*'$%*"*, +*#."! +.% %.$'%* * *"*"'*"! * /%)%/'%* * @.(#%*"!, % *++;"/'%, ! %(/%"/* * !+ *&*'!+ % '"*$>*"34! %&*%!$% *+*.+ '"*$*++*+ KY
O *$/*'$! $*1.'+'! *+)*$% 1.* ! &%! 5)'/! )*"%( +* '*"'&'1.* /! ! 1.*
&!' )$*>'+! * +* /!"+'.% * !@*! * /!"+*"'*"! )*(! !&*"'!
E+* $*1.'+'!, "%% %'+ *:'#* 1.* +*@% !+*$>%! ! *"1.%$%*"! !
/!"+*"'*"!, "%+ *(**"%$*+ ! ')!, )%$% 1.* )!++% *+/!"&'#.$=-(!
E !.$%+ )%(%>$%+, $*1.'+'! * /!*"! *:'#* 1.* ! /!"+*"'*"! +*@%
%! )%$% %1.*(* *>'! &' * "4! )%$% . !.$!, !. +*@%, )%$% 1.* )!++% +*$ >=('!! /!"+*"'*"! "! $=&'/! * )*++!%+ "% !%('%* )$!+'.'34!, %+ )%$*+
*">!(>'%+ *$4! 1.* *+%$ /'*"*+ ! 1.* !/!$$* "! *!$ * +.% $*(%34!
P!+ /!! +%'! ! $=&'/! * )*++!%+ * +.%+ *(**"%$*+ ! ')!
)$)$'! $%9'! "!+ %$'#!+ 2, 2-A * +*#.'"*+ D*+% &!$%, +* "4! &!$
!+*$>%% % '"*"34! %+ )*++!%+ )%$% %1.*(* )$!)+'! ! /!"+*"'*"! "4! +*$=
/!"+'.5!, *, )!$ /!"+*#.'"*, "4! +*$>'$= /!! *:/(.*"* % %"'@.$''/'%* P!$
*:*)(!, +* .% )*++!% /!"+*"'$ * +*$ $%"+)!$%% )%$% . !.$! E+%!,+%*"! %)*"%+ 1.* '$'% $%%(6%$, %+ "4! +%'% * 1.* !. /!!, * /6*#%"! (=,
* !.$! )%5+, !$'#%% % *:*$/*$ % )$!+'.'34! )%$% +* %"*$, !. % >*"6% %
*:*$/*$ /!! &!$% * )$%9*$, "*+*+ /%+!+, *+%$-+*-= '%"* ! *"1.%$%*"!
$=&'/! * )*++!%+ )%$% &'"+ * *:)(!$%34! +*:.%(, .% >*9 1.* *$% !
59 jESSELS, J!6%""*+, a'ud DOS SANTOS, M%.$'/'! M%/*! SÊ?A, V'>'%"* A%$%( O
5o7se7t4;e7to do o3e7d4do 7a teor4a do del4to J.+ "%>'#%"' ) 2 !. 2000 D'+)!"5>*( * g6)7@.+.!(/!$$*>'+%*:!QQ!-/!"+*"'*"!-!-!&*"'!-"%-*!$'%-!-*('!h A/*++! * 0*9 200
43
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 46/59
*+/!"6*/'*"! % >''% .% %+ *(**"%$*+ ! *('! 1.* "! /%+! * >!#%
+*$'% ! *:*$/5/'! % )$!+'.'34!, * %++' &%(!.-(6* ! /!"+*"'*"! )%$% %(
P!$, @= "! /%+! * .% )*++!%, *+/!"6*/*!$% % $*%('%*, >' %
&%/'('%$ % *"$%% !. +%5% * %(#. "! *$$'$'! "%/'!"%(, !. &%/'('%$ * &!$%
'"*$"% ! $%"+(%! * . *+%! )%$% . !.$!, * *+* %(#. >'*$ % *:*$/*$ %
)$!+'.'34!, !. )$%'/%$ 1.%(1.*$ %+ !.$%+ *(**"%$*+ ! ')!, "4! 6= 1.* +* &%(%$
* $=&'/! * )*++!%+
I++! )!+, ! '"'>'.! 1.* *+/!"6*/'% % $*%('%*, "4! '"6% % '"*"34! *
)$%'/%$ %+ *(**"%$*+ ! ')!, )!$ '++! '"/!$$*. * *$$! * ')!, "4! +
*+/%$%/*$'9%"! % %"'@.$''/'%*, .% >*9, 1.* %)*+%$ * +.% &%(% *
/!"6*/'*"!, 6%>'% ! ('>$* /!">*"/'*"! ! $%"+)!$%!, %+ %, )!$'"/!$$*$ "! *$$!, *:/(.'$'% % /.()%'('%* * )!$ /!"+*1^;"/'% ! )$)$'! /$'*
E )!$ .('!, /!! $*1.'+'!, )%$% ! /!"+*"'*"! >=('!, *+)*$%-+* 1.*
! * @.$5'/! (*+%! !. *:)!+! % )*$'#! * (*+4! +* +'.* "% *+&*$% *
'+)!"''('%* ! %1.'*+/*"*
C!! /*'3!, ! * @.$5'/! 1.* ! E+%! .+/% .*(%$ % ('*$%*
+*:.%( ! '"'>'.!, 1.* )%$% %(#."+ %.!$*+ . * 1.* +* +'.% "% *+&*$% !+
*"+ '"'+)!"5>*'+ E++* . )!+'/'!"%*"! !.$'"=$'!, +*#.'! )!$ !.!+ /!!R!#$'! S%"/6*+ %! *+.%$ ! *('! $=&'/! * )*++!%+, ! 1.%( >; )$*(*/'!"%$ 1.*
O /!"+*"'*"! )!$ )%$* %1.*(*+ 1.* +* +.** < %34! "4! *('* %
$*+)!"+%'('%* ! %#*"* )*(% )$='/% *('.!+%, * $%94! % '"'+)!"''('%* !
* @.$5'/! .*(%! '#"'%* +*:.%(KG]0 C!)$**"*"! 1.* % '#"'%* +*:.%(
+'#"'&'/% % .*(% % ('*$%* * ! *+*">!(>'*"! +*:.%( * /%% )*++!%
6.%"%G]
R!#$'! S%"/6*+, /!! >'+!, /!"+'*$% * &!$% *:)$*++% 1.* %'#"'%* +*:.%( . * @.$5'/! )$!*#'! "% ')'&'/%34! ! *('! $=&'/! *
)*++!%+, * 1.* ! *+!, *"1.%$%-+* &!$% % *+&*$% * '+)!"''('%* !
'"'>'.!, "4! )!*"! *+* )!$ /!"+*1^;"/'% '+)!$
60 SANCHES, R!#$'! ?OMES, L.'9 F(=>'! /`!K %). FALEIROS, E !4re4to 6e7al: 6arte es6e54al > * S4! P%.(!7 RT, 200 ) 2]
61 ?OMES, L.'+ F(=>'! Cr4;es 5o7tra a d4=74dade se8ual e outras re3or;as 6e7a4s D'+)!"5>*(*7g6)7@.+$%+'(/!$"!'/'%+Q202/$'*+-/!"$%-%-'#"'%*-+*:.%(-*-!.$%+-$*&!$%+-)*"%'+ h A/*++! * 0 *9 200
44
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 47/59
S*"! %++', )!*-+* /!"/(.'$ 1.* )%$% ! !.$'"%!, ! 1.* %&%+% %
)!++''('%* ! /!"+*"'*"! >=('! +*$>'$ /!! *:/(.*"* * %"'@.$''/'%*
+.)$%(*#%(, % %.+;"/'% * . !+ +*.+ $*1.'+'!+ 1.* +*$'% % '+)!"''('%* !
* .*(%! )*(! '$*'! )*"%( )=$'!
P!$, %!%! . !.$! )!+'/'!"%*"! !.$'"=$'! % *++* $*+)*'!,
*"1.%$%"! % '#"'%* +*:.%( "% *+&*$% !+ *"+ '+)!"5>*'+ ! '"'>'.!
.%"! *+* "4! +* $*>*+* * .% '*'%% .'('%* +!/'%( * ! E+%!$*/!"6*/* %! )%$'/.(%$ % *:/(.+'>'%* ! .+! * #!9!, *+* '+)!"5>*(, *,/!"$%$'%*"*, 1.%"! % .'('%* +!/'%( +* %"'&*+%$ * '*'%!, ! * '"'+)!"5>*(]2
T$%%(6%"! % ''%, %/'%, * J!+ H*"$'1.* P'*$%"#*(', )*$/**-+* 1.*
*(* *&*"* +*$ )!++5>*( % '+)!"''('%* ! *, 1.%"! *+* &!$ )*$*"/*"* %
*+&*$% ! )%$'/.(%$ C%*"!, %++', %! '"'>'.! * &!$% *:/(.+'>%, ! .+! * #!9!
! * .*(%! )*(! E+%!, +*)$* 1.* "4! &!$ . * * .'('%* +!/'%(, )!'+
*+*+ +4! '"'+)!"5>*'+ O$%, +* 1.* )$%'/% % )$!+'.'34!, *+% *:*$/*"! .%
%'>'%* ('/'%, * %'"% )!$ /'%, % *:*$/* "! +*'! +!/'%(, "4! 6= 1.* +* &%(%$ *
>'!(%34! % '#"'%* +*:.%(
R%/'!/5"'! )*$&'(6%! )!$ D%=+'! * J*+.+,
+* )!$ . (%!, *+=-+* * %/!$! * 1.*, *"! 6%>'! /';"/'% */!"+*"'*"! * $*(%34! %! )$!)+'! ! *+(!/%*"! *:*$/5/'! %)$!+'.'34!K, "4! 6= 1.* +* &%(%$ "% .(6*$ /!! +.@*'! )%++'>!, )!$ !.$!'"*:'+'"! %( %".;"/'%, % .(6*$ )%++% % +*$ % >5'% '$*% ! *('!, >'+!1.* !!+ !+ *%'+ *'!+ * )$='/% ! /$'* >'!(;"/'%, #$%>* %*%3% !.&$%.*K *"/*$$% !&*"+% < )$)$'% .(6*$ D*+%$$%9!%%, %++', %/!"+'*$%34! * 1.* "*++*+ /%+!+ ! * @.$5'/! )$!*#'! "4! )!++% *+%$>'"/.(%!, * %(#.% &!$% < )$)$'% .(6*$, !. * 1.* *(% &'#.$%$'% /!!>5'% '"'$*% c % +.% ('*$%*, +.% '"*#$'%* &5+'/%, +.% >'% !. +.%6!"$% 1.* *+4! +*"! !&*"'%+ "! *('! * $=&'/!, se;6re Hue 6rat45adose; a a7u754a a ;ulher ] #$'&!.-+*K
A++', "4! )!*$= +*$ (''%! ! *:*$/5/'! % )$!+'.'34! * . !.$!
E+%!, !. "!+ *+%!+ '"*$"!+ ! *$$'$'! $%+'(*'$!, 1.%"! &!$ $*%('9%!, +*@%
/! %@.%, !. /! &'"+ */!"`'/!+ * . *$/*'$!, *"! %+ )%$*+ %/!$%! *
%".5! *"$* +' C%*"! %! E+%! .% .*(% )."''>% +*/."=$'%, 1.%"!
)$!/.$%! )!$ . !+ *">!(>'!+ "% $*(%34!
62 PIERAN?ELI, J!+ H*"$'1.* O 5o7se7t4;e7to do o3e7d4do: 7a teor4a do del4to * S4!P%.(! R*>'+% !+ T$'."%'+, 200 ) 2[63 JESUS, D%=+'! *, a'ud CAPEZ, F*$"%"! PRADO, S*(%, MARZA?ÃO J_NIOR, L%*$* I/!!K * %( Tr2345o de 6essoas S4! P%.(!7 .%$'*$ L%'", 200 ) 2Y
45
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 48/59
P!$ "4! )!* +*$ "*#%! 1.* )$*!'"% ! '"*$*++* *+%%(, +*)$*
1.* ! '"'>'.! '.(%$ ! * )$!*#'! )*(! E+%!, &!$ !$'#%! % *(* &%9*$ .+!,
%++' 1.%"! % )$!+'.'34! &!$ *:*$/'% * &!$% &!$3%%, !. (.'$'%%, +!&$*$=
>'!(%34! % '#"'%* +*:.%(, !$"%"!-+*, %.!%'/%*"*, * '"*$*++* ! E+%!
< .*(% * )$!*34! % %( >'!(%34!
L*$%"! 1.* ! %"! "4! )!* +*$ /!"&."'"! /! % *$%
'!$%('%* % /!".%, /! % !&*"+% * >%(!$*+ '/!-+!/'%'+, "* /! ! &%/! *
% /!".% +* %&%+%$ ! )%$4! +!/'%(*"* %/*'! !'"%"* * /!)!$%*"!G][
E++* ! )!+'/'!"%*"!, 1.* % %!%! )!$ A('/* B'%/6'"']Y, %!
/$''/%$ ! *"1.%$%*"! % '#"'%* +*:.%( "% *+&*$% * *"+ '"'+)!"5>*'+ *
$*+)%(%"!-! /!! . * * '"*$*++* )8('/!
N%% %'+ '"&*('9 * '"/!$$*!K 1.* *++% ).('/'9%34! * . * @.$5'/! 1.* *'"*"**"* )*++!%( K R*+$'"#'$ ! * @.$5'/! !+ *('!+ +*:.%'+ <('*$%* +*:.%( %&%+%"!-+*, )!$%"!, % .*(% % !$%('%* +*:.%(K %'.* ('*$=$'%, )!$1.* )*$'* 1.* +* *':* * ')$''$ .% /!"+%"*>'#'("/'% %!+ /!)!$%*"!+ +*:.%'+, )!++''('%"! 1.* /%% 1.%(*+%*(*3% ! 1.* (6* )%$*3% )$)$'!, +*)$*, /(%$!, 1.* %( *+/!(6% "4!$*)$*+*"* .% !&*"+% < ('*$%* +*:.%( ! !.$!JJ
A !.$'"%!$% *"1.%$%, %++', ! !@*! .*(%! )*(! ')! )*"%( !
$=&'/! * )*++!%+ )%$% &'"+ * *:)(!$%34!, +*@% '"*$"%/'!"%( !. "%/'!"%(, "!+ *"+)%++'>*'+ * '+)!+'34! % /$'$'! * +*. '.(%$
S='! )!+'/'!"%*"!, ! % !.$'"%!$% U% >*9 1.* "'"#. *(6!$
1.* ! '.(%$ % '#"'%* +*:.%( )$!*#'% )*(! E+%!, )%$% +%*$ !+ (''*+
+.)!$%!+ )*(! *:*$/5/'! * +*. '$*'!, %++' /!! )*(%+ >'!(%3*+ +!&$'%+ )*(!
*+!
N4! )!*"!, ! E+%! $*'$%$ % *+&*$% ! )%$'/.(%$, %(#! '"'!, 1.* !
*+!, )!++''('% +*. .+! 1.%+* 1.* )(*"!, .% >*9 1.* ! *:*$/5/'! %)$!+'.'34!, "4! *"/!"$%! /!! &%! 5)'/! "! !@! %+ (*'+ )*"%'+, ! 1.*
64 NATSCHERADETZ, %$, a'ud ?RECO, A(*++%"$% O$/*+' RASSI, J!4! D%"'*( Cr4;es 5o7tra ad4=74dade se8ual S4! P%.(!7 A(%+, 200 ) Y[65 A !.$'"% %+'/%*"* .""'* "! *"*"'*"! * 1.* ! * @.$5'/! )$!*#'! "!+ *('!+ *$=&'/! '"*$"%/'!"%( * '"*$"! * )*++!%+ % !$%( +*:.%( )8('/% ?.'(6*$* * S!.9% N.//', J.('!F%$'"' M'$%**, L.'9 R*#'+ P$%!, *"$* !.$!+K, 1.* b $*)$*+*"%% )!$ . /!"@."! * "!$%+1.* '% ! /!)!$%*"! % +*$ !+*$>%! )*(% +!/'*%*, "!+ !5"'!+ % +*:.%('%*b I%$%I(#*"&$'9 % S'(>%K BIANCHINI, A('/* Tr2345o de 6essoas e le4 1$10D F deG $ D'+)!"5>*(
* g 6)7%$'"%*$(!/!2002$%&'/!-*-)*++!%+-*-(*'-20Y06( h A/*++! * 0*9 20066 I*
46
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 49/59
'&'/.(% ! *"*"'*"!, * ! )!$1.; "4! +*$ /!"+'*$%! ! /!"+*"'*"! /!!
*:/(.*"* % %"'@.$''/'%*
N*+% ('"6% * $%/'!/5"'!, ! '"'>'.!, + +*$= /!"+'*$%! >5'% ! *('!
$=&'/! * )*++!%+ )%$% &'"+ * *:)(!$%34! +*:.%(, * %(#.%+ 6')*+*+, %+ 1.%'+
+*$'% (''%%+ < &%(% * +*. /!"+*"'*"! >=('! E+% ('"6% * $%/'!/5"'!
)$*(*/'!"%% )!$ A(*++%"$% ?$*/!, %! '+)!$ 1.*
%)*+%$ * )!*$ *:'+'$ '&'/.(%* * )$!>%, *+* (!#! 6= 1.* +* '+'"#.'$$;+ +'.%3*+7 % %1.*(* !. %1.*(% 1.* +4! %('/'%!+ /! &%(+%+)$!*++%+ * * 1.*, (!#! %)+, % +'.%34! "4! *+*@%% +* $*>*(%, %+1.*, %%+ %+ /'$/."+%"/'%+, '$$*>*$+5>*( % %1.*(*+ 1.* +%* 1.%( %+'.%34! 1.* !+ *+)*$% * *++% +'.%34! %/*'%, %+, )!$ *'!+ * /!%34!,"4! )!* %%"!"%-(% * % %1.*(*+ 1.* +%* ! 1.* !+ *+)*$% * %/*'%
*++%+ /!"'3*+ )!$1.* +.% /!"'34! * >'%, %'"% 1.* *"!+ '#"%, *(6!$ ! 1.* "% $*#'4! * !$'#*N! )$'*'$! /%+!, * 1.%(1.*$ !+ !*"!+ % %34! /$''"!+%, "4! 6= 1.*+* &%(%$ * %)('/%34! % *!$'% % %.!/!(!/%34! % >5'% * $'+/! !./!"+*"'*"!, *"! * >'+% 1.* &%(% ! >!"%* ('>$* * "4! >'/'%% *+%8('%N! +*#."! * "! *$/*'$!, ! )!"! )*"*"* *+= "% %/*'%34!, +* ('>$* */!"+/'*"* % >5'% <+ /!"'3*+ % "!>% >'%, * /%$=*$ '"'/'%( !.)*$%"*"**"*, * ! %++.'$ ! $'+/! !+ *+>'!+ /!."+ * /%+!+ *++%"%.$*9% +.&'/'*"* )%$% *:/(.'$ ! /$'* * $=&'/! * )*++!%+]
E+.%!+ !+ $*1.'+'!+ "*/*++=$'!+ )%$% 1.* +* )!++% *"1.%$%$ !
/!"+*"'*"! /!! +*"! >=('!, &'/% ')!++5>*( * %/*'%$ % >'!(%34! 1.* *:'+*%! '$*'! * ('*$%* +*:.%( %+ )*++!%+ 1.%"! *+%+ 1.*$* *:*$/*$-(! * +.%
)(*"'.*, +*"! %:%% /!! )*++!%+ >5'%+ * $=&'/!, +*"! %++', % ''% 1.*
)%++* % !/!$$* .% /!$$*% %*1.%34! *"$* %+ %3*+/!".%+ * % ')'&'/%34!
%*1.%% I++! 1.%"! "*/*++=$'! P!+! 1.* *:'+% >=$'!+, /%+!+, !+ 1.%'+
*>* +*$ %"%('+%!+ * &!$% '+!(%% * ')%$/'%(
C!! )*$/*'! ! /!"+*"'*"! >%('! +*$>* +' /!! &%!$
*+/%$%/*$'9%"* ! *('! $=&'/! * )*++!%+, "! *"%"!, /!! @= &!' /!(!/%!%(6.$*+, %/$*'%, * *&*"*-+* 1.* + )!*$= *+/%$%/*$'9%$, 1.%"! *+'>*$ '%"*
* . *1.'>!/! "% !%('%* $=&'/! * )*++!%+ )%$% &'"+ * *:)(!$%34! +*:.%(,
%$'"! % )!++''('%* * *"1.%$%*"! % /!".% * .% !.$% ')'&'/%34!,
*+* 1.* /(%$! )$*>'+% )$*>'%*"* * (*'
L*$%"!-+* 1.* *&*"'!, )!$ *+% )*+1.'+% % ')!++''('%* *
*:)%"'$ *++% *:/(.*"* +.)$%(*#%( * %"'@.$''/'%* %+ *%'+ !%('%*+ *
$=&'/! * )*++!%+, )*(!+ !'>!+ @= *:)!+!+ * * $%%(6%!+
67 ?RECO, A(*++%"$% O$/*+' P*$! MARZA?ÃO J_NIOR, L%*$* I /!!K * %( Tr2345o de6essoas S4! P%.(!7 .%$'*$ L%'", 200 ) 0
47
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 50/59
0 !AS COSE.U+CIAS SOCIAIS EM COSI!ERAR A RE(A"#O ETRE APROSTITUI"#O E O TRÁ%ICO !E PESSOAS
A#!$%, /6*#%% % 6!$% * %!$%$ %+ /!"+*1^;"/'%+ "! *'! +!/'%(
1.%"! +* %*1.%$ % /!".%, /! % ')'&'/%34! /!$$*%, *:/(.'"! ! ')! $=&'/! *
)*++!%+ )%$% &'"+ * *:)(!$%34! +*:.%(, 1.%"! *">!(>*$ ! /!"+*"'*"! >=('! !
'.(%$ ! * .*(%! )*(! E+%!
Y DA RELAÇÃO7 PROSTITUIÇÃO E OS BONS COSTUMES
A /!"&.+4! 1.* %/!"*/* "! !*"! * **$'"%$ * &!$% >=('% !
!@*! @.$5'/! ! *('! $=&'/! * )*++!%+ )%$% &'"+ * *:)(!$%34! +*:.%(, +* =
#$%3%+ < $*(%34! '>*$#*"* *"$* % )$!+'.'34! * ! !+ !"+ /!+.*+ *+* >'+!
/!! . )$'"/')'! #%$%"'!$ * /%$=*$ /!#"!+/''>!, %( /!! !/!$$* /! !!+ !+
*%'+ *"+ @.$5'/!+G]Q
P!$, "% $*%('%*, "4! +* )!* +.+*"%$ 1.* % )$!+'.'34! +*@% .%
%'>'%* 1.* >%' * *"/!"$! %!+ !"+ /!+.*+, )!'+ % *+% )$%'/%% *
%/*'%, )*(% +!/'*%*, "4! +*"! +.% )$='/% %(>! * ')'&'/%34! %(#.%
U% >*9 1.* )%$% ! '$*'! )*"%(, '&*$*"**"* ! 1.* !/!$$* /! !
'$*'! /'>'(, !+ !"+ /!+.*+ + %%$/% % !$%('%* * */;"/'% +*:.%( .*
/!$$!!$% /! *++* )!+'/'!"%*"! P'*$$%"#*((', %! $%%(6%$ % (''%34! !
/!"+*"'*"! "! '$*'! )*"%(, %&'$%"! 1.* N! '$*'! )*"%(, * .% %"*'$%
#*$%(, % !.$'"% (''% +.% *+&*$% * %.%34! < */;"/'% * % !$%( +*:.%(G ]
R*+%"!, %++', < /!"+/';"/'% !$%( % +!/'*%* /!! *(**"! !+
!"+ /!+.*+, "! '! ! '$*'! /'>'( A++' /!! /*'3!, % )$!+'.'34! "4!/%.+% %"! % "*"6. !+ *(**"!+ /!)!"*"*+ ! /!"+*"'*"! "% *+&*$% !
'$*'! )*"%(
V*$-+* "*/*++=$'! *&*"*$ % (''%34! +!&$'% "! !@*! !+ !"+
/!+.*+, * $*(%34! %! '$*'! )*"%(, )!$1.* +* &!$ %$%"#;-(!, )!$ *:*)(!, )%$%
!+ )$'"/5)'!+ '/!+ * '$*'! * #*$%(, >%' /%.+%$ ''".'34! "% '+)!"''('%* !+
*"+ ! /'%4!
68 PIERAN?ELI, J!+ H*"$'1.* O 5o7se7t4;e7to do o3e7d4do: 7a teor4a do del4to * S4!P%.(! R*>'+% !+ T$'."%'+, 200 ) 2269 I*
48
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 51/59
E "4! +* '#% 1.* 1.*$*"! %$-+* %'!$ %)('.* %! /!"/*'! * !"+/!+.*+, )%$% %$%"#*$ % !!+ !+ )$'"/5)'!+ )*$*"/*"*+ %! )%$'`"'!'/! * .% +!/'*%*, 1.%+* 1.* +* /6*#%$'% < %+!(.% "*#%34! %('*$%* * /!"+*"'$, !. +*@%, % .% *:%#*$%% (''%34! % )!++''('%** '"'>'.%('9%$ !+ '"*$*++*+ '+)!"5>*'+ 0
A++' $*+% /(%$! 1.* 1.%"! % %34! ! /'%4! /%.+%$ %"! *&*'>! %!+
*(**"!+ 1.* /!)* !+ !"+ /!+.*+, )!*$= ! E+%!, * "!* %
+!/'*%*, '"*$>'$ A++' "4! ! , )!$, 1.%"! % '"%#%34! +* &%9 '$*%*"*
%! /!"+*"'*"! ! '.(%$ ! '$*'!, !., )!$ !.$%+ )%(%>$%+, %! %! * '+)!+'34!
1.* )*$'* /!"+'*$%$ (5/'% .% /!".% 5)'/%G
O. +*@%, 1.%"! !/!$$*$ >'!(%34! %!+ !"+ /!+.*+, * *++% >'!(%34!
)$*+/'"'$ ! /!"+*"'*"! >=('! ! '.(%$ ! * .*(%!, *+! %++', "4!
)!*$= +*$ /!"+'*$%% 5)'/% % /!".% )$%'/%% )*(! %#*"* U% >*9 1.* +* !
/!"+*"'*"! >=('! +*$>' )%$% *:/(.'$ % %"'@.$''/'%*, (!#! +*$>'$= )%$% 1.* +*@%
*+/!"+'*$%% >'!(%34! %!+ !"+ /!+.*+
D'%"* '++!, !% )*++!% )!* ('>$**"* .+%$ * #!9%$ * +.% ('*$%* *'+)!+'34! * . * $*"."/'=>*( * !+ !"+ /!+.*+ + *"/!"$% (''*+1.%"! ! /!"+*"/'*"* /(%$%*"* >'!(% !+ )$'"/5)'!+ * *:'#;"/'%+ '/%+ %/!"+/';"/'% !$%( * .% +!/'*%*, /!! !/!$$* ,)*g* "! /!"+*"'*"!)%$% +*>5/'%+ +*:.%'+ 1.* )$!.9* (*+*+ /!$)!$%'+ * "%.$*9% #$%>*2
D*+* !!, ! /'%4! ('>$* )%$% *:*$/*$ % )$!+'.'34!, +* 1.* (6*
+*@% %$'.5! $*+)!"+%'('%* % >'!(%3*+ !+ !"+ /!+.*+, *+* 1.* $*+)*'*
! '$*'! %(6*'!, .% >*9 1.* %( >'!(%34! "4! )!*$= !/!$$*$ "! *:*$/5/'! (5/'! %
%'>'%* +*:.%( $*)$*+*"%% )*(% )$!+'.'34!
Y2 DA RALAÇÃO7 PROSTITUIÇÃO E O TRÁFICO DE PESSOAS
A *>!(.34! % +!/'*%*, +* /!"/$*'9!. * %( &!$% 1.* "4! +.)!$%
%'+ *++* /*$/*%*"! < +.% ('*$%*, *, %++', +* &%9 "*/*++=$'! *"*"*$ 1.*
S*"! % )$!+'.'34! >!(."=$'% %'"% 1.* *).$$%% )!$ /%.+%+ +!/'%'+K,"4! 6= * @.$5'/!-)*"%( 1.* *+*@% +*"! >'!(%! O$%, +* % )*++!% ('>$*,'"/(.+'>* )%$% +* )$!+'.'$, )!$ 1.%( $%94! %1.*(* 1.* )$!!>*, &%9 %'"*$*'%34! !. &%/'('% % +.% *"$%% !. % +.% +%5% ! *$$'$'! "%/'!"%(!. ! +*. *+(!/%*"! *"$! %+ &$!"*'$%+ ! )%5+ *>* +*$/$''"%('9%!d
70 PIERAN?ELI, J!+ H*"$'1.* O 5o7se7t4;e7to do o3e7d4do: 7a teor4a do del4to * S4!P%.(! R*>'+% !+ T$'."%'+, 200 ) 271 I*72 I*, ) 2[
49
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 52/59
I++! +* = )!$ /%.+% ! )$*/!"/*'! %>'"! * .% +!/'*%* 6')/$'%
1.* '"+'+* * "4! *>!(.'$, )%$% %(/%"3%$ ! *+*">!(>'*"! * +*. )!>! P!'+ !
1.* %/!"*/*, "4! * !!+ !+ /%+!+, %+ "! *&*"'! )*(% )*+1.'+%, .%$*(%34! 1.* +* *1.')%$% %! >5"/.(! *)$*#%5/'!, * 1.* )!* +*$ /!)%$%% %
1.%(1.*$ !.$% %'>'%*, !"* +* * )$*+*"* /!! )%$* '"*$*++%%+ )*++!%+
/! !@*'>!+ $*/5)$!/!+ * /!">*$#*"*+, 1.* +!&$* (''%3*+ %! +*. '$*'! <
('*$%*, )!$ !'>!+, 1.* "! =:'!, &*$* % !$%(
E %++', &%9 *&*+% S'(>*'$%,
P*(! *+>%9'%*"! ! /!"*8! )*"%( +*:.%(, "! '$*'! $%+'(*'$!, $*(%'>!+ <
!+/*"'%* !. )!$"!#$%&'%, &$%.* +*:.%(, /!$$.)34! * *"!$*+,$*++%(>%"! !+ /%+!+ * 1.* +* *">!(>% *"!$*+ !. 1.* % )$!+'.'34!+*@% &!$3%%, .! )%$% *>'%$-+* % .*(% * *$%+ !$%('%*+[
N4! * "*#%$ 1.* % /%.+% % )$!+'.'34! /!"+'*$%% .% %+
)$!&'++*+ %'+ %"'#%, +* *. )!$ &%!$*+ +!/'%'+, /%$;"/'% * '"/*"'>! )%$% .
*(6!$ *+*">!(>'*"! "! )%5+, &%(% * '"&!$%3*+ "*/*++=$'%+, +.'++4! %
.(6*$ %! 6!*, * * &', )!$ >=$'!+ !'>!+
P!$ * '%+ %.%'+, *++*+ "4! +4! !+ 8"'/!+ !'>!+ 1.* (*>% .
'"'>'.! % +* )$!+'.'$, /(%$! 1.* "4! *+%$ +*"! *+/%$%! <+ *:'+;"/'%+ !+
)$!(*%+ /'%!+, * +' )!* % '9*$ 1.* %(#."+ *(*+ *>!(.5$% % )%%%$*+
'"/$5>*'+, %+ "4! +* )!* '#"!$%$, )!$ !.$! (%!, 1.* % )$!+'.'34! *+% +*"!
*:*$/'% /!! *'! * %'"#'$ +%.+ "% +!/'*%*, * 6!@* % .% &!$% *
.%$ % /(%++* */!"`'/!-+!/'%( * 1.* >'>* +*. )$%'/%"*, +*$>'"! /!! .
*'! )%$% %'"#'$ . &'
S* &!$ $*%('9%% .% &'+/%('9%34! *&*'>% "% %'>'%* % )$!+'.'34! )!$
)%$* ! E+%!, $*#.(%"! %+ $*(%3*+ %>'"%+ *++% $%"+%34! /!! +* &!++*1.%(1.*$ .% !.$% )$*+%34! * +*$>'3!, $*+%$'% ''".5% % *:)(!$%34! +*:.%( *
.% &!$% +'#"'&'/%'>%
A++' /!! * $*+%$'%, )$!&'++'!"%'+ $*#.(%$*+ – '++! '"'/% %'!$*+ *
/%)%9*+ - )%$% +.)$'$ %+ "*/*++'%*+ ! *$/%!, ! 1.%( % +!/'*%* "4! )!*
"*#%$ 1.* *:'+* R*+.(%"!, %++', "% ''".'34! ! $=&'/! * )*++!%+ )%$% &'"+
73 BIANCHINI, A('/* Tr2345o de 6essoas e le4 1$10D F deG $ D'+)!"5>*( * g
6)7%$'"%*$(!/!2002$%&'/!-*-)*++!%+-*-(*'-20Y06( h A/*++! * 0 *920074 SILVEIRA, a'ud ?RECO, A(*++%"$% O$/*+' RASSI, J!4! D%"'*( Cr4;es 5o7tra a d4=74dadese8ual S4! P%.(!7 A(%+, 200 ) Y
50
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 53/59
* )$!+'.'34!, )$'"/')%(*"* "! 1.* %"#* %!+ *"!$*+, .% >*9 1.* *$'%
)$!&'++'!"%'+ %)!+ % *:*$/*$* % %'>'%* )$!&'++'!"%( * % '+)!+'34! ! )%$!"!
I++! /(%$!, /!! @= '!, %$%>+ % *&*'>% %.!$'9%34! ! E+%!, * $*#.(%*"!
/!"'9*"* /! % )$!&'++4!
S* &%(%$, "% %$$*/%%34! $'.%$'% 1.* +*$'% '+)!+% %! E+%!, )%$%
1.* *++* ).*++* '">*+'$ "*++*+ )$!&'++'!"%'+ U% >*9 1.* /!! /*'3!,
%'>'%* +*:.%( '$$*#.(%$ %/%$$*% * (./$! )%$% %+ )*++!%+ *$$%%+, ! 1.* + +*$>*
)%$% %.*"%$ % *:)(!$%34! +*:.%( ! 6!* )*(! )$)$'! 6!*
S*"! %++', ! 1.* )$**"* /! *+% )*+1.'+% /'*"'&'/% )!+!,
% )!$ A('/* B'%"/6'""' %! *&*"*$ % '&*$*"3% *"$* $=&'/! * )*++!%+ *
)$!+'.'34! >!(."=$'% % +*#.'"* &!$%7
H= 1.* +* '&*$*"/'%$, *"$*%"!, ! $=&'/! * . (%!K %1.*(% )$!+'.'34!* !.$! (%!K 1.* +* = * &!$% >!(."=$'%, "4!-/!*$/''>%, *">!(>*"!%.(!+ T%( )$*!/.)%34! "4! +* &*9 )$*+*"* "% (*#'+(%34! $%+'(*'$% 1.*,/!"&!$* %"*$'!$*"* *"/'!"%!, )$*>'. +%"3*+ )%$% /!".%+ ('#%%+%! *+(!/%*"! ('>$* * )*++!%+ )%$% % )$!+'.'34! >!(."=$'%,*"!'"%"!-%+ '#.%(*"* * $=&'/! * )*++!%+ )%$% &' * *:)(!$%34!+*:.%(F0
R*%('9%% *++% '&*$*"/'%34!, $*+%$= * /!"/(.+4!, 1.* !+ "8*$!+ 1.*
*+4! *"#$%"*/*"! %+ *+%5+'/%+ !+ *('!+ $=&'/! * )*++!%+ )%$% &'"+ *)$!+'.'34! "4! /!"'9* /! % $*%('%*
P!'+, /!! )!*$= .% )*++!%, 1.* ('>$* )%$% *:*$/*$ % %'>'%*
+*:.%(, * %++' ! &%9 )!$ *'! % )$!+'.'34!, )!++% +*$ /!"+'*$%% /!! >5'%
* $=&'/! * )*++!%+ )%$% &'"+ * )$!+'.'34! 1.%"! /'*"* ! 1.* &%9, * >%' &%9*$d
A++', %, /!! )!*$= .% )*++!%, +*$ *"1.%$%% "! +%.+ *
+.@*'! %'>! ! *('! $=&'/! * )*++!%+ )%$% &'"+ * )$!+'.'34!, 1.%"! %)*"%+
%.:'('%, .% !.$% )*++!% % *:*$/*$ +*. '$*'!, * )$%'/%$ % )$!+'.'34!, 1.* .%%'>'%* (5/'% "! !$*"%*"! @.$5'/! )=$'!d
E "! /%+! * .% *)$*+%, '#%-+* /!! *:*)(!, .% %#;"/'%
%"/%$'%, 1.* *)$*+* '"6*'$! )%$% . /'%4!, *+* *':%"! /(%$!, "! !*"!
% $%"+%34!, 1.* >%' .+%$ ! '"6*'$! )%$% /!)$%$ % )%++%#* )%$% 1.* )!++% +*
)$!+'.'$ * . !.$! )%5+, % *)$*+% %"/%$'%, +*$'% $*+)!"+=>*(, $*+)!"*"!
)*(! *('! * $=&'/! * )*++!%+d
75 BIANCHINI, A('/* Tr2345o de 6essoas e le4 1$10D F deG $ D'+)!"5>*( * g6)7%$'"%*$(!/!2002$%&'/!-*-)*++!%+-*-(*'-20Y06( h A/*++! * 0 *9200
51
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 54/59
D* %/!$! /! ! 1.* >* %/!"*/*"!, +*$'% )!++5>*( % *)$*+%
$*+)!"*$ +', .% >*9 1.* *+%$'% )$!!>*"!, &%/'('%"!, %.:'('%"! %
)$!+'.'34! I++! '"/!"'9*"* /! % $*%('%* +!/'%( )$*+*"*, )!'+ ! /'%4!
('>$* )%$% '$, >'$ !. )*$%"*/*$, "4! )!*"!, +*. '$*'! * ('*$%*, +!&$*$
>'!(%34! + )!$ 1.* +*$= *:*$/'! /! %.:'('! * . *$/*'$!, "% )$%'/% * .%
%'>'%* (5/'%
T%(>*9 +* %&'#.$*, 'rima facie, 1.* lN!+ )%5+*+, /!! ! "!++!, * 1.* "4!+* )$!'' % )$!+'.'34! * +' *+!, +*@% '"@.+'&'/=>*( % $*)$*++4! !+(*"*+, )!'+ +* %( !. 1.%( &%! )*$''! !. )*"%(*"* '"'&*$*"*, "4! +**>*$'%, /!*$*"**"*, '"/$''"%$ !+ 1.* (6* +4! &%.(%'>!+ !.%/*++$'!+ K]
O 1.* !$"% #$'%"* % '"/!*$;"/'% *"$* ! )$'"/')'! /!"+'./'!"%( %
$*+*$>% (*#%(, .% >*9 1.* ! 1.* "4! )$!''! "% "!$% )*"%(, +*$= )*$''!, * !
/*$/*%*"! ! '$*'! < ('*$%*, 1.%"! +* $%% ! *:*$/5/'! % )$!+'.'34!
N% *+% ('"6% * $%/'!/5"'! /!(!/%-+* A(*++%"$% ?$*/!, %! *&*"*$ %
+*#.'"* *+*7
S*, * . (%!, *:'+* .% )*++!% %'!$ * /%)%9 1.* %++.* ! $'+/! !.
/!"+*"* * !.$!, *:'+* % *+)*/'%( '"/$''"%34! % &%/'('%34! < /!".34!* )*++!%+ )%$% &'"+ (5/'!+, *'+ 1.* % )$!+'.'34! . !+ /%+!+ /(=++'/!+* $=&'/!+ * )*++!%+K E +' *+%, "4! /$'*, *+! "!+ )%5+*+ *%'!$ $'#!$ !$%(GdK
D*+% &!$%, *$= 1.* +*$ $*+!(>'! *++* ')%++*, %++', !. * /!"'".%
% /!"+'*$%$ ! *:*$/5/'! % )$!+'.'34! .% %'>'%* (5/'%, /!! !/!$$* * >=$'%+
/'>'('9%3*+, *"$* *(%+, % '.(! * *:*)(!, % $%+'(*'$%, * $*+)*'% % ('*$%* !
/'%4! * )!*$ '+)!$ * +.% ('*$%* +*:.%(, )%++%"! % /!"+'*$%$ !
/!"+*"'*"! >=('! /!! *:/(.*"* * %"'@.$''/'%* ! $=&'/! * )*++!%+,
)%$% &'"+ +*:.%'+, *+.%"! /%% /%+! * )%$'/.(%$
O., * (!#!, ')'&'/%$ ! *:*$/5/'! % )$!+'.'34! O 1.* +*$'% '"/!"/*5>*(
"% +!/'*%* $%+'(*'$%
P!$, ! 1.* "4! )!* )*$%"*/*$ *++% '"/!*$;"/'% 1.* &*$* )$'"/5)'!+
/!"+'./'!"%'+, * >'!(% !+ '$*'!+ ! /'%4! /!!7 % '#"'%* 6.%"%, ('*$%*,
(*#%('%*, *"$* !.$!+
76 HUN?RIA, N*(+!", a'ud CAPEZ, F*$"%"! PRADO, S*(%, MARZA?ÃO J_NIOR, L%*$* I /!!K
* %( Tr2345o de 6essoas S4! P%.(!7 .%$'*$ L%'", 200 ) 2077 ?RECO, A(*++%"$% O$/*+' P*$! J_NIOR MARZA?ÃO, L%*$* I /!!K * %( Tr2345o de6essoas S4! P%.(!7 .%$'*$ L%'", 200 )
52
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 55/59
J COSI!ERA"ES %IAIS
A )$!+'.'34! .% %+ )$!&'++*+ %'+ %"'#%, %+ 1.%'+ +* * "!'/'%
D*+* *"4!, /!"$'.' /! % +!/'*%*, )!'+ #$%3%+ %! +*. *:*$/5/'!, 1.* +* >*
/!"+*#.'"! *>'%$, * &!$% +'#"'&'/%'>%, ! %.*"! "!+ /$'*+ +*:.%'+
I++! ! 1.* @.+'&'/% % $*%('9%34! ! *+.! "% *!$'% ! /!"+*"'*"!
>=('!, %!$%"! +*.+ $*1.'+'!+ *++;"/'%+, )%$% 1.* %++' ).*++* +*$
/!"+'*$%!, * %!(%"!-! "% )!++''('%* * +*$>'$ /!! /'$/."+"/'%
*:/(.*"* % %"'@.$''/'%*, !, 1.* !*$"%*"*, >* +*"! *"*"'! /!!
$=&'/! * )*++!%+, )%$% &'"+ * *:)(!$%34! +*:.%(C6*#%"! < *.34!, 1.* /%% /%+! *>*$= +*$ %"%('+%! * &!$%
'"'>'.%( * ')%$/'%(, +* 1.* *+% !+*$>%34! *+*@% >'/'%% )!$ )$*/!"/*'!+
+!/'%'+ >%(!$%'>!+
O 1.* )!* %/%$$*%$, * .% 6')*+* /!"'9*"* /! % $*%('%*, )*(%
1.%( % +!/'*%* >* +* *)%$%"!, .% >*9 1.* ! *:*$/5/'! % )$!+'.'34!,
%)*+%$ * +!&$*$, )!$ %(#."+, /%$#%+ /! >%(!$*+ "*#%'>!+, .% %'>'%* ('/'% *
.+.&$.5% )!$ )%$* /!"+'*$%% % +!/'*%*, +*@% *:*$/*"!-%, +*@%/!)%$'(6%"! * +*. *:*$/5/'!
A++', $*+!. *!"+$%!, 1.* 1.%"! %+ )*++!%+, * ('>$* >!"%*,
/!"+*"*, * *:*$/*$ +*. '$*'! < ('*$%*, "% *+&*$% +*:.%(, %$%>+ !
*:*$/5/'! % )$!+'.'34!, /! %.:'('! * . %(#., *!. * (!/%( '&*$*"* ! 1.%(
/!+.% *:*$/*-(%, "4! )!*$= +*$ /!"+'*$%%, *++% %'.*, /!! $=&'/! *
)*++!%+, )%$% &'"+ * *:)(!$%34! +*:.%(
U% >*9 1.* "% $*(%34! !$% *"/'!"%%, ;-+* )*++!%+ /%)%9*+ */!"+/'*"*+, .+.&$.'"! * . '$*'! #%$%"'! "% C!"+'.'34! F**$%( * 1.* "4!
)!* +!&$*$ (''%3*+ )!$ "!$%+ '"&$%/!"+'./'!"%'+, /!! >* !/!$$*"! /! %
'#"'%* +*:.%(, %$%>+ ! C'#! P*"%(
S*"! %++', *&*"*-+* 1.* ! /!"+*"'*"! >=('!, 1.%"! )$*+*"*
+*.+ $*1.'+'!+ *++*"/'%'+, +*$>* /!! &%!$ *+/%$%/*$'9%"* % %"'@.$''/'%*,
! *('! $=&'/! * )*++!%+ "% !%('%* )$!+'.'34!
S'.%34! *++% 1.* "4! )!*$'% "* +* 1.*$ +*$ %:%% * /$'*, .% >*9
1.* /!! @= '! %+ )%$*+ *">!(>'%+ "4! *+4! )$%'/%"! 1.%(1.*$ %!
'"/!"'9*"* /! ! '$*'! !. /! % $*%('%* +!/'%(
53
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 56/59
P!$, % (*+4!, 1.* >* +!&$*"! % '#"'%* +*:.%(, 1.* ! *
)$!*#'! "! *('! *+.%!, )!*$'% +*$ /!"+'*$%% /!! .% >'!(%34! %
'#"'%* % )*++!% 6.%"%, )!$ '"&$'"#'$ ! '$*'! < ('*$%* ! '"'>'.!
P%$% +!(./'!"%$ *++* '(*%, ! )!*$ (*#'+(%'>!, )!$ *'! * (*' !$'"=$'%,
)$**"/6*"! !+ $*1.'+'!+ &!$%'+ * %*$'%'+, *:)$*++!+ "% C!"+'.'34! F**$%(
* QQ, *>*$'% $*%('9%$ .% $*&!$% "% )%$* *+)*/'%( ! C'#! P*"%( B$%+'(*'$!,
* *+)*/'&'/! "!+ %$'#!+ 2 * 2-A, +*.+ )%$=#$%&!+ * '"/'+!+, )%++%"! % &%9*$
$*&*$;"/'% *:)$*++% %! /!"+*"'*"! >=('!, /!! *:/(.*"* % %"'@.$''/'%* !
*('! $=&'/! * )*++!%+, )%$% &'"+ * *:)(!$%34! +*:.%(
F%9*"! /*++%$, *+% &!$%, % >'!(%34! 1.* >* +!&$*"! % '#"'%* %
)*++!% 6.%"%, .% >*9 1.* ! !$*"%*"! @.$5'/! * . )%5+ * 1.*%/!)%"6%$ % *>!(.34! * )$**"/6*$ %+ "*/*++'%*+ * +*. )!>!
54
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 57/59
REFERÊNCIAS
BIANCHINI, A('/* T$=&'/! * )*++!%+ * (*' 20Y0 0 *9 200 D'+)!"5>*( * g6)7%$'"%*$(!/!2002$%&'/!-*-)*++!%+-*-(*'-20Y06( h A/*++!* 0 *9 200
BITENCOURT, C*9%$ R!*$! T$%%! * '$*'! )*"%(7 )%$* *+)*/'%( * [ >S4! P%.(!7 S%$%'>%, 200
T$%%! * '$*'! )*"%(7 )%$* #*$%( ] * S4! P%.(!7 S%$%'>%, 200
BRASIL. Código civil (2002). Código Civil Brasileiro. Brasília: Câmara dosDeputados, 2002.
__________. Código Penal (1940). Código Penal Brasileiro. Brasília: Câmara dosDeputados, 1940.
CAPEZ, F*$"%"! MARZA?ÃO J_NIOR, L%*$* I /!!K * %( T$=&'/! * )*++!%+S4! P%.(!7 .%$'*$ L%'", 200
C!"+.(%! ?*$%( !+ E+%!+ U"'!+ – S4! P%.(! B$%+'( S*/$*%$'% % J.+'3% /$'%! )$'*'$! *+/$'$'! * )$*>*"34! * /!%* %! $=&'/! * )*++!%+ ! )%5+D'+)!"5>*( * g 6)72*%':%%%*$'/%"%!$#$'"*:)6)d%/'!"o+%!)%.(!%*$'%)6)p'o2[]2p+.*".op'**".o]]h A/*++! *7 0 *9200
D*/$*! L*#'+(%'>! BRASIL P$*+';"/'% % R*)8('/% D*/$*! L*#'+(%'>! "a 2,* 2 * %'! * 200 A)$!>% ! P$!!/!(! A'/'!"%( < C!">*"34! %+ N%3*+U"'%+ C!"$% ! C$'* O$#%"'9%! T$%"+"%/'!"%( R*(%'>! < P$*>*"34!, R*)$*++4!* P."'34! ! T$=&'/! * P*++!%+, * E+)*/'%( M.(6*$*+ * C$'%"3%+D'+)!"5>*( *76)7/*'"/!$+'*)&(*#'+(%/%!$%%!+)$!!/!(!%'/'!"%(%/!">*"/%!%+"%/!*+."'%+/!"$%!/$'*!$#%"'9%!$%"+"%/'!"%()& A/*++! * 0 *9 200
?RECO, A(*++%"$% O$/*+' P*$! RASSI, J!4! D%"'*( C$'*+ /!"$% % '#"'%*+*:.%( S4! P%.(!7 A(%+, 200
O$/*+' P*$! MARZA?ÃO J_NIOR, L%*$* I /!!K * %( T$=&'/! *)*++!%+ S4! P%.(!7 .%$'*$ L%'", 200
?RECO, R!#$'! C.$+! * '$*'! )*"%(7 )%$* *+)*/'%( * > R'! * J%"*'$!7I)*.+, 200
C.$+! * '$*'! )*"%(7 )%$* #*$%( 2 * R'! * J%"*'$!7 I)*.+,200
?OMES, L.'+ F(=>'! C$'*+ /!"$% % '#"'%* +*:.%( * !.$%+ $*&!$%+ )*"%'+D'+)!"5>*( *7g6)7@.+$%+'(/!$"!'/'%+Q202/$'*+-/!"$%-%-'#"'%*-+*:.%(-*-!.$%+-$*&!$%+-)*"%'+ h A/*++! * 0 *9 200
55
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 58/59
JESUS, D%=+'! * D'$*'! )*"%(7 )%$* #*$%( * S4! P%.(!7 S%$%'>%, 200
qLE, L'"% D** T$%"+%34! )*"%(7 $*>'+4! /$5'/% < (.9 ! %/*++! < @.+'3%C.$''%7 J.$.=, 200
M'"'+$'! ! T$%%(6! * E)$*#! T$%%(6! *+/$%>! )*$#."%+ * $*+)!+%+D'+)!"5>*( *7 6)7*#!>$')$*"+%*&%.(%+) A/*++! *7 0Y * J."200
MIRABETE, J.('! F%$'"' FABBRINI, R*"%! N M%".%( * '$*'! )*"%(7 )%$*#*$%( 2] * S4! P.(!7 A(%+, 200 ) Q
NUCCI, ?.'(6*$* * S!.9% C'#! )*"%( /!*"%! * S4! P%.(!7 R*>'+%!+ T$'."%'+, 200
M%".%( * '$*'! )*"%(7 )%$* #*$%( * *+)*/'%( * S4! P%.(!7R*>'+% !+ T$'."%'+, 200
PEREIRA, ?(9'% N!#.*'$% C!!K T$=&'/! * )*++!%+ )%$% &'"+ * *:)(!$%34!+*:.%( P*$"%./!7 A++*)(%", 200Q
PIERAN?ELI, J!+ H*"$'1.* O /!"+*"'*"! ! !&*"'! "% *!$'% ! *('! * S4! P%.(!7 R*>'+% !+ T$'."%'+, 200
RIBEIRO, A"% B*('+% MARZA?ÃO J_NIOR, L%*$* I /!!K * %( T$=&'/! *)*++!%+ S4! P%.(!7 .%$'*$ L%'", 200
RIBEIRO, M%$/.+ V'"'/'.+ D'$*'!+ 6.%"!+ * &."%*"%'+ S4! P%.(!7 R.++*((,200
SANCHES, R!#$'! ?OMES, L.'9 F(=>'! /`!K %). FALEIROS, E D'$*'! )*"%()%$* *+)*/'%( S4! P%.(!7 RT, 200
SANTOS, M%.$'/'! M%/*! !+ SÊ?A, V'>'%"* A%$%( O /!"+*"'*"! !!&*"'! "% *!$'% ! *('! J.+ "%>'#%"' ) 2 !. 2000 D'+)!"5>*( * g6)7@.+.!(/!$$*>'+%*:!QQ!-/!"+*"'*"!-!-!&*"'!-"%-*!$'%-!-
*('!h A/*++! * 0 *9 200SIUEIRA, F(=>'! A.#.+! M%$*' D! /!"+*"'*"! ! !&*"'! J!$"%( J.$', S4!P%.(!, 0 @%" 200 D'+)!"5>*( * g6)7@!$"%(@.$'/!$%*$'%+"!'/'%+/!"+*"'*"!-!&*"'!h A/*++! *7 0*9 200
TOLEDO, F$%"/'+/! * A++'+ P$'"/5)'!+ =+'/!+ * '$*'! )*"%( Y * S4! P%.(!S%$%'>%, 200
VASCONCELOS, C!!K %). BERLIN?UER T$=&'/! * )*++!%+ P*$"%./!7
A++*)(%", 200
56
7/23/2019 Artigo-Completo-Edvaldo-Paulo.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/artigo-completo-edvaldo-paulopdf 59/59
VASCONCELOS, %$'"% N!#.*'$% C!!K T$=&'/! * )*++!%+ P*$"%./!7 A++*)(%", 200
VENOSA, S'(>'! * S%(>! D'$*'! /'>'( - )%$* #*$%( 0 * > S4! P%.(!7 A(%+,
200
jIIPcDIA, % *"/'/(!)'% ('>$* D!%34! * +%"#.* D'+)!"5>*( *7g6)7)'')*'%!$#''D!%kCkAkCkA!*+%"#.*h A/*++! *7 0Y @." 200
57