Post on 11-Feb-2018
7/23/2019 Contestao Ao Civil Pblica
1/33
G n`ahor tckbcg murfbcg go s`u gacgkc`+ HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+con
@XC@A@KVSSBNO S@KHOT FOPVOT MPB] FO VTGDGAHO FO VTGDGAHO F@
KOYG Y@KKCBG @S
\roc`sso k
Gutor= Nbkbstrbo \dabco fo Vrgdgaho
Tu=______________________________
Q........................! m qugabibcgfo koi`bto `n `pjrgi`! por n`bo f` s`u procurgfor bk ibk` gssbkgfo!qu` t`n `scrbtrbo Tug __________________________! v`nr`sp`btosgn`kt` p`rgkt` Yossg @xc`akcbg gpr`s`ktgr
COKV@SVGO
GO CBYBA \DABCG gmubzgfg p`ao Nbkbstrbo \dabco foVrgdgaho \rocurgforbg T`jbokga fo Vrgdgaho fg ________ T`jbo!
por bkt`rnfbo fg \rocurgforg fo Vrgdgaho m qugabibcgfg! p`aoss`jubkt`s igtos ` iukfgn`ktos murfbcos g s`jubr `xpostos=
B \T@ABNBKGT@S CGTKCBG FG GO
7 .Igatg f` bkt`r`ss` f` gjbr fo pgrqu`t
HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+con
Ygf`n`cun+okabk`Ljngba+con
http://var/www/apps/scribd/scribd/tmp/scratch9/HTTP://vademecumjuridico.blogspot.comhttp://var/www/apps/scribd/scribd/tmp/scratch9/HTTP://vademecumjuridico.blogspot.com7/23/2019 Contestao Ao Civil Pblica
2/33
G n`ahor tckbcg murfbcg go s`u gacgkc`+ HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+con@n qu` p`s` o `kt`kfbn`kto fg T`pr`s`ktgkt` fo
N\V! ko `xbst` bk cgsu! bkt`r`ss` f` gjbr cono gjorg s`f`nokstrg+
O proi`ssor Hund`rto Vh`oforo Mr+! `n sug odrg
Curso f` Fbr`bto \roc`ssuga Cbvba! Yoa+ B f`i`kf` qu`=
O bkt r`ss` proc`ssuga! g un s t`npo! hgv`r trgfuzbr.s` kung r`ago f`
k`c`ssbfgf` ` tgndn kung r`ago f` gf`qugo fo provbn`kto postuagfo! fbgkt`fo cokiabto f` fbr`bto ngt`rbga trgzbfo soauo mufbcbga+ N`sno qu` g pgrt` `st`mg kgbnbkkcbg f` soir`r un fgko `n s`u bkt`r`ss` ngt`rbga! ko s` pof` fbz`r qu` `xbstg obkt`r`ss` proc`ssuga! s` gqubao qu` s` r`cagng fo rjo mufbcbga ko s r tbamurbfbcgn`kt` pgrg `vbtgr g t`nbfg a`so+ pr`cbso s`npr` qu` o p`fbfo gpr`s`ktgfogo mubz trgfuzg iornuago gf`qugfg sgtbsigo fo bkt`r`ss` coktrgrbgfo! ko t`nbfo!ou torkgfo bkc`rto+
O bkt`r`ss` f` gjbr kgs f`ngkfgs coa`tbvgs!pgrt` fg a`jbtbnbfgf` g s`r v`rbibcgfg! f`v`.s` t`r c`rtgcgut`ag qugkto a`jbtbnbfgf` fo Nbkbstrbo \dabco! qu` pr`sun`
`st` bkt`r`ss` f` gjbr+ @stg pr`suko f`v`r s`r v`rbibcgfg `ncgfg cgso `sp`cibco! prbkcbpgan`kt` ko qu` tgkj` g k`c`ssbfgf`+
Ko `kt`kfbn`kto f`i`kfbfo `n sug odrg GoCbvba \dabcg! fo proi`ssor \`fro fg Sbavg Fbkgngrco=
(+++" sbtug`s cokcr`tgs pof`n f`nokstrgr qu` o r`suatgfof`s`mgfo pof` s`r gacgkgfo s`n g utbabzgo fo proc`sso + Gssbn! `v`ktuga pr`sukogdsoautg fo bkt`r`ss` f` gjbr j`rgrbg o rbsco f` ung hbp`rtroibg fg go cbvba pdabcg!
pr`cbsgn`kt` `n vbrtuf` fo s`u uso j`k`rgabzgfo ` bkfbscrbnbkgfo+(jk"
Fg gkabs` fos igtos torkg.s` icba gcokstgtgo f` qu` ko s` trgtg f` un jrgkf` agtbiukfbrbo ou`npr`jgfor r`juagr! r`bkcbf`kt` kg bkirgo fg a`jbsagotrgdgahbstg drgsba`brg+
HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+con
Ygf`n`cun+okabk`Ljngba+con
7/23/2019 Contestao Ao Civil Pblica
3/33
G n`ahor tckbcg murfbcg go s`u gacgkc`+ HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+con________________ gp`kgs un grr`kfgtrbo f`
ung p`qu`kg ja`dg f` 79 gaqu`br`s okf` crbg poucgs cgd`gs f`jgfo! cono gibrnou g prprbg coksort` fo `npr`jgfo Gf`asok f`Gan`bfg Cokc`bo! `n f`pobn`kto qu` s` `xtrgb fg prprbgbkbcbga fg pr`s`kt` go+
Cono vbsto gcbng kgs ab`s fos foutrbkgfor`s!o bkt`r`ss` f` gjbr! cono ung fgs cokfb`s fg go! s`cgrgct`rbzg p`ag pr`s`kg fo dbknbo k`c`ssbfgf`/utbabfgf`cono un fos r`qubsbtos f` gfnbssbdbabfgf` tut`agmurbsfbcbokga! ou s`mg! fg vbgdbabfgf` fg f`ngkfg+
Coksudstgkcbg.s` p`ag k`c`ssbfgf` fg pgrt`bkjr`ssgr `n muzo pgrg g odt`ko f` un d`n fg vbfg ` suggi`rbo s` igz p`ao cot`mo `ktr` os igtos f`cabkgfos` osp`fbfos iornuagfos+
S`jukfo os igtos kgrrgfos kg bkbcbga! kgspgagvrgs fg prprbg procurgforg qu` sudscr`v`u g Go Cbvba
\dabcg= +++ g sbtugo bkfbvbfuga fo trgdgahgfor Gf`asok t`r sbfo qugs` qu`conpa`tgn`kt` soaucbokgfg n`fbgkt` g gtugo fg STV@/@S (jrbio kosso"+
G prprbg STV@.@S ko gpabcou qugaqu`r sgkogfnbkbstrgtbvg! c`rtgn`kt` por `kt`kf`r qu`! ung v`zsgtbsigz`kfo tofgs gs `xbjkcbgs! o r`qu`rbfo ko f`v`rbg s`rp`kgabzgfo+
Vofgs gs provbfkcbgs `xbjbfgs p`ag STV@/@Siorgn ib`an`kt` tongfgs p`ao r`qu`rbfo! qu` pgjou tofgs gsv`rdgs r`scbsrbgs! provbf`kcbou o trgksport` fo s`u gt `ktoKBCO `npr`jgfo f` voatg sug cbfgf` f` orbj`n ` r`gabzou ggkotgo r`trogtbvg fg CV\S+
HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+con
Ygf`n`cun+okabk`Ljngba+con
7/23/2019 Contestao Ao Civil Pblica
4/33
G n`ahor tckbcg murfbcg go s`u gacgkc`+ HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+conGo coktrrbo fo qu` ga`jg g Foutg
T`pr`s`ktgkt` fo Nbkbstrbo \dabco fo Vrgdgaho! o r`qu`rbfof`nokstrou cgdgan`kt` o s`u r`sp`bto a`jbsago trgdgahbstg `fbjkbfgf` p`ssog hungkg go gt`kf`r proktgn`kt` s `xbjkcbgsfg STV@/@S! bkcausbv` provbf`kcbgkfo s sugs `xp`ksgs! g nufgkgfo `x.`npr`jgfo sug cbfgf`! cono ngkfg g a`b+
Ch`jg.s`! portgkto! cokcauso fg guskcbg f`cokfbo fg go kg nofgabfgf` k`c`ssbfgf` d`n cono utbabfgf`!m qu`! t`kfo o r`qu`rbfo tongfo tofgs gs provbfkcbgs pgrg gr`pgrgo fgs brr`juagrbfgf`s `kcoktrgfgs! irbs`.s`! COKVTG S@PKBCO @N\T@JGFO! ko `xbst` g k`c`ssbfgf` f` s` socorr`r fo@stgfo.Mubz pgrg o ibn f` gacgkgr n`fbfgs qu`! f` iorng`spoktk`g! cokiorn` prprbg ga`jgo fo N\V! m iorgn tongfgs+
Vofo o p`fbfo fo gutor s` dgs`bg kgs`v`ktugbs iuturgs coktrgtg`s fo ru! coktufo! cono m
f`scrbto ` cgdgan`kt` f`nokstrgfo! `st` ko `npr`jgfor kg r`gagc`po fg pgagvrg! ngs to son`kt` f` p`qu`ko crbgfor f` jgfoqu` p`ag prbn`brg v`z `i`tuou g coktrgtgo f` vgqu`bro pgrggmufg.ao+
C`rtgn`kt` qu` go r`qu`rbfo ko fgfo ofbr`bto f` ga`jgr f`scokh`cbn`kto fg a`b! coktufo! ko cgso `nt`ag! ko `xbst` fgko g s`r r`ssgrcbfo ou brr`juagrbfgf` g s`rsgkgfg! `bs qu` m iorgn provbf`kcbgfgs p`ao r`qu`rbfo cokiorn`r`qubsbtgfo p`ag STV@/@S+
4 Fg ba`jbtbnbfgf` gtbvg gf cgusgn
O Nbkbstrbo \dabco fo Vrgdgaho ga`joua`jbtbnbfgf` gtbvg con dgs` kg AC :0/7223! grt 742 fg CI ` A`b:+36:/80! grtbjo 7! bkcbso BY! pgrg f`i`sg prbnrbg fg orf`nmurfbcg ` s`cukfrbg fos fbr`btos fbiusos! coa`tbvos `
HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+con
Ygf`n`cun+okabk`Ljngba+con
7/23/2019 Contestao Ao Civil Pblica
5/33
G n`ahor tckbcg murfbcg go s`u gacgkc`+ HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+conbkfbvbfugbs honojk`os+ @n qu` p`s` g grjun`ktgo fg baustr`r`pr`s`ktgkt` fo N\V! `stg ko f`v` prosp`rgr! ung v`z qu` kos` vbsaundrg ko cgso! fbr`btos coa`tbvos! fbiusos ou honojk`osg s`r`n f`i`kfbfos+
O grtbjo 742! bkcbso BBB! fg Cokstbtubo fgT`pdabcg! go cokibgr go rjo fo Nbkbstrbo \dabco gpr`rrojgtbvg f` propor go cbvba pdabcg! gssbn o i`z kg f`i`sgfos bkt`r`ss`s fbiusos ` coa`tbvos+ F` bjuga nofo! g A`bConpa`n`ktgr k :0/23! bjugan`kt` gpabcv`a kg s`grgtrgdgahbstg! `n s`u grtbjo 9! bkcbso YBB! gak`g f! fbsp` qu`go Nbkbstrbo \dabco bkcund` propor go cbvba pdabcg pgrg gprot`o f` outros bkt`r`ss`s bkfbvbfugbs bkfbspokv`bs!honojk`os! socbgbs! fbiusos ` coa`tbvos+
O N\V gibrng pr`t`kf`r tut`agr os fbr`btostrgksbkfbvbfugbs ou n`tgbkfbvbfugbs! r`agtbvgn`kt` gos fbr`btos
bkfbspokv`bs fos trgdgahgfor`s `i`tbvos ou `n pot`kcbga for`qu`rbfo+
S`jukfo abo fos Nbkbstros fg Suds`o B@sp`cbgabzgfg `n Fbssfbos Bkfbvbfugbs fo Vrbdukga Sup`rbor foVrgdgaho! `xgrgfg ko \roc`sso k VSV.@.TT.029+730/22+
(+++" O grtbjo 742! bkcbso BBB! fg Cokstbtubo fg T`pdabcg! go
cokibgr go rjo fo Nbkbstrbo \dabco g pr`rrojgtbvg f` propor go cbvba pdabcg!
gssbn o i`z kg f`i`sg fos bkt r`ss`s fbiusos ` coa tbvos + F` bjuga nofo! g A`b
Conpa`n`ktgr k :0/23! bjugan`kt` gpabcv`a kg s`grg trgdgahbstg! `n s`u grtbjo 9!
bkcbso YBB! gak`g f! fbsp` qu` go Nbkbstrbo \dabco bkcund` propor go cbvba
pdabcg pgrg g prot`o f` outros bkt`r`ss`s bkfbvbfugbs bkfbspokv`bs! honojk`os!
socbgbs! fbiusos coa`tbvos+
Gp`sgr fg r i`rkcbg coktbfg kg korng `n gpr`o! g r`jrg
f`stbkgfg go Nbkbstrbo \dabco `n j`rga! o fg Pkbo! ngbs gdrgkj`kt`! portgkto+
HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+con
Ygf`n`cun+okabk`Ljngba+con
7/23/2019 Contestao Ao Civil Pblica
6/33
G n`ahor tckbcg murfbcg go s`u gacgkc`+ HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+conS`rbg pgrgfoxga cokc d`r s`u gacgkc` qu`a`s i`btos f` kgtur`zg trgdgahbstg+ G
`st`s! g A`b Conpa`n`ktgr k :0/23 f`u kort` prprbo! r`strbtbvo+
Con `i`bto! o grtbjo 83! bkcbso BBB! fg korng conpa`n`ktgr! go trgtgr
fg conp`tkcbg fo Nbkbstrbo \dabco fo Vrgdgaho! abnbtou g pronoo f` go cbvba
pdabcg! ko ndbto fg Mustbg fo Vrgdgaho! `xcausbvgn`kt`! pgrg g f`i`sg f`
bkt`r`ss`s coa`tbvos+
G gtugo fo Nbkbstrbo \dabco fo Vrgdgaho! bk cgsu! gchg.s`abnbtgfg+Ko s` trgtg f` f`i`kf`r bkt`r`ss`s coa`tbvos ! porqu` `ss` gacgkc` o igto
j`rgfor f`stg go ko possub+ O coa`tbvo qu` gfm`tbvg os bkt`r`ss`s g `ks`mgr g
go cbvba pdabcg ko ndbto trgdgahbstg ngbs gnpao! ko s`ktbfo f` cgt`jorbg+(jrbi`b"
Ko s` pr`t`kfg! f` bjuga sort`! cokiukfbr o Nbkbstrbo \dabco fg
Pkbo (jk`ro" fo Nbkbstrbo \dabco fo Vrgdgaho (`spcb "! ko qu` tgkj`
conp`tkcbg+ G A`b Conpa`n`ktgr k :0/23! `n qu` p`s` ko rgro s`r f`sigvor`cbfg
f` n`ahor tckbcg a`jbsagtbvg! fotou o Nbkbstrbo \dabco fg Pkbo (jk`ro" f` un
gfnbrv`a `a`kco f` conp`tkcbgs+ I.ao gc`rtgfgn`kt`+
Ngs! ko qu` s` r`i`r` go Nbkbstrbo \dabco fo Vrgdgaho (`spcb`"!
`sp`cbibcou ` `xpabcbtou cagrgn`kt` sug gdrgkjkcbg `! por coroarbo! r`strbkjbu sug
gtugo+ Aojo! bkcgdv`a p`ag vbg mufbcbga `st`kf`r.ah` g gdrgkjkcbg! ung v`z qu`
ko o i`z o a`jbsagfor bkirgcokstbtucbokga+
Os bkt r`ss`s bkfbvbfugbs honojk`os ko `sto bkscrbtos kg
pr`vbso a`jga r`strbtbvg fo grtbjo 83! bkcbso BBB! fg AC :0/23+ F` bjuga sort`!
qugkfo trgtg fos bkt`r`ss`s bkfbvbfugbs bkfbspokv`bs! abnbtou o pgp`a
prot`tor fo Nbkbstrbo \dabco fo Vrgdgaho s kuabfgf`s f` causuags f`
korng coa`tbvg gutokongn`kt` crbgfgs (grt+ 83! BY"5 qugkfo qubs s`r
ngbs `sp`cibcg! ` trgtou bsoagfgn`kt` f` f`t`rnbkgfos sum`btos! i.ao
f` nofo tgndn r`strbtbvo= n`kor`s! bkcgpgz`s ` kfbos (grt+ 83! Y"+
G hbpt`s` f`st`s gutos ko a`jbtbng o Nbkbstrbo \dabco fo
Vrgdgaho pgrg g pr`s`kt` go+ Ko s` cubfg f` bkt r`ss`s coa`tbvos (grt+ 83!BBB"!
k`n f` fbr`btos bkfbvbfugbs bkfbspokv`bs vboagfos por korng coa`tbvg (grt+ 83! BY"!
k`n f` n`kor`s! bkcgpgz`s ` kfbos (grt+ 83! Y"+
HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+con
Ygf`n`cun+okabk`Ljngba+con
7/23/2019 Contestao Ao Civil Pblica
7/33
G n`ahor tckbcg murfbcg go s`u gacgkc`+ HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+con
N`sno qu` s` gc`bt` g a`jbtbnbfgf` foNbkbstrbo \dabco fo Vrgdgaho pgrg tut`agr os fbr`btoscoa`tbvos bk agtu s`ksu! s`kfo `a`s os fbr`btos coa`tbvos!fbiusos ou bkfbvbfugbs honojk`os! ko s` vbsaundrg s`qu`r trgofg oi`ksg g fbr`btos trgksbkfbvbfugbs! cono pr`t`kf` conprovgr oNbkbstrbo \dabco fo Vrgdgaho+
Bkt`r`ss`s fbiusos so gqu`a`s qu` gdrgkj`nkn`ro bkf`t`rnbkgfo f` p`ssogs ukbfgs p`ags n`sngscbrcukstkcbgs f` igto! o qu` ko s` vbsaundrg ko cgso+
M os fbr`btos coa`tbvos! por sug v`z! sogqu`a`s p`rt`kc`kt`s g jrupos! cgt`jorbgs ou cagss`s f` p`ssogsf`t`rnbkv`bs! abjgfgs `ktr` sb ou con g pgrt` coktrrbg por ungr`ago murfbcg dgs`+ Fbr`btos ou bkt`r`ss`s honojk`os so osqu` tn g n`sng orbj`n conun (grt+ 87! BBB! fg A`b k 8+
7/23/2019 Contestao Ao Civil Pblica
8/33
G n`ahor tckbcg murfbcg go s`u gacgkc`+ HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+consudungkgs! s`n r`c`dbn`kto f` sgarbo ` ngktbfos conov`rfgf`bros r`iks kg proprb`fgf` fo `xpaorgfor `coknbco+
@n cgfg un fos cgsos okf` gtuou o N\V! s`mg kgf`i`sg f` bkt`r`ss`s fbiusos ` coa`tbvos! s`mg kg f`i`sg f`bkt`r`ss`s n`tgbkfbvbfugbs `n j`rga! s`npr` `xbstbg un igtor `nconun= g paurgabfgf` f` `npr`jgfos a`sgfos+ f`stg paurgabfgf`f` `npr`jgfos qu` kgsc` o bnpgcto socbga fos bacbtostrgdgahbstgs+
S` tga paurgabfgf` ko ioss` cokfbtbo sbk` qugkok pgrg g gi`rbo fg r`p`rcusso socbga fo igto! o Nbkbstrbo\dabco fo Vrgdgaho t`rbg g odrbjgo! f`corr`kt` fo prprbonukus pdabco qu` `x`rc`! f` gv`rbjugr g cgfg r`cagngotrgdgahbstg! k`n qu` ioss` coktrg ung sbnpa`s fokg f` cgsg qu`coktrgtou `npr`jgfg fonstbcg! o bnpgcto qu` o ko pgjgn`kto f`un fbr`bto trgdgahbstg troux` socb`fgf`+
H f` s` t`r cgut`ag go f`ibkbr g a`jbtbnbfgf`gtbvg fo Nbkbstrbo \dabco fo Vrgdgaho! kg tut`ag fos fbr`btosbkfbvbfugbs bkfbspokv`bs! pobs! auz fo Fbr`bto fo Vrgdgaho!tofos os fbr`btos agdorgbs so f` kgtur`zg bkfbspokv`a+
F`cbfbr p`ag a`jbtbnbfgf` gtbvg fo pgrqu`t `ng`s cono g pr`s`kt`! `n qu` t`nos f` un agfo un `npr`jgfor`sporfbco ` fo outro un `npr`jgfo a`sgfo! trgr un pr`c`f`kt`p`rbjoso! ch`jgkfo go gdsurfo f` s` gutorbzgr g`s cbvbs
pdabcgs `n tofg r`cagngo trgdgahbstg novbfg por igatg f`gkotgo kg CV\S ou pgjgn`kto f` irbgs ` outros fbr`btos`stgd`a`cbfos ko grtbjo : fg Cokstbtubo I`f`rga+
Cgso gkaojo! s`rbg p`rnbtbr gopgrqu`tpr`t`kf`r bkf`kbzgo p`rgkt` tofg g socb`fgf`! f`vbfo gko pgjgn`kto f` irbgs ou cokc`sso f` abc`kg ngt`rkbfgf`
HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+con
Ygf`n`cun+okabk`Ljngba+con
7/23/2019 Contestao Ao Civil Pblica
9/33
G n`ahor tckbcg murfbcg go s`u gacgkc`+ HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+con`npr`jgfg fonstbcg! por `x`npao+ O Nbkbstrbo \dabco s` v`rbg`kto a`jbtbngfo ` odrbjgfo g f`i`kf`r os fbr`btostrgksbkfbvbfugbs f` tofg g cagss` f` `npr`jgfos fonstbcos qu`puf`ss`n porv`kturg! s`r `npr`jgfos por gqu`ag f`t`rnbkgfg`npr`jgforg ou `npr`jgfor+
Sgatg gos oahos o gdsurfo ` g igatg f`rgzogdbabfgf` fo `x`npao gcbng cbtgfo! qu` ko fbi`r`kt` fgpr`s`kt` sbtugo+
Ko `xbst`! ko cgso! fbr`btos n`tgbkfbvbfugbsg s`r`n r`sjugrfgfos+ @xbstbrgn brr`juagrbfgf`s qu` iorgnproktgn`kt` sgkgfgs p`ao r`qu`rbfo `n t`npo f`t`rnbkgfo p`agSTV@+ Ko s` pof` bkt`ktgr f`i`kf`r fbr`btos coa`tbvos fosIPVPTOS @ @Y@KVPGBS \OV@KCBGBS @N\T@JGFOS! f`nokstrgfo o tbpo f`gtbvbfgf` `x`rcbfg p`ao p`qu`ko grr`kfgtrbo! qu` s`qu`r possubpostos f` trgdgaho g s`r`n ocupgfos ou oi`r`cbfos+
BB . NTBVO
Gf grjun`ktgkfun tgktun! `n ko s` gcoah`kfogs pr`abnbkgr`s org gfuzbfgs! pgssgnos g gkabs` fg ngtrbgn`rbtrbg! kg quga o gutor bjugan`kt` ko coktg con n`ahorsort`+
7 Fo r`jbstro ` gssbkgturg f` CV\S fos trgdgahgfor`s ko prgzo a`jga +
O Nbkbstrbo \dabco pa`bt`bg! `n s`f` f`tut`ag bkbdbtrbg! qu` o r`qu`rbfo s`mg cokf`kgfo `n odrbjgof` igz`r g `i`tugr g gssbkgturg fg CV\S f` tofos os s`us`npr`jgfos gtugbs ` iuturos! cokiorn` f`t`rnbkg o grtbjo 42 ` 67fg CAV+
HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+con
Ygf`n`cun+okabk`Ljngba+con
7/23/2019 Contestao Ao Civil Pblica
10/33
G n`ahor tckbcg murfbcg go s`u gacgkc`+ HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+conFgtg vkbg trgtg.s` f` un p`fbfo pgt`tbcgn`kt`
bkcuo! ung v`z qu` g sbtugo fo `npr`jgfo `n qu`sto iobgdsoautgn`kt` r`soavbfg+ G cgrt`brg fo `npr`jgfo `n qu`sto iobf`vbfgn`kt` gkotgfg! bkcausbv` r`trogtbvgn`kt` fgtg f` sugcoktrgtgo+
Ko `xbst`n `npr`jgfos gtugbs g s`r`nd`k`ibcbgfos p`ao pr`s`kt` p`fbfo+ O `npr`jgfo g qu` onbkbstrbo \dabco s` r`i`r` `n sug bkbcbga `rg o KBCO`npr`jgfo fo p`qu`ko grr`kfgtrbo+
Ko s` pr`t`kf` gqub bnpabcgr ko f`scgdbn`ktofg gtugo fopgrqu`tgtrgvs f` tut`ag bkbdbtrbg+ Coktufo! tgagtugo abnbtgfg r`bkcbfkcbg ko bacbto trgdgahbstg ou p`aon`kos kg jrgkf` prodgdbabfgf` f` sug ocorrkcbg+ Vgbs hbpt`s`socorr`n! por `x`npao! kos cgsos f` `npr`sgs ou n`sno `npr`srbosbkfbvbfugbs qu` `npr`jgn vrbos trgdgahgfor`s+ Cono sug
gtbvbfgf` aucrgtbvg sbnpa`sn`kt` ko pof` s`r `x`rcbfg s`n gcoktrgtgo f` no.f`.odrg! `xbst` ung jrgkf` prodgdbabfgf` qu`o bacbto v`khg g ocorr`r kovgn`kt`+
Gfnbtbr ung tut`ag bkbdbtrbg ko pr`s`kt`cgso! f` p`qu`ko grr`kfgtrbo qu` son`kt` t`v` o vgqu`broGf`asok cono `npr`jgfo! s`rbg o n`sno qu` p`rnbtb.ag `n tofos gsr`cagng`s trgdgahbstgs f` tofgs gs Ygrgs fo Vrgdgaho fo pgs+
Wugaqu`r `npr`jgfor! n`sno o `npr`jgfor
fonstbco! qu` t`khg coktrg sb ung r`cagngo trgdgahbstg porigatg f` gkotgo fg CV\S! pof`r ibjurgr con ru `n go cbvbapdabcg vbsgkfo g tut`ag bkbdbtrbg kos noaf`s `n qu` pr`t`kf` gbaustr` procurgforg fo Nbkbstrbo \dabco+
Cono gc`rtgfgn`kt` fbsps o nbkbstrbo \dabcokg bkbcbga! g odrbjgtorb`fgf` f` gkotgo kg CV\S `st pr`vbstg
HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+con
Ygf`n`cun+okabk`Ljngba+con
7/23/2019 Contestao Ao Civil Pblica
11/33
G n`ahor tckbcg murfbcg go s`u gacgkc`+ HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+conkg Coksoabfgo fgs A`bs fo Vrgdgaho `! portgkto! ko hgv`kfo gr`bkcbfkcbg ou g prodgdbabfgf` f` ocorrkcbg f`stg! g n`fbfgko pgssg f` pr`t`kso f` cokibrngo f` a`jbsago m `nvbjor ` con odrbjgtorb`fgf` dvbg+
Ngbs ung v`z! cgd` gqub o don s`kso fogpabcgfor fo Fbr`bto pgrg coks`jubr gpabcgr g a`trg furg fg a`b` fos proc`fbn`ktos proc`ssugbs go cgso cokcr`to! `vbtgkfo qu` ggo cbvba pdabcg s` trgksiorn` `n ung pgkgcbg! qu` ngbspr`mufbcgr . con o gdgrrotgn`kto fgs Ygrgs Vrgdgahbstgs . foqu` d`k`ibcbgr g coa`tbvbfgf`! kg tut`ag f` s`us fbr`btostrgksbkfbvbfugbs+
4 Fo f`psbto n`ksga fo IJVS ` r`coahbn`kto f` coktrbdub`spr`vbf`kcbrbgs+
O Nbkbstrbo \dabco r`qu`r `n s`f` f` tut`ag
bkbdbtrbg! qu` o r`qu`rbfo s` gdst`khg f` ko r`gabzgr of`psbto fo IJVS kg iorng fg A`b 8Cono m r`ssgatgfo bkn`rgs v`z`s! o cgsov`rsg sodr` coktrgtgo kbcg f` un vgqu`bro! por p`qu`kogrr`kfgtrbo pgrg ngk`mo f` poucgs cgd`gs f` jgfo+ Ko s`trgtg f` `npr`sg con vrbos iukcbokrbos ou f` jrgkf` profutorrurga qu` pgrg f`s`kvoav`r sug gtbvbfgf` aucrgtbvg!odrbjgtorbgn`kt` t`n qu` s` vga`r f` no.f`.odrg coktrgtgfg+
Ko `xbst` r`bkcbfkcbg k`n tgnpoucoprodgdbabfgf` f` r`bkcbfkcbg fo bacbto trgdgahbstg+
HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+con
Ygf`n`cun+okabk`Ljngba+con
7/23/2019 Contestao Ao Civil Pblica
12/33
G n`ahor tckbcg murfbcg go s`u gacgkc`+ HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+conO r`qu`rbfo r`coah`u tofo o vgaor f`vbfo g
ttuao IJVS! bkcausbv` nuatg r`scbsrbg f` 6
7/23/2019 Contestao Ao Civil Pblica
13/33
G n`ahor tckbcg murfbcg go s`u gacgkc`+ HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+conKo `xbst`n trgdgahgfor`s gtugbs! portgkto g
n`fbfg ngbs ung v`z s` nostrg s`n utbabfgf`+ Gc`btgr gnovbn`ktgo fo Nbkbstrbo \dabco pgrg prot`j`r ungcoa`tbvbfgf` igktgsng gc`btgr sug novbn`ktgo g cgfgr`cagngo trgdgahbstg bsoagfg! okf` pgrg `vbtgr qu` or`cagngkt` bkirbkmg kovgn`kt` g a`jbsago trgdgahbstg! ah` s`mgbnp`abfg ung odrbjgo f` igz`r+
Bk`xbst`kt` bk cgsu g r`bkcbfkcbg ou n`sno gprodgdbabfgf` f`stg! qu` gutorbzgrbg g bkt`rv`ko fopgrqu`t+
6 Fo `xgn` nfbco gfnbssbokga
O N\ r`qu`r`u tut`ag bkbdbtrbg g ibn f` odrbjgr or`qu`rbfo g r`gabzgr `xgn` gfnbssbokga! pgrg gs gtugbs ` iuturgscoktrgtg`s! g rbjor fg KT : ` grtbjo 798 fg CAV+
Gqub! kovgn`kt` g procurgforg fo N\V pa`bt`bgtut`ag bkbdbtrbg `n igvor f` trgdgahgfor`s qu` sbnpa`sn`kt` ko`xbst`n' Irbs`.s`= o vgqu`bro Gf`asok `rg o prbn`bro ` kbco`npr`jgfo fo r`qu`rbfo! notbvo p`ao quga g pr`s`kt` tut`ag s` nostrgvgzbg f` utbabfgf` ` k`c`ssbfgf`+
Yrbgs so gs r`cagng`s trgdgahbstgs propostgskgs Ygrgs fo Vrgdgaho! okf` o r`cagngkt` ga`jg gcbf`kt` f` trgdgaho ouA@T (a`so por `sioro r`p`tbtbvo"! pr`t`kf`kfo g sug cokibjurgo f`pagko f`vbfo guskcbg f` `xgn` gfnbssbokga i`btg p`ao r`cagngfo+ @n
k`khun fos cgsos! v`rbibcg.s` g gtugo fo Nbkbstrbo \udabco `nf`i`sg fos f`ngbs `npr`jgfos ou n`sno fos `npr`jgfos `n pot`kcbga!
pa`bt`gkfo tut`ag bkbdbtrbg `n s`f` f` odrbjgo f` igz`r+
Kgfg ngbs co`r`kt`+ @n s` a`jbtbngkfo `coks`q`kt`n`kt` odrbjgkfo o Nbkbstrbo \dabco g gjbr k`st`s cgsos!
cgusgrbg ung v`rfgf`brg hbp`rtroibg ` dgkgabzgo fg Go Cbvba
HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+con
Ygf`n`cun+okabk`Ljngba+con
7/23/2019 Contestao Ao Civil Pblica
14/33
G n`ahor tckbcg murfbcg go s`u gacgkc`+ HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+con\dabcg! qu` s`rvbrbg gp`kgs pgrg bkiagr o m to sodr`cgrr`jgfoMufbcbrbo Vrgdgahbstg! con g`s gdsoautgn`kt` f`sk`c`ssrbgs+
Ko `xbst` r`bkcbfkcbg' Ko `xbstbu p`kgabfgf`gpabcgfg p`ag STV@/@S' Ko `xbst`n postos f` trgdgaho g pr``kch`r `gssbn s`kfo ko `xbst` prodgdbabfgf` f` r`bkcbfkcbg'
F`stg i`btg! ngbs ung v`z f`scgdbfg g pr`t`kso fo
pgrqu`t! ko pr`s`kt` cgso+
0 Fo f`scunprbn`kto fgs korngs f` n`fbcbkg ` s`jurgkg fo trgdgaho KT 37
S`jukfo ga`jg`s fo Nbkbstrbo \dabco! or`qu`rbfo bkirbkjbu fbsposbtbvos fg KT 37! portgrbg 89/4
7/23/2019 Contestao Ao Civil Pblica
15/33
G n`ahor tckbcg murfbcg go s`u gacgkc`+ HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+conKo `xbst` sup`fk`o itbco ou murfbco pgrg
odrbjgr o r`qu`rbfo g ngkt`r un gaomgn`kto kos t`rnos fg KT 37!cokiorn` pa`bt`bg o Nbkbstrbo \dabco fo Vrgdgaho+ O r`qu`rbfo ko `npr`jgfor hgdbtuga ` por opo p`ssoga! f`pobs fg f`sgstrosg`xp`rbkcbg! m f`cbfbu `n prov`r p`ssogan`kt` o ngk`mo fg proprb`fgf`grr`kfgfg+
Png v`z qu` ko `xbst` g prodgdbabfgf` f` kovg
bkirbkjkcbg fg korng trgdgahbstg ` nubto n`kos r`bkcbfkcbg! ko hf` s` igagr `n cokc`sso f` tut`ag bkbdbtrbg! g ibn f` gss`jurgrcunprbn`kto f` a`b! qu` m `n vbjor ` fotgfg f` conpuasorb`fgf`+
9 Fg bkocorrkcbg fo trgdgaho f`jrgfgkt` `n f`corrkcbg fof`sr`sp`bto KT 37
G r`pr`s`ktgkt` fo Nbkbstrbo \dabco ga`jg qu``rgn pr`crbgs gs cokfb`s fo aocga utbabzgfo cono norgfbg p`aotrgdgahgfor ` sug ignabg! r`p`tbkfo fbv`rsgs v`z`s grjun`ktos sodr` gguskcbg f` cgngs! grnrbos ` f` r`v`stbn`kto fo cho fg cozbkhg+
Dgs`bg kbcg ` `xcausbvgn`kt` kgs cokfb`s fobnv`a! g igatg f` jgrgktbg f` un pgtgngr nkbno f` fbjkbfgf` `f`jrgfgo fo n`bo gndb`kt` f` trgdgaho ` ignbabgr! qugabibcgkfo otrgtgn`kto fbsp`ksgfo p`ao r`qu`rbfo pgrg con o s`u KBCO `npr`jgforcono f`sungko ` f`jrgfgkt`+
Org! NN Mubz! `xbst` un v`rfgf`bro gdbsno `ktr`
trgtgn`kto f`sungko ` sbnpa`s f`sod`fbkcbg f` un ou fobs bt`ks f` ungKT ou \ortgrbg' G fbjkssbng r`pr`s`ktgkt` fo N\V iob d`n `kitbcg go
r`ssgatgr gs supostgs igahgs con`tbfgs p`ao r`qu`rbfo! ngs`strgkhgn`kt` `squ`c`u.s` f` n`kcbokgr qu` ko n`sno aocgasupostgn`kt` bksgaudr` ` gdsoautgn`kt` bkgdbtv`a! `xbstbg VYcoaorbfg con gkt`kg pgrgdabcg! iojo g js! auz `atrbcg! jug`kcgkgfg ` j`agf`brg'
HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+con
Ygf`n`cun+okabk`Ljngba+con
7/23/2019 Contestao Ao Civil Pblica
16/33
G n`ahor tckbcg murfbcg go s`u gacgkc`+ HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+conKo pgr`c` crv`a qu` s` possg qugabibcgr g sbnpa`s
guskcbg f` grnrbos ou r`v`stbn`kto fo pbso fg cozbkhg! cono sbtugof`jrgfgkt` ou f`sungkg+ Gabs! cgso s`mg `st` o `kt`kfbn`kto fopr`s`kt` muzo! cunpr` sgab`ktgr qu` o prprbo r`qu`rbfo vbv` `ncokfb`s f`sungkgs ung v`z qu` g cgsg s`f` ko `n kgfg n`ahor foqu` g qu` iob ocupgfg p`ao s`u `npr`jgfo+
G KT 37 `n s`u bt`n 37+43 fo quga s` `xtrg`n os
bt`ks cbtgfos p`ao N\V! trgtg f` r`g f` Ybvkcbg ko cgso f` ir`kt` f`trgdgahgfor`s rurgbs! ou s`mg! ko cgso f` coktrgtgo f` vrbostrgdgahgfor`s pgrg coah`btg ou outro s`rvbo t`nporrbo+
S`jukfo o bt`n 37+43+7 fg r`i`rbfg KT37 o`npr`jgfor rurga ou `qubpgrgfo f`v` fbspokbdbabzgr gos trgdgahgfor`s
r`gs f` vbvkcbg conpostgs f`=
g" bkstgag`s sgkbtrbgs5 (C > 737+367. 737+364.8/B3"
c" gaomgn`ktos! qugkfo houv`r p`rngkkcbg f` trgdgahgfor`s ko`stgd`a`cbn`kto kos p`rofos `ktr` gs morkgfgs f` trgdgaho5 (C >737+363.9/B3"
f" aocga gf`qugfo pgrg pr`pgro f` gabn`ktos5 (C > 737+366.6/B3"
`" agvgkf`rbgs5 (C > 737+360.4/B3"
Aojo gps go r`i`rbfo bt`n! g KT igz r`i`rkcbg gtofos os r`qubsbtos fgs bkstgag`s sgkbtrbgs! aocgbs pgrg r`i`bo!gaomgn`ktos! aocga pgrg pr`pgro f` gabn`ktos ` agvgkf`rbgs+
Son`kt` ko bt`n 37+43+77! gbkfg f`ktro fo gsp`ctovbvkcbg! ngs conpa`tgn`kt` iorg fo ndbto GT@G F@ YBYKCBG! g KT 37`stgd`a`c` os r`qubsbtos pgrg NOTGFBGS+
S` gt`ktgrnos d`n pgrg o qu` fbz g KT 37 `n s`ubt`n 37+43+77 v`r`nos qu`! g rbjor! o r`qu`rbfo ko f`scunprbu k`khun
fos r`qubsbtos pgrg gNOTGFBGf` `npr`jgfo rurga! s`ko v`mgnos=
HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+con
Ygf`n`cun+okabk`Ljngba+con
7/23/2019 Contestao Ao Civil Pblica
17/33
G n`ahor tckbcg murfbcg go s`u gacgkc`+ HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+con
g" cgpgcbfgf` fbn`ksbokgfg pgrg ung ignabg= ko`xbst` r`juagn`ktgo fo qu` s`mg `ssgcgpgcbfgf` fbn`ksbokgfg+ G r`sbfkcbg ocupgfgp`ao vgqu`bro coktrgtgfo ` sug ignabg! ko
ngbor ou n`ahor fo qu` g cgsg s`f`+
d" \gr`f`s cokstrufgs `n ngf`brg ou gav`kgrbg=tofgs gs pgr`f`s `rgn cokstrufgs `n
gav`kgrbg+c" \bsos f` ngt`rbga r`sbst`kt` ` agvv`a= o
kbco cnofo qu` `rg f` cho dgtbfo cokiorn`s` f`spr`kf` fg prprbg bkbcbga! `rg gcozbkhg+ Vofo o r`sto fg norgfbg tbkhg pbsor`v`stbfo f` cbn`kto (furv`a ` agvv`a porkgtur`zg"
f" Cokfb`s sgkbtrbgs gf`qugfgs= g norgfbg `rgfotgfg f` dgkh`bro+ Ko `xbstbg igatg f`
cod`rturg fo dgkh`bro! ngs gp`kgs o igto f`qu` ung fgs t`ahgs f` gnbgkto `stgvg qu`drgfg
kg agt`rga! gajo qu` s`rbg igcban`kt`corrbjbfo+
`" Y`ktbago ` baunbkgo suibcb`kt`s= gnorgfbg `rg fotgfg f` mgk`ags ` portgs ` tbkhg
auz `atrbcg+
i" Cod`rturg cgpgz f` proporcbokgr prot`ocoktrg bkt`nprb`s= g norgfbg `rg cod`rtg por
t`ahgfo `n gnbgkto qu` gp`sgr f` ko s`r unfos ngbs r`sbst`kt`s! proporcbokgvg p`ri`btg
prot`o coktrg chuvgs ` qugaqu`r outro tbpof` bkt`nprb`+
j" \oo ou cgbxg f` jug prot`jbfo coktrgcoktgnbkgo= g cgsg coktgvg bkcausbv` conjug `kcgkgfg ` dgkh`bro+
h" Iossgs sptbcgs! qugkfo ko houv`r r`f` f``sjoto gigstgfgs fg cgsg ` fo poo f` jug! `naujgr abvr` f` `kch`kt`s ` g musgkt` fo poo=cono m fbto! g norgfbg `rg gpgr`ahgfg condgkh`bro+
HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+con
Ygf`n`cun+okabk`Ljngba+con
7/23/2019 Contestao Ao Civil Pblica
18/33
G n`ahor tckbcg murfbcg go s`u gacgkc`+ HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+con
Gs `xbjkcbgs qugkto g cgngs ` grnrbos pgrg jugrfgf` p`rt`kc`s so r`i`r`kt`s go bt`n 37+43+0 qu` trgtg f` GAOMGN@KVOS!qu` gndb`kt` coa`tbvo fbspokbdbabzgfo p`ao `npr`jgfor pgrg p`rkobt`fos fbv`rsos trgdgahgfor`s rurgbs f` ung f`t`rnbkgfg proprb`fgf`+
Org NN+ Mubz! s` o prprbo Nbkbstrbo foVrgdgaho fbi`r`kcbou norgfbg f` gaomgn`kto! `stgd`a`c`kfor`qubsbtos nkbnos fbi`r`kt`s pgrg `a`s! ko cgd` foutg\rocurgforg br gan fgs sugs gtrbdub`s bkstbtucbokgbs `pr`t`kf`r bjugagr okf` o prprbo r`juagfor fbstbkjubu'
Ko cgd` outrg gat`rkgtbvg g ko s`r ch`jgr gcokcauso f` qu` g Bang+ \rocurgforg t`ktg a`vgr g `rro o r+Muzo! go bkt`rpr`tgr go s`u d`a prgz`r korng r`juagn`ktgr foNbkbstrbo fo Vrgdgaho+
O r`qu`rbfo ko qu`r gqub suj`rbr qu` o `npr`jgfoGf`asok norgvg `n un pgagc`t`' K`n n`sno o r`qu`rbfo! suposto jrgkf`agtbiukfbrbo ngaibco cono qu`r bnpabcgr g foutg r`pr`s`ktgkt` foN\V! vbv` `n cokfb`s n`ahor`s fo qu` gs qu` tbkhgn o s`u `npr`jgfo+O igto qu`! n`sno ko pof`kfo s` gibrngr qu` o `npr`jgfo vbvbg conoun r`b! ko s` pof` fbz`r qu` `a` vbvbg `n cokfb`s f`sungkgs ouf`jrgfgkt`s'
Fgtg g nxbng v`kbg! quga g f`sungkbfgf` `n s`proporcbokgr ung cgsg! qu` gp`sgr f` ko s`r jrgkf` ` ko t`r
r`v`stbn`kto f` gzua`mo fo cho go t`to t`n auz `atrbcg! jug`kcgkgfg! iojo g js! pgrgdabcg ` VY g cor`s ` j`agf`brg? Org NN+Mubz s` trgtg f` norgfbg rurga `! portgkto `sp`rgfo qu` tga bnv`a
s`mg rstbco+ Coktufo! `xbst` un v`rfgf`bro pr`cbpcbo `ktr` s`rrstbco ` s`r bkgdbtv`a'
G fbjkg r`pr`s`ktgkt` fo N\V r`p`t` por fbv`rsgsv`z`s qu` ko hgvbg cgng ou grnrbos! cono s` g KT 37 `xbjbss` tgbs
HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+con
Ygf`n`cun+okabk`Ljngba+con
7/23/2019 Contestao Ao Civil Pblica
19/33
G n`ahor tckbcg murfbcg go s`u gacgkc`+ HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+conr`qubsbtos' Gabs! cunpr` sgab`ktgr qu` g r`g okf` `st aocgabzgfg gigz`kfg grr`kfgfg p`ao r`qu`rbfo p`rn`gfg por p`qu`kgs proprb`fgf`stofgs `n `qubvga`kt`s cokfb`s+ So proprb`fgf`s sbnpa`s! connorgfbgs sbnpa`s! j`rgan`kt` ngk`mgfgs p`ags prprbgs ignabgs+ Os`khor Gf`asok ko norgvg `n cokfb`s pbor`s qu` gs f`ngbs ignabgsproprb`trbgs fg r`jbo! ko `xbstbkfo k`n f` aokj` g to i`st`mgfgr`p`rcusso fo igto sust`ktgfg p`ao N\V+
Igatg con g v`rfgf` g Bang+ \rocurgforg g t`ktgrbnpbkjbr go r`qu`rbfo g bngj`n f` jrgkf` agtbiukfbrbo! vbao fgsocb`fgf`! `xpaorgfor fg gtbvbfgf` p`curbg'
N`sno qu`! gdsurfgn`kt` s` gfnbtbss`! qu` gajuksfos r`qubsbtos coktbfos kg KT 37 ko iorgn cunprbfos gf`qugfgn`kt`p`ao r`qu`rbfo! g STV@/@S pof`rbg t`r gpabcgfo sgko gfnbkbstrgtbvg!
f` gcorfo con o grtbjo 4
7/23/2019 Contestao Ao Civil Pblica
20/33
G n`ahor tckbcg murfbcg go s`u gacgkc`+ HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+con
C`rtgn`kt` houv` brr`juagrbfgf`s! igatg f` r`jbstrofg CV\S! ngs kgfg qu` ko t`khg sbfo r`soavbfo ko `kto fo r`torko fo`npr`jgfo pgrg o s`u aocga f` orbj`n+ Gabs! tgbs proda`ngs pof`rbgns`r sgkgfos por n`bo f` r`cagngo trgdgahbstg! o qu` ko iob
k`c`ssrbo f`vbfo go prokto gt`kfbn`kto f` tofgs gs provbf`kcbgs`xbjbfgs p`ag STV@+
Fos igtos kgrrgfos ` conprovgfos ko s` `xtrgb`a`n`ktos pgrg g conprovgo f` trgdgaho f`jrgfgkt`+ G norgfbgocupgfg p`ao vgqu`bro Gf`asok! gp`sgr f` rstbcg! `st aokj` f`cokibjurgr o suposto trgtgn`kto f`jrgfgkt` ou f` giroktg go prbkcpbofg fbjkbfgf` hungkg+ O `kto prbn`bro ` kbco `npr`jgfo fo r`qu`rbfo`rg vgqu`bro ` f`stg i`btg `x`rcbg o s`u trgdgaho go gr abvr` ` s`nbnposbo f` morkgfg+
Ko h f` s` igagr `n igatg f` s`jurgkg ou n`snof` igatg f` cokfb`s f` hbjb`k`! ko pgssgkfo g pr`s`kt` bkbcbgtbvgfo Nbkbstrbo \dabco f` gtbtuf` r`vgkchbstg gkt` g r`cusg fo
r`qu`rbfo ko r`c`dbn`kto f` kotbibcgo pgrg gssbkgturg f` VGC! qu` s`op`rou ngbs por igatg f` bkstruo fo qu` por qugaqu`r outrg cobsg+
Gabs! o V`rno f` gmustgn`kto f` Cokfutg ko pgssgf` bkstrun`kto f` qu` s` vga` o Nbkbstrbo \dabco pgrg f`t`rnbkgr gr`pgrgo bkt`jrga fo fgko! sod p`kg f` `x`cuo! ung v`z qu` s` trgtg
f` ttuao `x`cutbvo+ Gssbn! por n`bo f` VGC o bkt`r`ssgfo iorngabzg!`spoktgk`gn`kt`! sug bkt`ko f` r`pgrgr bkt`jrgan`kt` o fgko cgusgfopor `a`+
O r`qu`rbfo m hgvbg cunprbfo tofgs gs `xbjkcbgsfg STV@/@S r`pgrgkfo conpa`tgn`kt` os `v`ktugbs fgkos trgdgahbstgssoirbfos p`ao `npr`jgfo Gf`asok+ O fgko norga gajo p`rsokgassbno `s` ko iob grjbfo p`ao `npr`jgfo ko cgd` go Nbkbstrbo \dabcof`i`kf`r fbr`bto bkfbvbfuga f` cbfgfo pa`kgn`kt` bf`ktbibcv`a+ S``st` ko r`corr`u Ygrg fo Vrgdgaho pgrg pa`bt`gr r`ssgrcbn`kto porfgkos norgbs! c`rtgn`kt` porqu` ko soir`u k`khun fgko f`stgkgtur`zg+
HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+con
Ygf`n`cun+okabk`Ljngba+con
7/23/2019 Contestao Ao Civil Pblica
21/33
G n`ahor tckbcg murfbcg go s`u gacgkc`+ HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+con
: Fg bkocorrkcbg fo fgko norga coa`tbvo
O gutor pa`bt`bg g r`pgrgo f` fgkos norgbscoa`tbvos! gkt` g supostg cokfutg fo r`qu`rbfo qu` pof`rbg`kqugfrgr.s` `n bnpor go s`u KBCO trgdgahgfor cokfb`sf`jrgfgkt`s+ Gibrng qu` ung v`z qu` f`sod`f`c`u g a`jbsago
p`rtbk`kt` s`jurgkg ` n`fbcbkg fo trgdgaho! o fgko coa`tbvo`xbst` f`p`r sb `! portgkto f`v`r s`r r`ssgrcbfo! ung v`z qu`tofg g coa`tbvbfgf` iob gdgagfg+
G Bang+ \rocurgforg gfuz qu`! hgv`kfo gjr`ssogos fbr`btos ` jgrgktbgs iukfgn`ktgbs! g cokfutg fo r`qu`rbfof`v`r s`r iort`n`kt` pukbfg por n`bo f` bnposbo p`cukbrbg+
Cono m ga`jgfo ko s` trgtg f` cgso f`trgdgaho `scrgvo ou f`jrgfgkt`+ G norgfbg ocupgfg p`aotrgdgahgfor Gf`asok `rg rstbcg! ngs ko s` pof`! s`qu`rbksbkugr! g `xbstkcbg f` cokfb`s f`sungkgs ou f`jrgfgkt`s!qugkto n`kos igatg f` s`jurgkg fo trgdgaho+
O `kto `npr`jgfo fo r`qu`rbfo! S`khorGf`asok! `rg vgqu`bro `n ung p`qu`kg ja`dg f` t`rrgs! `trgdgahgvg! cono f` kgtur`zg fg prprbg gtbvbfgf`! go gr abvr`ko ngk`mo fo jgfo+ G p`qu`kg proprb`fgf` grr`kfgfg p`aor`qu`rbfo `st sbtugfg `n aocga okf` `xbst`n outrgs fbv`rsgs
p`qu`kgs proprb`fgf`s `n bjuga sbtugo+
Cono conun kg ngborbg fgs proprb`fgf`s f`\orto D`ao! `stgs so ngk`mgfgs p`ags prprbgs ignabgsr`sbf`kt`s! ` son`kt` `n ung ou outrg `xbst` g coktrgtgo!qugkfo nubto f` gp`kgs un! `npr`jgfo+ So proprb`fgf`snof`stgs! ocupgfgs por p`qu`kos p`cugrbstgs con pouco pof`rgqubsbtbvo ` fotgfos f` poucg bkstruo! okf` gs norgfbgs so
HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+con
Ygf`n`cun+okabk`Ljngba+con
7/23/2019 Contestao Ao Civil Pblica
22/33
G n`ahor tckbcg murfbcg go s`u gacgkc`+ HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+contofgs rstbcgs! ko bnpabcgkfo! coktufo `n gndb`kt` f`f`jrgfgo ou f` p`rbjo bnbk`kt`+
O prprbo r`qu`rbfo norg `n r`sbfkcbg d`npgr`cbfg con gqu`ag qu` `rg ocupgfg p`ao s`u `npr`jgfo'
K`n f` aokj` houv` g r`p`rcusso to i`st`mgfg
p`ao Nbkbstrbo \dabco fo Vrgdgaho kg pr`s`kt` Go Cbvba\dabcg+ Ko hgvbg trgdgaho f`jrgfgkt`' Ko hgvbg trgdgaho`scrgvo' Ko hgvbg rbsco bnbk`kt` coktrg g vbfg fo `npr`jgfo `f` sug ignabg'
\grg qu` s` baustr` o gdsurfo g qu` ch`jg gga`jgo fo Nbkbstrbo \dabco! conprovg.s` qu` o supostocgs`dr` cgbkfo gos p`fgos okf` r`sbfbg o `npr`jgfo `rg fotgfo
f` dgkh`bro! jug `kcgkgfg! j`agf`brg! iojo g js ` VY gcor`s con pgrgdabcg' Fgtg nxbng v`kbg `xbst`n vrbgsignabgs norgkfo bkcausbv` kgs cbfgf`s qu` possu`n n`kosigcbabfgf`s qu` tbkhg o `npr`jgfo! ` k`n por bsso pof`.s`coksbf`rgr qu` nor`n `n aocga f`jrgfgkt`+
H f` s` fbi`r`kcbgr auxo f` k`c`ssbfgf` `gbkfg! coksbf`rgr g gf`qugo fgs `xbjkcbgs go aocga ` ggtbvbfgf` `x`rcbfg+ Norgfbgs rurgbs so rstbcgs por kgtur`zg!o qu` ko gutorbzg g pr`suko f` igatg f` cokfb`s f`hgdbtgdbabfgf`+
Vo f`jrgfgkt``rg g sbtugo fo `npr`jgfo!qu` o r`qu`rbfo gutorbzgvg qu` `st` ibz`ss` gs conprgs kon`rcgfo f` \orto D`ao! h 7< En fg igz`kfg! ` provbf`kcbgvg g`ktr`jg fgs n`rcgforbgs+ G gssbkgturg ou ko f` r`cbdo oupronbssrbg `rg i`btg por `xbjkcbg fo foko fo n`rcgfo ` kop`ao r`qu`rbfo+ O `npr`jgfo Gf`asok conprgvg o qu` qu`rbg `qugkfo qu`rbg+
HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+con
Ygf`n`cun+okabk`Ljngba+con
7/23/2019 Contestao Ao Civil Pblica
23/33
G n`ahor tckbcg murfbcg go s`u gacgkc`+ HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+con
G pr`s`kt` go trgtg.s`! go coktrrbo fo qu`pr`t`kf` conprovgr o Nbkbstrbo \dabco! f` bkbcbgtbvg bkfbtg!qu` f`v` s`r r`c`dbfg con nubtg r`s`rvg p`ao Muajgfor! g ibn f`s` `vbtgr o `svgzbgn`kto fg Go Cbvba \dabcg+
\grg qu` s` gfnbtg g cokf`kgo por fgkos
norgbs p`ao sbnpa`s f`scunprbn`kto f` a`jbsago trgdgahbstg! k`c`ssrbo qu` `xbstg go n`kos ung paurgabfgf` f`trgdgahgfor`sf` nofo qu` possg cgusgr `i`tbvgn`kt` un bnpgctokg socb`fgf`+ k`st` s`ktbfo gs murbsprufkcbgs `a`kcgfgs p`aoprprbo N\V! ung v`z qu` VOFGS @AGS v`rsgn sodr` coktrgtgobrr`juagr ou trgdgaho `scrgvo f` vrbos trgdgahgfor`s+
KO @XBSV@ WPGAWP@T OPVTO \T@C@F@KV@ F@SV@VB\O F@ CGSO! okf` o Nbkbstrbo \dabco gssun` g f`i`sg fgsocb`fgf` gkt` g cokfutg f` un `npr`jgfor fbgkt` PN @N\T@JGFO
KBCO+ @n tofos os cgsos `n qu` o N\V pa`bt`bg bkf`kbzgo porfgkos norgbs cgusgfos coa`tbvbfgf`! `xbstbg ung paurgabfgf` f``npr`jgfos+
\grg baustrgr g kovbfgf` fg pr`s`kt` go!v`mgnos gs murbsprufkcbgs coksbf`rgfgs gkaojgs muktgfgs p`aoprprbo N\V=
Muajgfo `xgrgfo kos gutos fo \roc`sso YV \\ 4:9/4
7/23/2019 Contestao Ao Civil Pblica
24/33
G n`ahor tckbcg murfbcg go s`u gacgkc`+ HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+conproprb`fgf` fo prprbo pgtro! qu` ibcgvg ko ibkga contofo o sgarbo fos `npr`jgfos+
Muajgfo `xgrgfo ko proc`sso :38:76/4
7/23/2019 Contestao Ao Civil Pblica
25/33
G n`ahor tckbcg murfbcg go s`u gacgkc`+ HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+cona`sgfos cgusg ung r`puasg tga kg socb`fgf` qu` n`r`c` s`rr`ssgrcbfg+
Ko h k`khun r`jbstro f` cgso gkaojo go for`qu`rbfo! okf` ko `xbst` ung paurgabfgf` f` trgdgahgfor`s
`kvoavbfg! k`n qu` s`mg f` iorng pot`kcbga+ Ko cgso `n t`ag! ko`xbst` a`so pot`kcbga! pobs ko `xbst`n trgdgahgfor`s `n
pot`kcbga+ Cono m fbto bkn`rgs v`z`s! trgtg.s` f`p`qu`kg proprb`fgf` ` o r`qu`rbfo gt o pr`s`kt` non`ktoson`kt` t`v` PN @N\T@JGFO+
Hbpot`tbcgn`kt`! s`jukfo g t`orbg `xtr`ng foNbkbstrbo \dabco fo Vrgdgaho f`i`kfbfg ko pr`s`kt` proc`sso! gsocb`fgf` s`rbg a`sgfg! por `x`npao! ko proc`sso
7/23/2019 Contestao Ao Civil Pblica
26/33
G n`ahor tckbcg murfbcg go s`u gacgkc`+ HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+confo ns s`jubkt`! pr`stgr s`rvbos n`sng `npr`sg! por pr`oukbtrbo ` s`n os `kcgrjos socbgbs f` prgx`++ O prbkcpbo fgrgzogdbabfgf` bkfuz! k`ss`s cgsos! pr`suko fg irguf`+
M ko cgso `n t`ag! ko rgzov`a suporqu` un `npr`jgfo qu` tbkhg `n sug norgfbg VY con gkt`kgpgrgdabcg! jug `kcgkgfg! dgkh`bro! j`agf`brg! iojo gjs! auz `atrbcg! vbvbg `n sbtugo f`jrgfgkt` `f`sungkg+
N`kos rgzov`a gbkfg s`rbg gfnbtbr gbkt`rv`ko fo Nbkbstrbo \dabco g cgfg r`cagngo trgdgahbstgokf` o `npr`jgfo ga`jg! vbg f` r`jrg! bkirbkjkcbg f` s`usfbr`btos trgdgahbstgs! bkfbspokv`bs por kgtur`zg+
Gssbn s`kfo! bkcgdv`a qugaqu`r cokf`kgo gttuao f` fgko norga coa`tbvo! pobs `st` ko ocorr`u! s`mgporqu` ko houv` a`so coa`tbvbfgf`! ou porqu` o `npr`jgfo for`qu`rbfo ko `x`rcbg s`u trgdgaho `n aocga bksgaudr` `f`sungko! ou f`vbfo go igto f` ko `xbstbr ung coa`tbvbfgf` f``npr`jgfos `n pot`kcbga+
8 Fo Wugktun pa`bt`gfo g ttuao f` fgko norga coa`tbvo
G f`sp`bto f` tofg g grjun`ktgo gt gjorgr`gabzgfg! cgso s`mg fo `kt`kfbn`kto f` Yossg @xc`akcbg s`rcgdv`a g cokf`kgo fo r`qu`rbfo go pgjgn`kto f` qugaqu`rqugktbg g ttuao f` r`pgrgo por fgkos norgbs coa`tbvos! f`v`.
s` irbsgr qu` o vgaor pa`bt`gfo gdsoautgn`kt` brr`ga gkt`
os igtos kgrrgfos+
@n tofos os muajgfos okf` houv` g cokf`kgof` `npr`jgfor`s por fgkos norgbs coa`tbvos f`corr`kt`s f`bacbtos trgdgahbstgs con`tbfos coktrg ung COA@VBYBFGF@ f`trgdgahgfor`s! houv` ung proporcbokgabfgf` `ktr` g cgpgcbfgf`ibkgkc`brg ` os fgkos `i`tbvgn`kt` cgusgfos+
HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+con
Ygf`n`cun+okabk`Ljngba+con
7/23/2019 Contestao Ao Civil Pblica
27/33
G n`ahor tckbcg murfbcg go s`u gacgkc`+ HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+conKg ibxgo fos fgkos norgbs coa`tbvos! o
Muajgfor f`v` a`vgr `n coksbf`rgo o pgssgfo fg `npr`sg! o s`uhbstrbco f` r`bkcbfkcbg! g sug cgpgcbfgf` ibkgkc`brg! f`ktr`outros igtor`s+
Ko gcrfo `xgrgfo ko TOttuao f` fgkos norgbs coa`tbvos f`corr`kt`s f` gcbf`kt` f`trgdgaho igtga ocorrbfo `n sugs f`p`kfkcbgs! tgndn por igatgf` ods`rvkcbg fgs korngs f` hbjb`k` ` n`fbcbkg fo trgdgaho+
Ko prprbo muajgfo cbtgfo p`ag procurgforg foVrgdgaho s ias+ 49.4:! g s`kt`kg proi`rbfg p`ao NN+ Mubz fgYgrg fo Vrgdgaho f` \grgup`dgs/\G! okf` s`jukfo o gcrfo f`
bkt`bro t`or! kg Igz`kfg Dgkf`brgkt` iorgn `kcoktrgfos fbv`rsos
HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+con
Ygf`n`cun+okabk`Ljngba+con
7/23/2019 Contestao Ao Civil Pblica
28/33
G n`ahor tckbcg murfbcg go s`u gacgkc`+ HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+contrgdgahgfor`s `n sbtugo brr`juagr! sum`btos bnposbo f` trgdgaho f`jrgfgkt` `
iorgfo! kg n`fbfg `n qu`! os trgdgahgfor`s! `rgn r`fuzbfos ` `xpostos cokfb`s
f` trgdgaho sud hungko! s`n possbdbabfgf` f` fbspor fo fbr`bto f` br ` vbr! pobs o
`npr`jgfor ngktbkhg.os gtr`agfos sug gtbvbfgf` `coknbcg! ` g s`u mujo! `n
f`corrkcbg f` fvbfgs bkt`rnbkv`bs! r`agtbvgs supostgs f`sp`sgs f` hosp`fgj`n!
gabn`ktgo! trgksport` ` outros jk ros qu` conprgvgn kg cgktbkg fo ru+! g`npr`sg r iob cokf`kgfg go pgjgn`kto fg qugktbg f` T& 9
7/23/2019 Contestao Ao Civil Pblica
29/33
G n`ahor tckbcg murfbcg go s`u gacgkc`+ HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+con
BN\PJKGKFO OS \@FBFOS
7+ Vut`ag bkbdbtrbg= Cono gfnbtbfo p`ag\rocurgforg `n sug bkbcbga! tofos gs brr`juagrbfgf`s ocorrbfgskg coktrgtgo fo `npr`jgfo iorgn sgkgfgs+ Ko `xbst`n outros`npr`jgfos kg p`qu`kg proprb`fgf` grr`kfgfg ` ko h bkfcbos ou
prodgdbabfgf` f` r`bkcbfkcbg+Cono m conprovgfo! o r`qu`rbfo p`qu`ko
grr`kfgtrbo f` t`rrg ` ko k`c`ssgrbgn`kt` pr`cbsg f``npr`jgfos pgrg `x`rc`r g sug gtbvbfgf` rurga f` kgtur`zgignbabgr+
4+ Fg tut`ag gkt`cbpgfg
\grg qu` s`mg f`i`rbfg g tut`ag gkt`cbpgfg s`igz k`c`ssrbg g conprovgo fos r`qubsbtos pgrg g sugcokc`sso! s`mgn `a`s!p`rbcuaun bk norg ` iunus dokb burbs! qu`ko `sto pr`s`kt`s ko cgso+
Ko `xbst`n outros `npr`jgfos kg p`qu`kgproprb`fgf`+ O `npr`jgfo Gf`asok iob o \TBN@BTO @ KBCO`npr`jgfo coktrgtgfo p`ao r`qu`rbfo+
Gssbn! cono ko `xbst`n `npr`jgfos g s`r`nd`k`ibcbgfos con gs n`fbfgs pa`bt`gfgs! s`mgn `a`s gtugbs oupot`kcbgbs ` ung v`z qu` tofos gs brr`juagrbfgf`s r`i`r`kt`s coktrgtgo fo vgqu`bro Gf`asok iorgn f`vbfgn`kt` sgkgfgs!
f`scgdbfg g tut`ag gkt`cbpgfg pgrg cokc`sso fg tut`agbkbdbtrbg+
Bnpujkgkfo `sp`cbibcgn`kt` os p`fbfos f`tut`ag gkt`cbpgtrbg=
HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+con
Ygf`n`cun+okabk`Ljngba+con
7/23/2019 Contestao Ao Civil Pblica
30/33
G n`ahor tckbcg murfbcg go s`u gacgkc`+ HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+con7" T@GAB]GT GKOVGO FGS CV\S= BKF@YBFO+ Ko`xbst n trgdgahgfor`s gtugbs ou pot`kcbgbs g s r`n
d`k`ibcbgfos con g n`fbfg pa`bt`gfg! p`ao qu` s` nostrg
bkcug ` gt`ktgtrbg go prbkcpbo fg `cokonbg proc`ssuga
4" @I@VPGT O T@JBSVTO F@ VOFOS OS S@PSVTGDGAHGFOT@S @N ABYTO! IBCHGS OP SBSV@NG
@A@VTKBCO @N COKIOTNBFGF@ CON O GTVBJO 67FG CAV= BKF@YBFO+ Ko `xbst`n trgdgahgfor s gtugbs oupot`kcbgbs g s`r`n d`k`ibcbgfos con g n`fbfg pa`bt`gfg!
p`ao qu` s` nostrg bkcug ` gt`ktgtrbg go prbkcpbo fg
`cokonbg proc`ssuga
3" \GJGT OS SGATBOS F@ VOFOS OS S@PS@N\T@JGFOS GV O WPBKVO FBG VBA FO NSSPDS@WP@KV@ GO Y@KCBFO! KG IOTNG FO GTVBJO602! 7 FG CAV! IOTK@C@KFO T@CBDO GSSBKGFO @
FGVGFO \@AO \T\TBO @N\T@JGFO= BKF@YBFO+ Ko`xbst n trgdgahgfor`s gtugbs ou pot`kcbgbs g s r`n
d`k`ibcbgfos con g n`fbfg pa`bt`gfg! p`ao qu` s` nostrg
bkcug ` gt`ktgtrbg go prbkcpbo fg `cokonbg proc`ssuga
6" GDSV@T.S@ F@ T@V@T! \GTCBGA OP VOVGAN@KV@ O\GJGN@KVO SGAGTBGA F@ S@PS @N\T@JGFOS=BKF@YBFO+ Ko `xbst`n trgdgahgfor`s gtugbs ou pot`kcbgbs g
s`r`n d`k`ibcbgfos con g n`fbfg pa`bt`gfg! p`ao qu` s`nostrg bkcug ` gt`ktgtrbg go prbkcpbo fg `cokonbg
proc`ssuga
0" @I@VPGT F@\SBVOS N@KSGBS G VVPAO F@ IJVS@N COKVG YBKCPAGFG FO VTGDGAHGFOT! D@NCONO T@COAH@T O IJVS T@SCBSTBO WPGKFO
HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+con
Ygf`n`cun+okabk`Ljngba+con
7/23/2019 Contestao Ao Civil Pblica
31/33
G n`ahor tckbcg murfbcg go s`u gacgkc`+ HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+conF@YBFO! KG FGVG @ IOTNG @SVB\PAGFG \@AG A@B8+
7/23/2019 Contestao Ao Civil Pblica
32/33
G n`ahor tckbcg murfbcg go s`u gacgkc`+ HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+conG norgfbg gt `kto f`stbkgfg go `npr`jgfo Gf`asok
cunpr` tofos os r`qubsbtos fo bt`n 37+43+77 fg KT 37+
3 Fg tut`ag f`ibkbtbvg
Bnpujkgkfo o p`fbfo f` tut`ag f`ibkbtbvg=
7" \roc`fkcbg fo p`fbfo iornuagfo kg go
cbvba pdabcg ` cokf`kgo ko pgjgn`kto f`bkf`kbzgo por fgko norga ko vgaor f` T&0
d"Cgso ko s`mg gcoahbfo g gak`g g fo pr`s`kt`p`fbfo! r`qu`r g BN\TOC@FKCBG VOVGA fgpr`s`kt` GO CBYBA \DABCG+
\rot`stg o r`qu`rbfo por tofos os n`bos f`provgs `n fbr`bto gfnbtbfgs! kotgfgn`kt` provgs t`st`nukhgbs!
HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+con
Ygf`n`cun+okabk`Ljngba+con
7/23/2019 Contestao Ao Civil Pblica
33/33
G n`ahor tckbcg murfbcg go s`u gacgkc`+ HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+conmuktgfg f` kovos focun`ktos! `xgn`s p`rbcbgbs! vbstorbgbs! ` f`tofgs gs outrgs qu` s` ibz`r`n k`c`ssrbgs+
V`rnos `n qu`!
\`f` f`i`rbn`kto+
HVV\=//vgf`n`cunmurbfbco+daojspot+con